Chosen (a Cafftown actually won!)

[Primate]

/in.

[Primate]

Vote charter

For voting someone. Aren't you aware townies could *die*.

[Primate]

9 posts between me looking at the thread and my post coming through.

gogo marathon day.

[Primate]

So what's wrong with L-2 if we're all coordinated enough not to quick lynch?

Was thinking about that. I imagine it's a mechanism for the corner case of 2 vs 2 with chosen one still alive.

[Primate]

So what's wrong with L-2 if we're all coordinated enough not to quick lynch?

Was thinking about that. I imagine it's a mechanism for the corner case of 2 vs 2 with chosen one still alive.

Oh hey it says this in the first post now.

I am good.

[Primate]

OK, we're lynching tajo today.

If I vote for him will you take all responsibility for my vote?

[Primate]

I am pretty sure I am the chosen one.

[Primate]

OK, we're lynching tajo today.

If I vote for him will you take all responsibility for my vote?

FOS

Ok, where do *you* want me to put my vote?

[Primate]

Do you frequently vote for things you don't understand over things you think are scummy?

[Primate]

OK, we're lynching tajo today.

OK, we're lynching tajo today.

If I vote for him will you take all responsibility for my vote?

I am pretty sure I am the chosen one.

Found our scum pair, guys.

"Pretty sure" cannot be any surer than random, unless you're part of our ickle informed minority.

Does it hurt to think.

[Primate]

UNVOTE; VOTE: PRIMATE

I don't like your posting.

I don't like your face.

[Primate]

Do you frequently vote for things you don't understand over things you think are scummy?

What appears scummy in this game to you, Primate?

It's a chat game, effectively. Look for people using established forum scumtells irrespective of context in the early game, punish lurkers, punish people who refuse to commit to attitudes.

[Primate]

In other news, hohum is town.

why?

[Primate]

I think I like OGML.

[Primate]

What are you talking about? Relax, people. Im still in the random stage. I dont have any strategies in a game Ive never played in.
In other news, hohum is town.

not buying this kind of explaination.

I poercieved random stage was over and your vote was actually part of a wagon, which it was.

if you really thought primate was scum you would have said you percieved the copy as an actual scum tell instead of viewing your own actions as scummy or randomly careless

Vote: Tajo

Except I dont think Primate is scum.
FAIL.

Then who do you think is scum?

[Primate]

Opinions on hohum? His page 5 posts seem scummy to me. Enthusiastic townie also fits the bill.

I was thinking around this.

[Primate]

unvote

I don't think Primate is scum anymore.

GJ leaving the bandwagon when people on it start to be suspected. They'll never suspect a thing.

[Primate]

What are you talking about? Relax, people. Im still in the random stage. I dont have any strategies in a game Ive never played in.
In other news, hohum is town.

not buying this kind of explaination.

I poercieved random stage was over and your vote was actually part of a wagon, which it was.

if you really thought primate was scum you would have said you percieved the copy as an actual scum tell instead of viewing your own actions as scummy or randomly careless

Vote: Tajo

Except I dont think Primate is scum.
FAIL.

Then who do you think is scum?

I still dont know. I think you and hohum are town.

Why Hohum?

[Primate]

Bad answer there Hohum.

[Primate]

What exactly has crywolf done this game?

I thought she was town until she dropped off my wagon for no reason than everyone else was doing it. I didn't like that.

[Primate]

What exactly has crywolf done this game?

Been an easy target for a scum-powered lurker+parrot case, as per her meta.

I think I might like you too.

[Primate]

What exactly has crywolf done this game?

What have you done?????

This is the first post I've seen from you for a while. Still getting that pizza or have you thought of another reason to lurk and coast?

Um dude. I've posted every page. Go look back Srsly.

Someone is going to quote this and say "posted WHAT though?" and then start a wagon.

Can I do it please?

[Primate]

Def leaning towards an OGML + Tajo pair. Early bus, hoping a case would build itself against Tajo. Now either one is feeling out a pushable wagon on null tells and neutral play; Tajo is actually contradicting his obvtown read from a page ago, based on an obvpressure vote.

I don't think OGML is scum.

[Primate]

OMG PRIMATE!! <33 Where have you been?

Unvote Vote charter

Why?

Following Primate

I know it was earlier in the game but I still stand behind this.

[Primate]

I think we lynch charter today.

[Primate]

I hear chompas are a great replacement for tissues when mast********

How is this even remotely relevant?

When is Jath relevant?

NVM

Why NVM?

Cuz i saw your post explaining your utterly irrelevant post.

