Rocky Horror Picture Show - players suck, game over

[northsidegal]

I think everyone should vote nancy drew in their next post. Unlikely to have already been recruited, unlikely to be recruited.

If I'm "unlikely to be recruited" then wouldn't that be a wasted vote? Wouldn't it make far more sense to immunize someone who can actually help the "unrecruited" win?

What i meant was that if the cults hadn't already used their recruits, i doubted they would use them on someone who was still yet to post, even if that person was the immunization vote.

also, even just having someone get immunized is more important than making sure the immunization is on someone the cults would want to recruit (not to downplay your skill or anything, you just hadn't posted at all yet)

[Venmar]

man im pretty convincing

[drealmerz7]

IMMUNITY VOTE #1

-

Cerberus v666 - 6 - Srceenplay, Vecna, Creature, mutantdevle, Chickadee, TheGoldenParadox,

Almost50 - 5 - Venmar, Gamma Emerald, northsidegal, Varsoon, Nancy Drew 39,

Chickadee - 2 - Cerberus v666, JaydragonKing,

Gamma Emerald - 2 - Lifthrasil, SnarkySnowman,

Varsoon - 2 - Boonskiies, Porkens,

Nancy Drew 39 - 1 - Almost50,

JaydragonKing - 1 - CheekyTeeky,



-

it currently takes 13 votes on 1 player to attempt to make them immune to recruitment

if I have your vote in the wrong spot please let me know via PM

[Nancy Drew 39]

What i meant was that if the cults hadn't already used their recruits, i doubted they would use them on someone who was still yet to post, even if that person was the immunization vote.

also, even just having someone get immunized is more important than making sure the immunization is on someone the cults would want to recruit (not to downplay your skill or anything, you just hadn't posted at all yet)

OIC, no worries LOL; not even remotely offended.

[Boonskiies]

Damn it, Janet, I love youuuuu.

[Boonskiies]

Also, can we end this phase? I’ll hammer anyone.

[Ms Columbo]

My cold took me out of commission the past 36 hours. Starting to feel human again...

I can get behind an Almost vote:
VOTE: Almost50

[Ms Columbo]

Anyone still up?

[Gamma Emerald]

Anyone still up?

Yeah, hey christi

[Ms Columbo]

Anyone still up?

Yeah, hey christi

So what do you think, should we have one wagon, multiple wagons, does it matter?

[Chickadee]

I think everyone should vote nancy drew in their next post. Unlikely to have already been recruited, unlikely to be recruited.

If I'm "unlikely to be recruited" then wouldn't that be a wasted vote? Wouldn't it make far more sense to immunize someone who can actually help the "unrecruited" win?

Well, another valid strategy for cult leaders would be to start inside the pools of players deemed less likely to be picked.

But if we're trying to guess at this stage, we just open the game up to too much wifom.

[Gamma Emerald]

Anyone still up?

Yeah, hey christi

So what do you think, should we have one wagon, multiple wagons, does it matter?

I think multiple wagons is a good idea

[timewarp]

Can someone tell me who to vote?

[Creature]

VOTE: Almost50

[Creature]

Can someone tell me who to vote?

Choose one wagon with votes.

[Lifthrasil]

Toucha toucha toucha touuuch me.

I wanna be dirty!


I'm back. And I have two questions. One was asked before, but I didn't find an answer to it: what's the deal with these HURT / HEAL tags? The other: what's a virgin in the context of this forum or game?

Moreover: there was some discussion about the winnability of the game from the neutral (town) side. I'm quite sure that drealmer took care of that. Sure, without PRs and with no lynching town would automatically lose. The 'making one person immune' wouldn't help in the long run, since we can expect two conversion attempts per pause. But he already hinted in the signup thread that there will be deaths and we had a softclaim of a vig already. Also there will be more PRs who might be able to kill, protect or investigate. Also, since this is drealmer who's running the game, I also expect that there will be some non-standard PRs who can do all sorts of theme-fitting shenanigans.

So, what I'm trying to say: don't assume too much on Day 1. We don't have much information so all boils down to the usual WIFOM. We try to immunize someone, who we think the CLs might try to recruit. Alternatively we immunize someone who we are reasonably sure is towny, so that his alignment can't change over the pause phase. After the first pause we will probably have more information about this game setup.

[Lifthrasil]

Anyone still up?

Yeah, hey christi

So what do you think, should we have one wagon, multiple wagons, does it matter?

Yes, I think it does matter. I guess for now multiple wagons aren't bad, but eventually we should bring someone to L-1 ... and then immunize someone else. Or not. In any case force the CLs to make a decision or risk wasting their shot and then try to foil that decision.

Therefore, to further the wagon forming stuff:

unvote GammaEmerald
vote Almost50

[JaydragonKing]

Holy shit a new guy talking.

[Creature]

That species should be studied.

[Creature]

Is it alright to use vocaroo in a mafia game?

[Creature]

Would've been fun rn.

[Gamma Emerald]

Is it alright to use vocaroo in a mafia game?

what is it

[Creature]

You can record your own voice there.

[Creature]

The problem is that it's deleted some time later.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd suggest not, someone got in trouble in one of my first games here for making a voice recording as it was too townclearing