Mini Normal 1923: BooneyToonz IV - Five Weeks in a Boon END

[Vedith]

Not really, your reads are trash and I don't care about them.

This is a team game Vedith, no need for this anti-town reply. You need to convince eachother of your scum reads (and convince me of yours).

I gave you guys Scum.
If you take it that's up to you.

[Keyser Söze]

Madame, care to dance? Clearly I do not understand what you have been upto so far this game. Elaborate. Explain. Illuminate this refined playstyle of yours.

If you're asking for a readslist with delightful colors and an emotional outlay of soul and passion, sorry no. Currently I am only analysing and talking through points that I find suspicious/challenging.

Right now I want to talk about your strongest scum reads (excluding me).

[Keyser Söze]

VOTE: Vedith

In the game we just finished together your behaviour on replace-in was completely different from what it was this game.

Interestingly, what was the climate of that game from the moment Vedith replaced in? Moreover, how would you describe town-Vedith? Was Vedith as bold/brash/confident in that game too?

[Keyser Söze]

Tchill and DeasVail both feel like theyre not pushing an agenda. Not passionately at least, and it doesnt feel like theyre trying to figure things out.

I have similar mild concerns with DaesVail but I feel it could simply stem from low-activity paranoia. DaesVail needs to post. His ISO only has his strong counter-attack on Mulch. This information would only get interesting upon a Mulch flip which I doubt will happen today.

[Vecna]

viewtopic.php?f=23&t=71931

Read this, and compare Vedith to this game. Im interested to see how you feel about the differences and similarities. Yes the context is obviously different since this game is much more in the early stages, but the difference in tone is quite large.

[Vecna]

VOTE: Keyser soze

But, youre still my #1 scumread. And you shall stay that way untill you convince me otherwise.

[Vedith]

V/LA over the weekend! Have fun all! \o/

[Keyser Söze]

viewtopic.php?f=23&t=71931

Read this, and compare Vedith to this game. Im interested to see how you feel about the differences and similarities. Yes the context is obviously different since this game is much more in the early stages, but the difference in tone is quite large.

Please can you share with me (preferably in clear bulletpoint form) the meta/tonal differences. I don't have the time to read that game right now.

[Sergtacos]

VOTE: Fykus

His tone in this game sounds like "what a drag, I'm scum again" idk, maybe thats just me? Mulch, Tchill, Klazam, your opinion?

This isn't right at all

If you were in my previous game you would understand. Which is why I asked Mulch, Tchill and Klazam.

[Sergtacos]

I think Mulch is strong town now.

Why exactly?

Because he simply said he isn't scum.

That's not a towntell!

Was being funny and sarcastic? I don't think he's town, hence my vote on him.

[Sergtacos]

No!!!!!!!!

I'm officially telling you to stop this. It was cute early. Now it's obnoxious.

'

No!!!!!!!!

[Gamma Emerald]

Thats how u catch up, 57 pages like its nothing.

Reads reads reads:

Town:

Vecna
Mulch
Sergtacos

(yes, tacos and mulch are both town and need to stop the dickswinging contest)

Stay Away from my girlfriend

Probably town, but less certain than above group:

Gamma

(but really really only because of the way Geralt replaced out, Gamma's play himself feels very scummy so far and im probably putting too much weight on the cop claim)

Fykus

Scumpool:

Maestro
Creative
Vedith
Klazam
Maestro
Tchill
DeasVail

Most strong scumread:

Keyser Soze

VOTE: Keyser Soze

Some explenations;
Gamma feels really weird. His replace in is done in the exact same way as he did it in EverHope - where he just quotes a buch of posts as well and replies to them very briefly, and in a very detached way. I did my catchup at nearly the same time as he did. Nothing of the vibes he gives of sound familair. Nowhere did I go "oh yeah, I felt the same way about this as he did!". It feels fake. If it wasnt for the way Geralt responded to the cop claim id be all over this and trying to push for a lynch here.....but the response to the vig seemed to genuine, so im gonna have to sit on this for a while longer and think about it.

Klazam feels reasonably different from the last game I had with him. He was an easy read there, that is an easy TOWNread. Here I cannot do the same, he feels far away, like hes playing through the mist. Silly gorrila you.

Mulch, Serge, SAFMGF (dude couldnt you have picked a shorter name?) and to a lesser extent Fykus all felt pretty genuine while catching up. They all made statements that I felt I could get behind, or where I could recognise the reasoning. Not that I agreed with everything they stated, but most of it felt like it came from a good place. Klazam did have a few of these lightbulb-moments as well, but not as many.

Vedith Vedith. Why so aggresive this game? I didnt like Keychain, and I dont like your play so far. Suspicion. I have it for you, in abundance.

Tchill and DeasVail both feel like theyre not pushing an agenda. Not passionately at least, and it doesnt feel like theyre trying to figure things out.

Keyser Soze is basically a worse version of the 2 above. He just appears to be trying to say things that he think will sound good. There is no "soul" to his play. There is no emotion. He doesnt appear to be figuring things out, hes not prodding, he's not passionate about anything. Its just carefull calculation, meant to sound good without drawing any attention to himself so he can stay under the radar for now. This slot is scum, Im convinced of it.

How about you realize

it's how I catch up

. Also you're pinging my bullshit radar because I think I explained it to you in the past. Also, you say TChill and DV arent pushing agendas but have them in your scumpool at the same level as the others?

[Gamma Emerald]

No!!!!!!!!

I'm officially telling you to stop this. It was cute early. Now it's obnoxious.

'

No!!!!!!!!

Please
For my sanity

[Klazam]

MAESTRO

are you intentionally lurking or??? Get in the game.

[Sergtacos]

MAESTRO

are you intentionally lurking or??? Get in the game.

I'll be sad if he replaces out

[Mulch]

I like this new mug

[Mulch]

Prob pocketing me but w/e

[Tchill13]

Hey guys... Let's lynch fykus. I don't really agree with the new guy's reads.

[Mulch]

Tchill your town right

[Tchill13]

Yep.

[Mulch]

What would you say to me locking you into a top town read right now?

[Gamma Emerald]

Mug? What's a mug?

[DeasVail]

Vecna seems pretty town to me.

[DeasVail]

Keyser, why do you think a Mulch flip would not happen today?

Vecna, what do you think of Mulch's points on me specifically, and the criticisms of his slot?

[Mulch]

Vecna seems pretty town to me.

BULLSHIT they are saying I'm obvious town and that your scum and your voting me