Mini Normal 1976 - The Firsts - Night 2[End Jan 8]

[Hawk]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

[Hawk]

I don’t understand what you just said

Any argument that starts with.

"If I was scum" is WIFOM. You can sit there and tell me all day about how you would do blah as scum rather than what you have done. It doesn't defend your action it says that the action you have taken is opposite this supposed truth you put on the other side. I suppose it's more of a False Dichotomy than Wifom.

I'm to believe that no matter what as scum you would claim odd night cop instead of even. And not any other possibility. Idk you that well and as scum it's an easy defense to something you've done.

[Mulch]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

A check cannot be fake if you are not fake

[TwoInAMillion]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

[Mulch]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

You feel slimy

[Mulch]

I don’t understand what you just said

Any argument that starts with.

"If I was scum" is WIFOM. You can sit there and tell me all day about how you would do blah as scum rather than what you have done. It doesn't defend your action it says that the action you have taken is opposite this supposed truth you put on the other side. I suppose it's more of a False Dichotomy than Wifom.

I'm to believe that no matter what as scum you would claim odd night cop instead of even. And not any other possibility. Idk you that well and as scum it's an easy defense to something you've done.

Put it this way

I’m about 11-1 as scum in mini normals

If I was scum I would be 1) townread and 2) know odd night cop is a better claim

[TwoInAMillion]

Wow appeal to experience and WIFOM in the same post.

[Mulch]

Wow appeal to experience and WIFOM in the same post.

What the fuck is appeal to experience

Zzz

Ur almost as scummy as acorn

[Hawk]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

Two things.
1. If you're town you don't know his alignment so saying his check would be fake is just furthering a push that he's scum without adding anything.

2. You easily could have just said you're only providing a single possible outcome Mulch that can't be proven. What you said can only be truthful if you're his scum partner cause you know the claim is fake and his check would be fake.

Pedit: that's cool I give no fucks about your record as scum because it doesn't pertain to the case at hand, and 2 your statement still doesn't do anything for your town rep. You could be lying, and as scum saying "If I was scum I would *insert thing here that I'm not doing this game*" is an easy lie to tell.

[TwoInAMillion]

Appeal to Authority, my bad.

Relying overmuch on the arguments of "older, wiser" players (especially when the argument is theoretical rather than based on the facts of the current game) can be a fallacious arguments designed to persuade.

[TwoInAMillion]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

Two things.
1. If you're town you don't know his alignment so saying his check would be fake is just furthering a push that he's scum without adding anything.

2. You easily could have just said you're only providing a single possible outcome Mulch that can't be proven. What you said can only be truthful if you're his scum partner cause you know the claim is fake and his check would be fake.

Pedit: that's cool I give no fucks about your record as scum because it doesn't pertain to the case at hand, and 2 your statement still doesn't do anything for your town rep. You could be lying, and as scum saying "If I was scum I would *insert thing here that I'm not doing this game*" is an easy lie to tell.

I'm 4-3 as town and 2-1 as scum. My wiki page is updated.

[Hawk]

Wow appeal to experience and WIFOM in the same post.

What the fuck is appeal to experience

Zzz

Ur almost as scummy as acorn

It's an arguement from authority basically.


An argument from authority, also called an appeal to authority, or the argumentum ad verecundiam[note 1], is a form of defeasible[4] argument in which a claimed authority's support is used as evidence for an argument's conclusion. It is well known as a fallacy, though it is used in a cogent form when all sides of a discussion agree on the reliability of the authority in the given context.

pulled from Wikipedia. It's basically using your winlose record as scum and your own baseless statement as foundation for your argument that "I would claim odd night rolecop" is true.

[Mulch]

Look at all my scum games.

I’m townread.

I don’t get scumread as scum

It’s very simple logic

[Mulch]

Fallacies are a great way to lose games
Also it’s not a fallacy cause it’s true

[Hawk]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

Two things.
1. If you're town you don't know his alignment so saying his check would be fake is just furthering a push that he's scum without adding anything.

2. You easily could have just said you're only providing a single possible outcome Mulch that can't be proven. What you said can only be truthful if you're his scum partner cause you know the claim is fake and his check would be fake.

