In post 1477, Dannflor wrote:Penguin, what's your read on the january/Psyche slot?
January, I'm not ignoring your Penguin case but I'm taking my time with responding to it because it's a holiday weekend and I imagine the game is gonna be pretty dead anyway.
I think it's a good case despite my previously stated town lean on Penguin. I've for the most part been content to give him a pass because I haven't really had the emotional energy to fight Pyrrha on yet another town read of hers, and there have been other scummier slots up until now, but it's a slot worth looking at. Thanks for taking the time to case it, I'll have more to say later.
And say we lynch Penguin instead of Banaki and he flips town, what then? I was not wrong on Gamma, so I don’t know why you’re so quick to discredit my reads.
Like just assume you’re wrong for a moment, where do you look next?
I obviously don’t know. Obviously one of my tr would have to be wrong.
All I know is I’m grateful january replaced into this game because I very likely would have mislynched Psyche. While I thought Pine scummy and Psyche bordeline, january is super townie. The sheer level of nuanced thinking is not something I can see scum replicating.
I do think he has a point about Penguin’s not really making the same level of deep reads he did in LNT. In every game I’ve played with scum!Penguin, he’s played more like he did in Excalibur and No Dead Person but then he says, his meta is different in larges than in micros.
So, with january slot, being super townie, I have to reconsider anyone who’s not townlock and january really seems obtown to me.
Sheep and Penguin were Banaki’s top townreads iirc?
*i prefer if u use she instead of he. ty <3*
and ok do u think my point applies to this game or not? and u did say that penguin was a strong-ish townread earlier (iirc) so can u explain that read a little bit
It’s just that I don’t really see any agenda to his play and nothing about his ISO really sticks out to me as scummy.
In post 1476, january wrote:anyone wanna read my penguino case or comment or something i put so much work into it
bc i seriously have no idea how penguin is townread and i really want to know
It's a bad case built around a prior assumption and looking for rationale versus the other way around.
In post 1477, Dannflor wrote:Penguin, what's your read on the january/Psyche slot?
I'd probably lynch it after BS but before Banakai. The ate worked.
My opinion on her case on me is above.
I’d lynch Banaki before BS and don’t think I want to lynch january at all. Other than disliking her case on you, what makes her scum because I think she’s transparently obvtown here?
In post 1477, Dannflor wrote:Penguin, what's your read on the january/Psyche slot?
January, I'm not ignoring your Penguin case but I'm taking my time with responding to it because it's a holiday weekend and I imagine the game is gonna be pretty dead anyway.
I think it's a good case despite my previously stated town lean on Penguin. I've for the most part been content to give him a pass because I haven't really had the emotional energy to fight Pyrrha on yet another town read of hers, and there have been other scummier slots up until now, but it's a slot worth looking at. Thanks for taking the time to case it, I'll have more to say later.
And say we lynch Penguin instead of Banaki and he flips town, what then? I was not wrong on Gamma, so I don’t know why you’re so quick to discredit my reads.
In post 1477, Dannflor wrote:Penguin, what's your read on the january/Psyche slot?
January, I'm not ignoring your Penguin case but I'm taking my time with responding to it because it's a holiday weekend and I imagine the game is gonna be pretty dead anyway.
I think it's a good case despite my previously stated town lean on Penguin. I've for the most part been content to give him a pass because I haven't really had the emotional energy to fight Pyrrha on yet another town read of hers, and there have been other scummier slots up until now, but it's a slot worth looking at. Thanks for taking the time to case it, I'll have more to say later.
And say we lynch Penguin instead of Banaki and he flips town, what then? I was not wrong on Gamma, so I don’t know why you’re so quick to discredit my reads.