[Primate]

Calling Charter+Hohum

[Primate]

Calling Charter+Hohum

Why calling hohum? I'm posting.

Calling means that I'm favouring you as scum, not that I'm calling you to the thread to post more, in this context. You're fine in that regard.

[Primate]

unvote vote p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-poker face

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ngf5Oo_XrjI

Yeah, ok, I can definitely see that.

[Primate]

charter - Less town than hohum
crywolf20084 - obvtown, she's much more cautious about her usual lurking and light banter when playing scum, since it attracts a lot of attention
hohum - More town than hohum
Nuwen Hi!
OhGodMyLife - scum with Tajo/Primate
PokerFace - Still neutral.
populartajo - posscum with OGML
Primate - posscum with OGML or Shadowlurker
ShadowLurker - posscum with Primate

Primate <-> Shadowlurker connection is based solely on voting patterns.

Hey lookit me being scum with all.

[Primate]

unvote charter

[Primate]

I've had enough.

Xd, constantly lurking. ShadowLurker, living up to the handle, not contributing anything useful, not justifying votes.

Vote: ShadowLurker

hmph

[Primate]

unvote charter

I am completely lost in this game.

It's a good attitude to have.

[Primate]

I've had enough.

Xd, constantly lurking. ShadowLurker, living up to the handle, not contributing anything useful, not justifying votes.

Vote: ShadowLurker

hmph

Care to elaborate? Do you think my read on Xd and ShadowLurker are wrong? Do you see this changing any time soon? Would you prefer to give a free pass to this sort of behavior?

I think your reasoning is understandable, but flawed. You are disregarding things you shouldn't be, but they aren't obvious things, so I'm still digesting it.

[Primate]

[/b]vote Pokerface[/b] I reckon.

[Primate]

vote Pokerface

[Primate]

Tajo, you keep saying in other news This person is town. or That person is town. Why??

This is actually a good question

It'd be a good question if it wasn't so general. Currently it's awful.

[Primate]

In other news Tajo is probably town.

[Primate]

Seriously though, I do not intend to lynch tajo. Get on Pokerface.

[Primate]

LOL at hohum's Primate-tajo double standard

I was going to make a post about how I do exactly the same thing, but I don't play enough for hohum to know my meta outside of this one game so it seemed pointless.

[Primate]

Tajo, you keep saying in other news This person is town. or That person is town. Why??

This is how I scumhunt. I find towntells that are more reliable than scumtells and start hunting scum by process of elimination.

You do that so you can stay under the radar. Pretty convenient for you to say someone is town so that you NEVER have to post a case to justify your conclusions.

Or because I really think they are prob town?

I don't buy this. It's the minimalist approach to playing this game.

People being right is better than people being wordy.

[Primate]

PS: Can everyone please get on PF.

[Primate]

LOL at hohum's Primate-tajo double standard

I was going to make a post about how I do exactly the same thing, but I don't play enough for hohum to know my meta outside of this one game so it seemed pointless.

Well hohum obviously doesn't know populartajo's either judging by his incessant nagging. It's intriguing but not in a scummy way. Does your name carry recognition or something that causes players to back down?

No not really. I do normally play like this though, so if I did have a recognisable pro-town meta through playing more, I'd be able to use that as a reference that the behaviour tajo is exhibiting isn't scummy except contextually.

[Primate]

That's a pretty lazy list PF.

[Primate]

FYI All, I would consider moving onto PF so we don't end up with no lynch.

[Primate]

I say this as someone who will not vote tajo fyi

[Primate]

COME ON YOU GAYS

[Primate]

Anti obv

[Primate]

I could support Kore or Hohum currently.

[Primate]

Now that we're not in a deadline I'm going to, like, actually read the thread.

Isn't the deadline like one hour this day?

Pedant

[Primate]

Unvote

Lets see if Andy can make up for what tajo has done.

Be fairly pro-town? DOn't know why he'd want to do that but hey.

[Primate]

I really don't like either of these posts, especially because the wagon on PF was bankrupt of any real foundation.

FYI All, I would consider moving onto PF so we don't end up with no lynch.

I'd support a PF lynch to avoid a no-lynch. We're getting pretty close to deadline, no?

Hohum's play on day 1 seemed to come from a sloppy, zealous town player though, while Primate's day 1 activity was far scummier.

I say this as someone who will not vote tajo fyi

OK, we're lynching tajo today.

If I vote for him will you take all responsibility for my vote?

OGML, Tajo, Primate <- our scum pair is in here somewhere.

Could you be more wrong?

