I re-read the first 12 pages and I think stuff gets more NAI from that point on. + I was here already and this messes up my reads greatly.
jodax, beefster, maki
dave, dunn, havo, screenplay
HWS, IMI, wavemode, UCV
tchill
jodax is looking and pushing many things this game, seems genuinely solvey. I don't like how she is defending tchill but I can see how someone townreads a player doing the things he is doing.
beefster has towntell all over his posting. if he is scum, bravo. I explained my townread on him in different ways this game, I'm fine with him up there for now.
maki is mason
dave's posts are good, I can see he is looking into things he believes are possibly alignment indicative. he just doesn't make as much effort to explain it, and deals with people by asking questions etc, but I think he is coming from a towny perspective. in hindsight, I can see his opinion on tchill possible scum motivation in pushing people not on the screen wagon to vote there, and in my first read it is something I missed, so that's cool. I wonder waht the town motivation for tchill is there though.
the more I read the game the more I agree with everything dunn is pushing for. I think his initial wolf team of tchill, UCV and HWS has at least one scum in it. and his town leans are probably all town too, so those are all good things.
screenplay has had some towny posting when reacting to pressure and I think he is also genuinely trying to solve the game. town lean for now.
havo's townread comes mostly from his deathwish and other tonal cues when we were talking with each other.
I think tchill is playing a character this game. this isn't his town game, he is making no effort into solving anything other than cast shade on anyone casting doubt on his slot. it's widely different from his last scum game that I saw, but the fact that the only thing this guy does is aggressive tunnel a bunch of slots doesn't read like genuine town behaviour that's just too 'out there'. it reads like scum pushing town all gameday because he decided to play it like that this time. if tchill is town, well good riddance.
the other 3 I have mostly in a POE;did some scummy stuff;not towny enough yet to lean town as of right now.
I think we should lynch tchill... I know maki isn't with me on this but he does actually read as scum doing an openscumming routine this game.
those are reads.