Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[MURDERCAT]

Can you explain why Echo, as scum, would make that statement but Echo, as town, would not?

[NoPowerOverMe]

It's not silly for day 1.

It's like someone landing on your property in monopoly and feeling bad about taking their money.

[Titus]

now talk to me please :p

Why do you have shelly town and Ranny scum?

[Titus]

Titus and EV are town upon a Ranny scumflip as well

I don’t understand what you’re trying to do here. How can you rule out SvS?

Why do you care?

[Rannygazoo]

Because it feels like what scum in a multiball game might say.

“If this person who’s not on my team is scum on another faction, then my buddies (or townies I want to pocket) have town cred instantly forever.”

I know the gambit won’t work because I know my alignment, but that’s the scum motivation for a statement like that.

I can’t see the town motivation and I was hoping someone would fill me in.

[redcardinal]

I actually agree with ranny on this point, giving town credit before a flip looks really bad, esp because of the likely multi setup

[Titus]

I actually agree with ranny on this point, giving town credit before a flip looks really bad, esp because of the likely multi setup

It's not that. The fact S v S being a theoretical possibility makes sense. Ranny shouldn't be considering any setup where he flips scum. It should be worthless.

[SirCakez]

PlusJOYED replaces Wiyvern!
ItalianoVD replaces shellyc!

[SirCakez]

Votecount 1.10

Rannygazoo (4) - NoPowerOverMe, redcardinal, EchoVision, iamausername
ItalianoVD (3) - Herta, Noraa, Titus
Herta (2) - ItalianoVD, Primate
redcardinal (1) - Rannygazoo
iamausername (1) - MURDERCAT

Not voting (2) - PlusJOYED, Iconeum

(expired on 2020-10-23 09:11:00) remain until day end

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to reach a majority.

[EchoVision]

hi plus
hi italiano
but hi plus more bc i know plus

[Noraa]

Hi plus!!

[ItalianoVD]

Aight so only person I know on the list having just played with them is Titus. However I’ve been following multiple games with Noraa, Echo and MURDERCAT, so I feel like I know them as well.

A little about myself:
- I gut read
- I gif post
- I don’t do meta dives
- I don’t partner hunt
- I can be sarcastic
- I don’t discriminate. I call out nonsense on everybody
- I hate Day 1s
- I love trolls
- I am analytical and logical
- I will troll if bored
- I can wall post, but I’d rather get to the point with quick posts and/or quotes

If any of these turn you off or clash with your personality all I gotta say is:



Don’t worry, we’ll get along just fine.

Oh yeah I’ve been following the game so no catch up needed.

[Noraa]

well technically you still need to post us a catch up post of who is scum and stuff.

[PlusJOYED]

yo

[ItalianoVD]

well technically you still need to post us a catch up post of who is scum and stuff.

Well that’s a readslist. It’s different from a catch-up post, but yeah I’ll definitely thrown one down in a bit.

[Noraa]

Am I scum Italiano?

[ItalianoVD]

Oh yeah

UNVOTE: Herta

Here’s a quick one. I don’t think Herta is scum at all, unlike my predecessor. I don’t agree with her read at all and don’t see what she saw.

[PlusJOYED]

yall are gonna get a low effort joyed this game, sorry
I looked through the list and I saw that there wasn't a mafia/antitown king, all i saw was a 1shot kingmaker. So I'm gonna be upfront so if we have a king they don't kill themselves: this game I rolled hero.
Probably gonna be more like a vt but whatever.

[ItalianoVD]

Am I scum Italiano?

You scared?

You could be. I know your scum game is pretty much your town game, so I’m not trusting you, but I still like how you post. I think the genuine feel to your posts is NAI.

[iamausername]

i finished rereading, and don't have any earth-shattering new revelations to offer, but i did spot further evidence that Ranny is scum that i don't think anyone has pointed out yet.

456: Ranny votes Titus for 'jesting'.
489: Ranny complains that people aren't scumreading Titus for doing a scummy thing that he himself did, and was scumread for.
(this is scummy in itself for the reaosns outlined by Primate in 490.)
492: Ranny cunningly talks his way around Primate's point: he didn't say that particular Titus post is

scummy

, he just doesn't understand why other people don't think it is.
498: he clarifies: "I am not scumreading Titus for that post.

I am scumreading Titus strictly for other reasons.

"
539:

"I didn’t even vote you [Titus] because I thought you were scum."

ok i actually didn't need to post all of that buildup, but Primate made a good point there and i wanted to remind people. anyway, Ranny can't even remember if he scumreads Titus or not. this is not a real read.

something felt off with Noraa from my reread too, might look at her iso and see if i can pin down what it is that's bothering me.

[Noraa]

Am I scum Italiano?

You scared?

You could be. I know your scum game is pretty much your town game, so I’m not trusting you, but I still like how you post. I think the genuine feel to your posts is NAI.

hmm is that so? I am informed that my scum game is not my town game at all so I'm not trusting you I feel like you shaded and buddied me all in the same post. That's a bit unfair tho I still pretty firmly believe ur slot is scum. Shelly welly repping out of a scum slot is quite strange I will say but those first few pages did not rub me the right way.

something felt off with Noraa from my reread too, might look at her iso and see if i can pin down what it is that's bothering me.

This sentence highlights why I dislike playing with people that I have played with me before.

[Noraa]

*take out the me

[ItalianoVD]

With the way this game is setup, (possible multiball) not sure I can really put anyone as locktown, but I will townlean you though.

I think Primate might be an anti-town role playing in a pro town way, which is why everyone seems to be vibing with him. As a matter of fact if I had to guess I’d say there are multiple anti-town roles posing as pro town right now.

[iamausername]

*take out the me

no i want to take out the I instead

[ItalianoVD]

hi plus
hi italiano

but hi plus more bc i know plus

Wow...