Mini 1991: Taking Justice Into Our Own Hands (Town Win)

[Beefster]

Official Vote Count 1-18

Fissure

(4): Luca Blight, Awoo, Lexa, Cedrick

Cedrick

(4): rb, Alexcellent, Papa Zito, Mumble

Lexa

(2): havingfitz, Fissure

Not Voting

(3): Eddie Cane, northsidegal, Havo

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2018-02-23 09:00:00)

Previous Vote Count | Next Vote Count

[Luca Blight]

@Luca, with Fissure's replacement, do you find their slot more scummy, less scummy or about the same?

I didn't find his catch-up particularly impressive; he's throwing shit around without any consideration and jumping to conclusions, and his attack on me was terrible.

I do find players like Mulch difficult to read as they're scatty as either alignment, but my read on this slot has not yet changed.

[Luca Blight]

I don't really want a Cedrick lynch today; as annoying as he is to read, I feel the hard stances he's taken make him more likely town.

My lynch pool is something like: Fissure, Awoo, maybe NSG.

If we're taking a punt on the PR's I'd probably side with lynching Lexa.

[Alexcellent]

I'm not keen on a fissure lynch, I think that slots town.

Why awoo or nsg? I probably need to look further into them, but had gut town leans there for the most part.

I'm mixed on Lexa, can defs see the scum but not confident enough to want to lynch a Pr D1. Im thinking maybe that claim needs to be revisited tomorrow?

I need to do some mulling

[Eddie Cane]

Happy birthday!

thanks @ both

[Eddie Cane]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whVYz1Z3n6Y

[rb]

cedrick/nsg/lexa

Ive decided thst oddnight watcher is pretty shit anyway even if lexa flips town

[rb]

Im willing to lynch havo/awoo as compromise

[Luca Blight]

Alex, I've already talked a fair bit about Awoo. NSG is more of a gut feeling - I liked her opening but I've felt nothing from her recent posts.

I'm willing to give Mulch a pass for today to give him a fair chance.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Lexa

I can see this flipping red.

[Lexa]

1110

Anyone disagree with this

If there's a fake claim between Mumbles and Lexa, it's Lexa. I CAN see potential scum motivation. Scum!Lexa sees Mumble suddenly claim doc, and pre-emptively claims to avoid the potential of anyone from Mumble's wagon changing to her. Lots of talk of quickhammers this game as well, so maybe she felt threatened that she may get quicklynched following Mumble's claim. I can see that kneejerk reaction coming from town though too... but it hurts town more than scum? So more than likely comes from scum?

And yeah. The immediate dismissal of the idea that Mumble's doc claim can't be true followed by the wall either means they're town super hard tunnelling Mumble or scum.

The 826 change to GNR feels opportunistic as well.

So I dunno, I don't disagree, Lexa's probs scum. Need to think about it though.

Read 826 in context of 809 and tell me if it still feels opportunistic

[Lexa]

Is mulch normally this trash at mafia?

[Lexa]

Les put this here

Lexa IMMEDIATELY

And ON THE SPOT

Bullshit called mumbles claim fake

He should have a gut fucking reason for it


Instead apparently it’s this wall of a post well thought out logical reason???


Hell fucking no

You decided it was scum and then decided to spend a fuckton of time building a reason around it

What’s more everything in that post is shit and your use of profanity is masking it

Mumbles claim is fine

Mumbles play is fine

If you read the post it’s BS

400 posts and 2 days later I go back and reevaluate the slot and you're acting like it came as a knee jerk follow up to his claim

Garbage

[havingfitz]

could you talk a little more about this? because i feel like the overconfidence was definitely there in c9++ and that's a large part of where my scumread on you was coming from. do you feel like that game isn't representative of your scumgame or what?

Are you scum reading me in this game?

That c9++ is no indicative of my scum game because I was not scum. I was an SK with approx 20 posts for the entire game.

I try to be town as any role but when I'm an sk...I am essentially (IMO) town. So that c9++ was not my scum game. It was also not similar to this game in that the confidence level in my reads is not the same. I'm more confident in this game hence my commitment to my read/s. When I'm scum I know my target is really innocent so I'm more likely to be less aggressive/committed to pushing a mislynch then I am as town pushing for what I strongly believe is a scum lynch.

[havingfitz]

....,....,Cedric

These are town

Why Cedrick? I'm not 100% opposed to this possibility so your reasons would be appreciated.

[Cedrick]

Is mulch normally this trash at mafia?

just ignore mulch, he's a hyperactive trolling piece of shit who ruins games with his presence

[havingfitz]

GNR off my scum list thanks to Mulch's crack.

[havingfitz]

Is there anything in the last ~16 pages since Friday that I need to address?

[Cedrick]

I’m not trying to fight with you but I want to have an honest discussion with you right now.

Why does mulch spam posting make you town read them when they do it as both alignments?

Do you understand why I’m suspicious of you yet? I really don’t believe you as town would town read somebody or scum read somebody for doing things that are done by both alignments.

Eddie made a comment about sorting people. Like players have to sort them to determine their actual alignment. You doing a 180 on a slot without any sorting at all is suspicious to me. To me it looks like he shares your read on Lexa so you are going to call him town.

So please explain exactly what mulch has done that makes him town over scum because I’m not seeing it personally

[Mumble]

VOTE: Lexa

Preferred lynch obvs.

[havingfitz]

Are you suspicious of me because I'm doing things you think town me or player having been on site x length of time me would never do as town? If you are town and everyone who was town always did things you thought town should do you'd be the best player ever. But everyone is different.

"You doing a 180 on a slot without any sorting at all" Isn't me reading the game this morning from Mulch's replace in and coming to the conclusion I think he is more likley to be town than scum sorting? Am I not allowed to change my mind on a slot that did nothing when a player joins who actually takes stances and provides opinions? Mulch has and it has changed my view on the GNR slot. And his content since joining has not been limited to Lexa suspiions...and I am not revising my read based soley on his Lexa suspicions.

What is your read on Mulch and if it's scum...is it for GNR or for Mulch?

p.edit ^ at Cedrick

[Cedrick]

I’m suspicious of you because your reads/actions/pushes don’t really make much sense. You scum read people for things that aren’t scummy which is what scum typically do.

Let’s assume gnr is scum lurking. Any replacement for him is going to most likely do the exact opposite since that’s why the slot is getting pressure. It’s easy to come in and hypo post as scum. I don’t feel like you have actually read his posts, I don’t think you’ve read any of the posts that have been made while you were “v/la”.

Mulch hasn’t really taken hard stances. He’s calling Lexa scum and now voting her when a majority of the players have been doing that. That could very easily be scum mirroring others.

What other hard stances has he made? He criticizes people for pressurng a lurker and says there are so many other scummy people yet he townreads most of the really scummy people.

You aren’t even trying to enguage with him to get him to explain his reads.

[Papa Zito]

oh jfc I'm playing with Mulch non o non onon onononon

[Papa Zito]

400 posts and 2 days later I go back and reevaluate the slot and you're acting like it came as a knee jerk follow up to his claim

Garbage

That's not what he said at all.

Let's solve this mystery today.


VOTE: Lexa

[Lexa]

L
He should have a gut fucking reason for it


Instead apparently it’s this wall of a post well thought out logical reason???

It's exactly what he said are you fucked

[Awoo]

>Scummy guy replaces out
>Spammy guy replaces in
>Scummy guy replaces out
>Spammy guy replaces in
fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck this game dude 1 sec