In post 335, Not Chara wrote:Rational: i don't like this response. to Firebringer, it's "mastin has called you scum, and she is a good scumhunter" but when it's about you, it's "you're not that good at reading me".
and 'stop being silly'? this feels like an attempt to win over mastin. no paranoia at all?
and you're saying you shouldn't have been expected to comment on every read mastin makes, but you didn't mention me at all, despite that being the main crux of mastin's point.
Titus has been getting better and better at reading scum lately, but still reads me wrong. She'll openly admit it (and a small voice says that if she doesn't, I can link you to literally a dozen or more games). Good scum hunters can be wrong about some people due to style. In particular, Cerb and I both don't really care about being town read. We work on solving the game and let people figure out we're town on their own schedule.
As for talking about
you
, we would have to be scum to be scum partners with you, so Mastin's suggestion that we looked like scum partners wasn't even worth responding to. The fact that it caught your attention does make me wonder about YOU though.
And ummm ... we're paranoid about everyone. Mastin was Connie in Steven Universe with us (We were Steven Universe and we could IC on day 5, but Mastin and Xtoxm showed up in a permanent neighborhood/alliance with us at the start of day 3) and we were paranoid of her then, even though the scum roles we saw flip made us believe that logically scum would not have been given knowledge that we were Steven prior to the first season finale because they had the ability to kill us and it would have taken just pure luck for us to escape death (we would have had to be allied with a specific player and that player would have had to use a 1-shot commute that specific night or otherwise scum could have killed us without any way for us to survive during the first finale, which was
BEFORE
we could get mod confirmation that we were IC. So even though we felt it was logically really bastard for either mastin or xtoxm to be scum, we were still paranoid of both of them (xtoxm ended up being scum, but that's a whole other story).
The point is... we don't give out town reads lightly. We're paranoid of everyone until we have good reasons to trust them, and you can see this in our play consistently in every game we've played.
So umm... stop assuming shit. This is a big game with a lot of people. Just because I'm not climbing down someone's throat doesn't mean I town read them. {Insert commentary about assumptions here}.
~D
P.S. - Cerb's at work and I've got a friend over so see ya'll later tonight