Large Normal 207: Theatre Mafia

[Raskolnikov]

VOTE: not known 15

[Not Known 15]

Can you explain why that post is scummy?

Already trying to pocket me, I see

Am I? I am just asking for the reasoning behind that post. This does not mean that I see you as good. We don't have much info yet so something that is supposed to be backed up by unknown info is not particularly helpful.

VOTE: UnaBombaH
Because his response (Post7) feels out of line for me

Why

If Una is town why should they mention - sarcastically - that they are definitely not seeking a fast lynch on Dunker? A fast lynch on someone in this way is usually not good for the town, because this is a team game, "opportunistic" does not make sense, why would they want them to be removed in post 7 when nobody else but one person had said something yet, and that was a vote on Dunker. Why should Una construct this sentence like that as town? I see no reason but that they are evil. Also, it just feels constructed to me. But that's just a feeling.

[Raskolnikov]

Did you consider he might be joking

How do most of the page 1 votes come across to you?

[Not Known 15]

Did you consider he might be joking

How do most of the page 1 votes come across to you?

6 is the first vote, and the first person to post. They can't have any reliable info. But that's ok, someone has to start.
7: I told you.
8: Essentially a naked vote, but that's early voting.
9: Starts a second wagon. With the 4th vote. Interesting pattern, and a bit concerning. Why do we already have 2 wagons there? Acid seems to know well enough that they formed a second wagon(because they state to agree with boon). There is a possibility that we have 1-2 evils in Dunker/Acid just because of this.

10: A bit more than a random vote. Reasoning seems to be that they can't trust them. Sounds ok so far at that stage.
11: My own post. I told you why.
12: And there is the third wagon. On the 7th vote. Unconditional "Fykus town"... why?
Also why did they start yet another wagon? There is definitely something off.
131516:No reasoning given but I would expect one. Last game with them they did it, too, and we were both evil. And it isn't good for town anyway if no one gives any reasoning.
They are in the second place for being voted currently, for me.
18:They find them hard to read, ok.
19:Random.
21:Restarts wagon that stopped when Acid switched to me. Then they accuse someone else in 22 yet don't vote for them. Why?
22: Very strange selfvote. Why would you vote yourself this early? No good reason to but apparently some people do that sometimes. Don't vote yourself as town, especially not that early. I am unable to read that properly.

[Raskolnikov]

My point was that most of the votes aren't serious, but reading them all as serious shows you're consistent in interpretation at least.

Actually okay thoughts on acid vote and dunkerdoodles

[Raskolnikov]

UNVOTE: not known 15

Get the impression this response is writing down what he already thought (genuine) instead of just making up stuff on the spot for defense.

[Mulch]

Wondering if new town or new scum...

[texcat]

Dunk, moz, carca, Fykus are my top early town leans. With carca being the strongest.

I'm not sure whether I should be impressed by your great skill, or ignoring you as full of bs. How could you have town leans this early? Carca has only made 1 post.

[Mulch]

Dunk, moz, carca, Fykus are my top early town leans. With carca being the strongest.

I'm not sure whether I should be impressed by your great skill, or ignoring you as full of bs. How could you have town leans this early? Carca has only made 1 post.

Meta/gut

I’ve played a large number of games with them . It’s not something I can explain, though- any logical explanation would be weak. It’s just something I feel

[mozamis]

Wondering if new town or new scum...

i think NotKnown is new town, he seem skinda earnest and worried about people voting and wagons forming. That kind of worry is hard to fake. Noob scum are normally more jovial and friendly.
Now you finally see my town game Mulch!

[mozamis]

Rask vote and unvote seems town, why would scum unvote that quickly? Rask looks like he has genuinely thought about Notknowns response.

[mozamis]

Moz, Rask, Notknown town

[Mulch]

Many a town have been led to destruction by underestimatinh newb scum.

Moz, mulch, carca townbloc rn

[wavemode]

Everyone who has posted on page 3 is town

Easy enough

[UnaBombaH]

Everyone who has posted on page 3 is town

Easy enough

I better stamp my one-way ticket to townie-land then?

[wavemode]

Sorry that train has sailed

[UnaBombaH]

Sorry that train has sailed

VOTE: Wavemode for false advertising.

[pisskop]

VOTE: boons

[Mulch]

Sorry that train has sailed

Train? Sail?

[wavemode]

Or whatever trains do

I'm not a botanist

[wavemode]

VOTE: pisskop

[Gamma Emerald]

MeowMix has returned and claims their slot!

[mozamis]

Train? Sail?

i first heard that joke here

[mozamis]

VOTE: boons

why?

[Mulch]

P sure rvs