Pedit: that's cool I give no fucks about your record as scum because it doesn't pertain to the case at hand, and 2 your statement still doesn't do anything for your town rep. You could be lying, and as scum saying "If I was scum I would *insert thing here that I'm not doing this game*" is an easy lie to tell.

I'm 4-3 as town and 2-1 as scum. My wiki page is updated.

Okay? The pedit was directed at Mulch not you lol. Pedit means I saw a post in my preview so I added that.

[TwoInAMillion]

If scum kill me, then they lose a mislynch the way things are going
If they don’t, I get a cop check

Simple

And it’s not wifom,
I would claim odd night as scum lol

Ok you were quoting my post so my bad.
You mean your fake check where you make up a guilty on someone, they end up being mislyched, and we are in a further hole?

Slander motion to strike from the record.

This is scummy. No reason to even post this as town.

I'm pointing out that Mulch's statements are not factually proven correct. How is that scummy?

Two things.
1. If you're town you don't know his alignment so saying his check would be fake is just furthering a push that he's scum without adding anything.

2. You easily could have just said you're only providing a single possible outcome Mulch that can't be proven. What you said can only be truthful if you're his scum partner cause you know the claim is fake and his check would be fake.

Pedit: that's cool I give no fucks about your record as scum because it doesn't pertain to the case at hand, and 2 your statement still doesn't do anything for your town rep. You could be lying, and as scum saying "If I was scum I would *insert thing here that I'm not doing this game*" is an easy lie to tell.

I'm 4-3 as town and 2-1 as scum. My wiki page is updated.

Okay? The pedit was directed at Mulch not you lol. Pedit means I saw a post in my preview so I added that.

[TwoInAMillion]

Fallacies are a great way to lose games
Also it’s not a fallacy cause it’s true

So you are arguing a winning town strategy is to use as many fallacies as possible?

[Hawk]

Look at all my scum games.

I’m townread.

I don’t get scumread as scum

It’s very simple logic

Gamblers fallacy? just like meta your past results have no bearing on what's actually going on in this game.

[Mulch]

Look at all my scum games.

I’m townread.

I don’t get scumread as scum

It’s very simple logic

Gamblers fallacy? just like meta your past results have no bearing on what's actually going on in this game.

Fallacies are a great way to lose games
Also it’s not a fallacy cause it’s true

So you are arguing a winning town strategy is to use as many fallacies as possible?

What the fuck???

VOTE: 2inamillion

[TwoInAMillion]

You shouldn't blame other people that no one can understand you.

[Hawk]

You shouldn't blame other people that no one can understand you.

Benefit of the doubt and burden of proof asside I'm not convinced that any more or any less of my read on Mulch.

Mulch why are you voting 2iAM? Just give me an idea of the things that he's said that make you think they're scum

[TwoInAMillion]

You shouldn't blame other people that no one can understand you.

Benefit of the doubt and burden of proof asside I'm not convinced that any more or any less of my read on Mulch.

Mulch why are you voting 2iAM? Just give me an idea of the things that he's said that make you think they're scum

It's called OMGUS.

[Hawk]

You shouldn't blame other people that no one can understand you.

Benefit of the doubt and burden of proof asside I'm not convinced that any more or any less of my read on Mulch.

Mulch why are you voting 2iAM? Just give me an idea of the things that he's said that make you think they're scum

It's called OMGUS.

If his only reason is because you're calling him scum it is. Stop answering questions he should be answering. You're literally not gaining anything from this and your idle comments feel like scum edging other people towards bad lynched rather than Town making solid cases against people they think are scum....

[Apple Jack]

Derpy do you think Profil hasn't been trying to dig up scum? What are your thoughts on Bujaber, and RB? You said you could do Psycho are you still feeling 2IAM is town?

No I don’t think he has.
Buja I don’t really have a read on him. He doesn’t worry me so much as others so I can worry about him later.
Rb is useless. If I used meta I’d say he’s scum based on that but since I don’t he’s just null
2iam I could see being scum but don’t like the people who are pushing him so for that he gets a pass from me.

[Sky_Paladin]

I'm only about halfway through page 11 but I've seen enough at this point for
VOTE: Bujaber

More to come.