Open 688: Diffusion of Power (Game Over)

[Almost50]

VC 3.09

Navy

(4): NJAC, Titus, Vedith, Mathblade,

Mathblade

(2): itlepip, Kelvin Smith,

Agent Sparkles

(1): NotTheRealPaul,

Titus

(1): RadiantCowbells,

Not Voting

(2): Navy, alban,
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
*Still looking for a Navy replacement unless she come back before one is found

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-07-07 21:50:00)

[Vedith]

I saw that.

Then I refuse to vote Titus before a Math flip.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Mathblade

[Titus]

Aww sorry about your cop clear honey but in case you hadn't forgotten this is the strategy that you stole from me

Just vote Math. Math will flip town.

We can lynch you and Navy then.

Then, we can find the last scum who is probably NJAC.

[Kelvin Smith]

Alban just revealed his scumminess in trying to defend Kelvin. Alban tore Kelvin's case apart yet doesn't actually say why I would be a good lynch. So Navy, Kelvin, Alban?

That's a pretty terrible argument. If alban was scum and you were not, then he could have placed his vote on you there when he said you could still be a good lynch. In fact, what he's done is shown himself to be amenable to reason, as the part of the case he found most compelling was the strategic part, not the part based on some fucking idiot's (me) personal read.

Also, he failed to tear my case apart, because it's still an incredibly solid case. Regardless of the fact that reads are unreliable and should not be used as the primary basis for lynch decisions, none of his points were actually reasons my read is inaccurate. Furthermore, he didn't counter the strategic reasons that mislynching you wouldn't matter. First, he just pointed out that numbers are important, which is true no matter what mislynch we make (and with a 7/3 ratio, we have greater than 50% chance of a mislynch). Then, he expressed concern that he might not be comfortable lynching town to confirm other town, which is fair, but risk vs. reward is an important part of Mafia and you are the lowest risk with the greatest reward. Finally, he expressed why the tunneling issue is more of a personal problem for me than something that helps everyone. While that part is partially true, it ignores the impact that having tunneled players can have on everyone else, both directly and indirectly.

[Vedith]

I'm also not voting outside of the docs.
If Titus/Math are scum, so is Navy.
Even if not, Navy is scum.

[Titus]

Might be itlepip but probably NJAC.

[MathBlade]

I saw that.

You want to fight? I'm cop cleared honey. You could try to buddy Kelvin harder man.

Navy's posting elsewhere. They aren't posting here because they are scum.

@Math, I don't think you have a single scum in your pool.

Error: Navy Alban Kelvin = scumpool
Error: Navy cannot be scum and not scum at the same time
Error: RC is voting cop clear
Error: The entire game of mafia is reads.
Error Overflow Exception Math too confused by bullshit.

[RadiantCowbells]

If I die tonight everyone is voting Titus tomorrow.
You're not going to say shit about how Math and Titus wouldn't have done this because I was the one who came up with the play that they're doing in 685 with Titus.

Just vote Math. Math will flip town.

Sure, honey

[Titus]

If I die tonight everyone is voting Titus tomorrow.
You're not going to say shit about how Math and Titus wouldn't have done this because I was the one who came up with the play that they're doing in 685 with Titus.

Just vote Math. Math will flip town.

Sure, honey

685 was a game where I faked a cop guilty on my partner. Math has an innocent. So that doesn't work and even if we fail to lynch scum!Navy, you'll be shown to be full of shit.

@Math, I didn't realize you had Navy in there. Brain fart on my end.

[Kelvin Smith]

If Titus/Math are scum, so is Navy.
Even if not, Navy is scum.

Please explain both of these statements.

[Vedith]

Please explain both of these statements.

What do you not understand with it?
Navy is scum regardless of anyone else.

[MathBlade]

Error Math also suffers from lag.

Error Kelvin is trying anything possible to avoid lynching Navy at this point.

We should like do something about my error log people.

