No. But it's relatively close.In post 49, Moonlight wrote:In that game I was part of an informed minority. Is the situation the same here?
No, I don't think it will. You've already made a minor townslip.. well.. a minor Moonlight townslip.In post 51, Moonlight wrote:I'd like to believe so, but this isn't the game where I'll find that out.
Why would you discount it like that?In post 54, tman2nd wrote:Oh, I didn't realize a wagon would appear on my RVS vote. Not to sure about the logic for it, but it's an RVS wagon, so whatever.
Fire mafia doesn't care about finding fire mafia, it only wants to find ice mafia and vise versa.In post 58, Not_Mafia wrote:You've yet to actually explain why my question was alignment indicative
Agreed. I like town's footing this game. This is a nice place to start, actually. We can get some good discussion going on this.In post 60, Moonlight wrote:@Tricks: I agree with your scumreads and I can't believe that people are calling this a random voting stage when there's a 4-vote wagon.
The fact that he doesn't seem to know why it would be a scumtell makes me strongly doubt it's the latter.@Not_Mafia: Your question could have easily been phrased "Are you scum?". It wasn't, which shows that you're looking at scum as two teams of scum instead of just scum. The way I see it, either you're interested in one team more than the other, or you're a Townie who wanted to give that impression to get us out of RVS ASAP.
No, because that doesn't say you're town, it just says you might not be scum. And if you were fire mafia, of course you would ask about fire mafia as well as ice mafia because it would be a major scum tell. You actuallyIn post 62, Not_Mafia wrote:Let's say I am scum. Why would I phrase my question that way, if Trickster is scum then I'd either know which scum he is, if he was my partner, or if he wasn't, which scum team he would have to be on if he was scum. The distinction of which scum is which is far important to town.
See how I can construct an argument saying the opposite. You can wifom and twist what I said 6 ways of Sunday but it will still be a random RVS joke post.
Why is wagoning bad?I don't know whether to vote Moonlight for badly twisting innocuous RVS posts in to scum tells, Finglove for wagoning with a naked vote or Trickster for sheeping.
Eenie meenie miny moonlight
VOTE: Moonlight
In post 63, Tr1ckster wrote:No, because that doesn't say you're town, it just says you might not be scum. And if you were fire mafia, of course you would ask about fire mafia as well as ice mafia because it would be a major scum tellIn post 62, Not_Mafia wrote:Let's say I am scum. Why would I phrase my question that way, if Trickster is scum then I'd either know which scum he is, if he was my partner, or if he wasn't, which scum team he would have to be on if he was scum. The distinction of which scum is which is far important to town.
See how I can construct an argument saying the opposite. You can wifom and twist what I said 6 ways of Sunday but it will still be a random RVS joke post.if you didn't. You actuallycan'ttwist it any way you want.
Why is wagoning bad?I don't know whether to vote Moonlight for badly twisting innocuous RVS posts in to scum tells, Finglove for wagoning with a naked vote or Trickster for sheeping.
Eenie meenie miny moonlight
VOTE: Moonlight
I didn't sheep, I posted my own reasons.
I don't like your OMGUS vote.
If you're going to use that standard then there's no such thing as a towny post or a townread, just "might not be scum" posts and "might not be scum reads".In post 63, Tr1ckster wrote:No, because that doesn't say you're town, it just says you might not be scum.
I said him wagoning with a naked vote was bad.In post 63, Tr1ckster wrote:Why is wagoning bad?
Your question answers itself by showing the defense that is implied just by the phrasing of your question to Tricks. It implies "Tricks, I don't know which scum team you're on if you're scum because I'm not scum". The phrasing is superfluous and the fact that you're reacting to this can be for various reasons, towny or not.In post 62, Not_Mafia wrote:Let's say I am scum. Why would I phrase my question that way, if Trickster is scum then I'd either know which scum he is, if he was my partner, or if he wasn't, which scum team he would have to be on if he was scum.
No. A town read (to me) is someone who is town because of pro-town play. A "not scum" read to me is someone who is not scum due to lack of scumminess.In post 66, Not_Mafia wrote:If you're going to use that standard then there's no such thing as a towny post or a townread, just "might not be scum" posts and "might not be scum reads".
Ok. Ask him to explain his vote then. And vote for him instead of Moonlight, who has done nothing to be worthy of your vote.In post 66, Not_Mafia wrote:I said him wagoning with a naked vote was bad.
Why are you upset that I'm defending my strongest town read from thrown together OMGUS arguments?In post 69, Not_Mafia wrote:Why are you so concerned with Moonlight being townread?
Give me a good reason he shouldn't be townread.In post 69, Not_Mafia wrote:Why are you so concerned with Moonlight being townread?
In post 72, Not_Mafia wrote:You know what my reasons for voting him are
Because he doesn't agree with it and doesn't think it warrants a lynch, duh.In post 55, Tr1ckster wrote:Why would you discount it like that?
That's a good question. Why IS your vote still on it, Tman?Why would you keep your vote on a wagon you don't agree with?
I feel like this is a stretch. A big stretch. The question was essentially a comment on the theme. And unless you expected someone to actually answer the question directly, it couldn't possibly gain scum any knowledge. There is no scum-benefiting way for that question to resolve. It's just banter and I don't see it as alignment indicative at all.In post 59, Tr1ckster wrote:Fire mafia doesn't care about finding fire mafia, it only wants to find ice mafia and vise versa.In post 58, Not_Mafia wrote:You've yet to actually explain why my question was alignment indicative
It doesn't matter to town which mafia a player is a part of.. at least not right now. Scum is scum is scum is food for the noose.