My name is Broderick Drake and some people have described me as a rancid fellow. I am just popping in to inform you that
Also, pieguy is probably scum.
-Nati
In post 26, YurikoJasmine wrote:I thought this was an open setting...
In post 29, Natirasha wrote:I'll be around starting Monday...Pride is taking up all my time this weekend.
--Muff
In post 103, Gentlemen Bastards wrote:would like to know what specifically of Yuriko that you are/were reading as scum at the time of your post
In post 103, Gentlemen Bastards wrote:also would love your read on Quilford with reasoning attached please
In post 106, pieguyn wrote:I'm not sure if RBD would think to push me the way they've done so far if they were scum, although this is mostly gut. zmuffin has had a lot of trouble in the past reading my town posts as "forced", whereas Nati pegged me immediately in our one scum-town game bc she (correctly) identified my posts as forced; what we're seeing here is Nati pushing me over forced posts. I think this makes slightly more sense from town than scum in that Nati would be more likely to think she's onto something reading my posts as forced, whereas zmuffin would be hesitant to push it - on the other hand if they were scum I would expect zmuffin would be slightly more likely to comment on his partner's supposed read on me either way.
In post 120, pieguyn wrote:if it's still relevant, I really feel I should let you know that every time you've read my posts as forced oustide of TH upick 1 I've been town.
In post 120, pieguyn wrote:as opposed to scum pushing an agenda
In post 123, pieguyn wrote:the ffery town read is entirely about her confidence. this probably sounds really dumb but that's how I always read her and it's always been right, so it works for me. I don't think she'd immediately jump in and push Empire first thing in the game if she was scum here for this reason (it would be a more bold move than what I'm used to from her).
In post 135, Quilford wrote:HMMMmmafdmfa okay maybe reg vs pie is town on town.
In post 262, sangres wrote:Do you think that overreacting is a scumtell for Pieguyn in particular? More importantly, what about pieguyn's reaction felt fake?
In post 323, sangres wrote:You challenged both of them about statements/stances, which is in keeping with your feeling that town wouldn't *know* either of their alignments.. What Muffin did looked more like taking sides.
In post 327, pieguyn wrote:I actually have an issue with this. how are you not seeing similarities between those posts and what I did in S&S?
In post 331, sangres wrote:In post 330, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:You're talking about #119, prior to when the back-and-forth between them actually started, right? Like, when there weren't even sides to actually take on the argument that hadn't yet happened, right?
It was fairly obvious that's where the tide of the game was going, unless you don't think you'd be able to pick up on that as scum.
In post 334, pieguyn wrote:In post 332, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:I don't remember you ever doing anything like that in Serum&Steel
eh, fair enough. FTR, I was referring to this (directed towards the same person, even!).
In post 336, sangres wrote:Also, from my perspective, Pie's case bordered on nonsensical.
In post 336, sangres wrote:Anyway, I'd kinda like for you to talk about what you think of the way their argument has evolved when you get a chance.
In post 328, sangres wrote:I don't think overreaction is a bad way to summarize your thoughts on Pie-scum. You believed his reactions weren't genuine because they seemed to be aggressive without having a reason to be aggressive, with added incentive to do so because of his meta, which means you think that he's scummy because he's overreacting, no?
In post 341, sangres wrote:I obviously disagree with the case on GB, but it fits with what I know about town-pie that she'd react the way she did
In post 345, pieguyn wrote:except in that game, your reasoning for scum reading me *was* correct. your reasoning was that I wasn't scum hunting, and it was right - I had not pushed anyone at that point in the game.
in this game, GB was pushing me for strategically lurking. which is incorrect - I wasn't posting bc I was busy.
you're saying you'd expect me to react the same way as TH 3. so why would you expect me to acknowledge I was doing something that I wasn't doing?
In post 347, sangres wrote:I think that it was more likely than not that Pieguyn was approaching the game from a town perspective than a scum one when she had the initial reaction she did to Regfan's post
In post 354, pieguyn wrote:...... except it is?
In post 328, sangres wrote:I don't think overreaction is a bad way to summarize your thoughts on Pie-scum. You believed his reactions weren't genuine because they seemed to be aggressive without having a reason to be aggressive, with added incentive to do so because of his meta, which means you think that he's scummy because he's overreacting, no?
In post 360, sangres wrote:Who should my strongest townread be?
In post 361, sangres wrote:I would vote you because you haven't done anything particularly town yet and leave it at that.
In post 372, Imperium wrote:In post 363, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:In post 360, sangres wrote:Who should my strongest townread be?
I would have thought you'd have a stronger read on, say, bork-hydra because I'm nowhere near as familiar with them as you are and I'm pretty sure they're town and they're not even my strongest town read tbh so yeah. I think you're
I can find scumgames from borkhydra that look pretty similar to this one (Tales of You). I can't find scumgames from pie that look anything like this. Can you?
In post 375, sangres wrote:I don't deny that this position is implausible coming from me as scum, but pretending that I don't have any alternatives is kind of ridiculous.
In post 393, sangres wrote:In post 391, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:In post 375, sangres wrote:I don't deny that this position is implausible coming from me as scum, but pretending that I don't have any alternatives is kind of ridiculous.
Oh also I think you had alternatives, they were just all shitty from the perspective of you wanting to look like you were thinking about the game in a town way
except nacho didn't need to look like he's thinking about the game, or even make an appearance. I've been playing with easy going confidence, had hit my stride and have been virtually fizzing with the joy that being town gives me.
If we were scum, the last thing nacho would have wanted to do was mess with that. This would be *my* break out game if we were scum.
We're not scum. We're gamesolving. If you're town, I think you should be able to see that.
In post 395, sangres wrote:In post 394, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:So you think that push seemed genuine because you don't think pieguy-scum would want to get into a tunnel argument?
ffery reply. I don't think scum-pieguy is afraid to tunnel. It's the zero to 100, wild-eyed paranoid leap into a 1v1 tunnel that doesn't look like something scum-pieguy would do. her tunnel in S&S didn't have even a whiff of wild-eyed paranoia.
In post 443, sangres wrote:I'm here. kinda zapped out.
was going to ask you if you're caught up and have reads, but I think that's negatory based on 434.
In post 442, BBmolla wrote:Muffin/Nati do you jokingly sign posts as each other or what, cause I missed something there
In post 444, Gold Saucer wrote:In post 441, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:Hi bork! I don't know how I feel about you atm! You're not dictating the flow of the game imo and that's something I always look for you in games with us.
Don't really know what this means or how my presence differs from what you expect. Explain?
-b
In post 458, sangres wrote:
My strong-town list: goldsaucer, pieguy, gb
My nulltown list: bbmolla, quillford (nacho would put Yuriko here too, I think)
In post 463, sangres wrote:those are pretty much the opposite of zmuffin's reads.
In post 468, Gold Saucer wrote:In post 464, BBmolla wrote:I think Yuriko doing setup spec is unlikely as a normal tree(she specifically named Arsonists by name). Hence the Firefighter/Arsonist thoughts and I still stand by it. I think she's probably scum who is scared of the playerlist and hiding behind setup spec.
Underlined: not a bad point at all and not something I was considering when I made my gutshot at her 55 forever ago
-b