[Primate]

Vote hohum

[Primate]

Vote hohum

Seriously, why has Primate been getting away with this type of crap?

Vote: Primate

Because I'm blatantly town?

Continue to posture based on poor reasoning though. No, it's fine, seriously.

[Primate]

I'm willing to switch to Cry but we should be lynching hohum today.

[Primate]

Still behind this pairing? Why Hohum over Charter today. Yesterday you were pegging Charter until your vote switched to PF.

I haven't really through charter was scum since I unvoted him. I like his attitude better.

[Primate]

And do you honestly think I'm carelessly throwing my vote around with the small amount I've voted? Grow up.

[Primate]

I'm willing to switch to Cry but we should be lynching hohum today.

You sure do waffle a lot. You did this yesterday too when you were convinced we had to get rid of Tajo but you were "willing to switch to PF." Now you're not even concerned about the former.

Do your voting patterns typically contain this much WIFOM?

Pay attention, he said something like "Tajo is prob town" late yesterday.

Yeah, I actually wanted to lynch Pokerface yesterday, regardless of deadline.

unvote
Vote CryWolf

[Primate]

Can we lynch Hohum now?

[Primate]

Can we lynch Hohum now?

No, as he's obviously the chosen.

I'm claiming vanilla and we're lynching me.

I don't see how that's a good play at all unless you are far more sure of things than you should be.

[Primate]

You see what you did there is fall into a really stupid trap. You are so certain of me being scum that you are assuming that the person I want to lynch is chosen. Should I just give up at this point cause you blatantly won't see sense and make a decent opinion? right, thought not.

[Primate]

*Sigh*

Why do I even try.

[Primate]

Thats 3 of you convinced I am scum now, you should probably lynch me.

You'd lose the game, but at least it ends it quicker then i can swear at you all when proven right.

[Primate]

I know, so we should be lynching the scum, who is Hohum.

[Primate]

Why are you so sure but not voting?

I don't like voting quickly in Lylo.

[Primate]

You'd lose the game, but at least it ends it quicker then i can swear at you all when proven right.

We won't lose if we lynch vanilla, and there's very little reason to believe that you're the Chosen. Even if my Andy/Tajo + Primate hypothesis is incorrect, you can lynch the leftover vanilla (read: Not Hohum) tomorrow in the same situation that I outlined above.

Vote: Primate

I think it's ludicrious to make any assumptions regarding the chosen TBH. The scum would have to be retarded to even slightly hint at it.

[Primate]

Primate is still town.
Nuwen, why the vote?

I don't think she's very good at mafia.

[Primate]

Oh, you meant what was her reasoning?

Oh nvm

[Primate]

Chances are reasoning won't be great though.

[Primate]

I've been completely unwagoned straight into day 3. Either one of our scum pair is going to come up with a brilliant case and get me lynched in an hour, or Primate's infatuation with Hohum makes him the Chosen.

Mmm, this makes sense.

No it doesn't.

[Primate]

Scum suspicion mounts and is infrequently original unless there is a point and a point has been uncessary.

[Primate]

I've been completely unwagoned straight into day 3. Either one of our scum pair is going to come up with a brilliant case and get me lynched in an hour, or Primate's infatuation with Hohum makes him the Chosen.

Mmm, this makes sense.

No it doesn't.

Why not?
Really leaning on charter-hohum scumpair.
Everybody can post thier top two?

Scum will not pursue chosen because the chosen being revealed is the situation in which the scum are utterly fucked so they will be coy and just generally just avoid the subject in order to win through decent playing irrespective of chosen, especially at this point in the game. Nuwen has been pretty consistently regarded as town, so scum would have to have a good reason to starta case against her, but no reason has appeared, so there's no real reason to persue it when other targets are avaliable.

[Primate]

Is it better to lynch town today? There's three townies, so 33% chance of loss, whereas if we kill mafia, then it's a 50% chance of loss tomorrow...

Don't bother with percentages. Here is what needs to happen for town to win:

1. We lynch scum or a vanilla townie today
2. We lynch scum or a vanilla townie tomorrow

Basically, town wins as long as we don't lynch the guy the prominent scum pair is telling us to lynch.

So the fact that 3 people in the game think I am scum means I am a bad lynch because lots of people are calling for my lynch?

Right?

I don't think that's the case and I doubt you do either.

[Primate]

Oh, anyone care to give me super secret info that could be important?

You're scum.

[Primate]

GL ya mooks.

[Primate]

Calling Charter+Hohum

This was the point in the game where I should have just stopped thinking.

Good game. Was extremely frustrating at times, but fun too.