[Titus]

Navy (4): NJAC, Titus, Vedith, Mathblade,
Mathblade (2): itlepip, Kelvin Smith, Radiant Cowbells
Agent Sparkles (1): NotTheRealPaul,


Not Voting (2): Navy, alban,

Ok, so we need NTRP and alban to get a scum lynch off today and solve the game by PoE. I wonder why there's so much resistance to lynching a lurker slot.

[Kelvin Smith]

Error: The entire game of mafia is reads.

I mean, if you play it poorly, it is.

[RadiantCowbells]

If I die tonight everyone is voting Titus tomorrow.
You're not going to say shit about how Math and Titus wouldn't have done this because I was the one who came up with the play that they're doing in 685 with Titus.

Just vote Math. Math will flip town.

Sure, honey

685 was a game where I faked a cop guilty on my partner. Math has an innocent. So that doesn't work and even if we fail to lynch scum!Navy, you'll be shown to be full of shit.

@Math, I didn't realize you had Navy in there. Brain fart on my end.

OH NO BULLSHIT THE ORIGINAL PLAN WAS FOR YOU TO INNO ME.
YOU ARE NOT ACTUALLY GOING TO LIE BECAUSE THE SCUM TOPIC NEVER GOT RELEASED.

[Titus]

Error Math also suffers from lag.

Error Kelvin is trying anything possible to avoid lynching Navy at this point.

We should like do something about my error log people.

No. Kelvin is town tunneling on you, which means we have to get every other town to agree to lynch Navy.

[Titus]

If I die tonight everyone is voting Titus tomorrow.
You're not going to say shit about how Math and Titus wouldn't have done this because I was the one who came up with the play that they're doing in 685 with Titus.

Just vote Math. Math will flip town.

Sure, honey

685 was a game where I faked a cop guilty on my partner. Math has an innocent. So that doesn't work and even if we fail to lynch scum!Navy, you'll be shown to be full of shit.

@Math, I didn't realize you had Navy in there. Brain fart on my end.

OH NO BULLSHIT THE ORIGINAL PLAN WAS FOR YOU TO INNO ME.
YOU ARE NOT ACTUALLY GOING TO LIE BECAUSE THE SCUM TOPIC NEVER GOT RELEASED.

We discussed and dismissed several plans over skype. We decided on guiltying you. I have done practically every move as town and as scum. So yeah, most everyone here knows it.

[RadiantCowbells]

Ftr my original suggestion was that she inno me which I still think would have been a fantastic play but she wasn't a fan so this was the play

TITUS IS BLATANTLY LYING. THE ORIGINAL DISCUSSION WE HAD WAS THAT SHE WOULD INNO ME SO PEOPLE WOULD LAY THE FUCK OFF ME. THAT CHANGED TO A GUILTY BECAUSE SHE WASN'T COMFORTABLE INNOING ME.
I DO NOT HAVE SCUM TOPIC BUT I REFERENCED THIS FACT SEVERAL TIMES IN THE POSTGAME OF THE GAME AND TITUS NEVER OBJECTED TO IT THERE.

[Kelvin Smith]

Please explain both of these statements.

What do you not understand with it?
Navy is scum regardless of anyone else.

How is Navy scum? Is it just the posting elsewhere?

[RadiantCowbells]

We discussed and dismissed several plans over skype. We decided on guiltying you. I have done practically every move as town and as scum. So yeah, most everyone here knows it.

Right yeah you're comparing the fact that I came up with the exact same plan in the exact same setup with the exact same execution and you've 'practically done everything'

[RadiantCowbells]

I CLAIM COP WITH A GUILTY ON TITUS. WE ARE LYNCHING IN THE TWO OF US, OR MATHBLADE IF I CAN'T NEGOTIATE A TITUS LYNCH.

[Kelvin Smith]

I'm not trying to buddy you, RC, but you are very quickly becoming my new favorite player. Especially after turning around mirro's slot in that Newbie game. You don't know how relieving it is to finally have somebody else on this Math/Titus train.

[MathBlade]

.......RC As I said earlier I checked Titus because I scumread her a fuck ton each game we play in. She was a policy check for me.

[RadiantCowbells]

.......RC As I said earlier I checked Titus because I scumread her a fuck ton each game we play in. She was a policy check for me.

Good for you.