Newbie 1352: Into the Darkness (Game Over)

[Skullduggery]

I have a homework assignment for all of you. During the night phase, I want you all to mull over the following question: If I really was orozorro's partner, do you really think I would be

this fucking obvious

about it?

I know it's WIFOM, but seriously, think it over. Everyone seems to be under the impression that I'm just the worst Scum player that ever lived. You don't really expect it to be that cut-and-dry, do you?

[Wisdom]

You know, all scum say the same.

[Wisdom]

But anyway Skullduggery, who do you think the partner is?

[frog]

I have a homework assignment for all of you. During the night phase, I want you all to mull over the following question: If I really was orozorro's partner, do you really think I would be

this fucking obvious

about it?

I know it's WIFOM, but seriously, think it over. Everyone seems to be under the impression that I'm just the worst Scum player that ever lived. You don't really expect it to be that cut-and-dry, do you?

I've seen scum act like this before. You are perfectly capable of being obvious about it as scum, and you know it. Your argument is pure WIFOM. It could easily be that cut and dry.

[UberNinja]

Newbie 1352 - Final Vote Count of Day 1

---

orozorro [5] - Wisdom, frog, Who, Belisarius,

T S O

T S O [2] - orozorro, Skullduggery
Beli [1] - Majiffy

Not Voting - catboi

---

A lynch has been reached.

orozorro has been lynched! He was the

Mafia Role Cop

!

It is now Night 1.

You have (expired on 2013-04-19 15:50:32) to send in your night actions.

[UberNinja]

Newbie 1352 - End of Night 1

Skullduggery has been killed in the Night! He was a

Vanilla Townie

!

Day 2 begins now.

The deadline is in (expired on 2013-05-12 16:36:41).

[Wisdom]

lolwut

[Wisdom]

What kind of scum leaves the doc alive AND kills the prime suspect...?

[catboi]

Uhh...

I was going to come into today fairly confident in town reads on T S O, Who, and Skullduggery, but I can't make any sense of that kill. At all.

Oh yeah, and I town read Wisdom too because he was the first to jump on Cybertronix.

Which really just leaves Belisarius and Majiffy. And I know who I suspect more out of those two~

VOTE: Majiffy

[Majiffy]

VOTE: Beli

Still scum. Good to know Oro was scum, though, he was one of my null-scum reads.

[Who]

The scum must have been sure Skullduggery was a PR. I can see no other possible explanation for that kill besides instigating WIFOM. Or possibly a move by someone (T S O) he was going after who felt he had to be silenced. (Though pursuing this line of reasoning causes WIFOM)

@Majiffy
Any particular reason?

[Majiffy]

Or possibly a move by someone (T S O) he was going after who felt he had to be silenced. (Though pursuing this line of reasoning causes WIFOM)

Or someone trying to pin TSO, which is more likely than this particular scenario, as Oro wouldn't have kept his vote on his buddy if there was a viable wagon on a townie to counterwagon.

@Majiffy
Any particular reason?

That would have been a question for yesterday when I could remember. But I know he was a firm scum read, and thus he needs to eat rope.

[Majiffy]

Town
{Wisdom, TSO, catboi}

Dunno,lol
{frog, Who}

Scum
{Belisarius}



If you're town, and not in the "Town" section, I advise interacting with me so I can get an accurate read on you.
Furthmore, if you're scum, and you find yourself in the "Town" section, please inform me so I can correct this.

[catboi]

frog's confirmed town, but I guess you weren't paying attention :3

[Who]

Or possibly a move by someone (T S O) he was going after who felt he had to be silenced. (Though pursuing this line of reasoning causes WIFOM)

Or someone trying to pin TSO, which is more likely than this particular scenario, as Oro wouldn't have kept his vote on his buddy if there was a viable wagon on a townie to counterwagon.

Hence the "pursuing this line of reasoning causes WIFOM."

@Majiffy
Any particular reason?

That would have been a question for yesterday when I could remember. But I know he was a firm scum read, and thus he needs to eat rope.

And yesterday I said

Is not explaining anything a requirement for ICs?

Majiffy, care to explain why Belisarius is scum?

And you didn't answer that either.
VOTE: Majiffy
Even you don't know why you're voting who you're voting.

[Belisarius]

I'm worried by that kill.

The fact that confTown wasn't killed shows contempt on the part of the scum--by rights, they should be scared.

I think it's a scumploy to lynch the IC since an ace player would be most likely to have that kind of contempt.

There is no way in hell I will support a lynch of Majiffy today based on that reasoning.

I'd rather acquiesce to my own lynch than be manipulated by a scum ploy.

VOTE: TSO

I think our other scum was under pressure yesterday or they would have taken the obvious optimal move, and I think they want to stop any speculation on night kills by making one that makes no sense.

Most likely NKs for tonight assuming we don't win are frog and Majiffy, so I want you both to keep the town aware of your top scumspects at all times Frog, you're up since Jiffy has already fingered me.

[Belisarius]

@Majiffy

Why do you have TSO as town?
Why

don't

you have Who as town?

TBH, I'm predictably disappointed that Who isn't the Doctor. A timelord on our side would be sure victory

[catboi]

Do you think orozorro's first move on replacing in would be to try to bus?

[Wisdom]

Majiffy, you will have to remember why Beli is scum and explain it to us.

[Belisarius]

Do you think orozorro's first move on replacing in would be to try to bus?

Oro's first real attack was on Skullduggery, who flipped town, so no

On mobile, so pre-apologies for the multi-post

Also pre-apologies for my known bias; I tend to see people who attack me as town--it's happened to me correctly too many times (ac1983fan and wisdom) to dismiss it.

[Belisarius]

Majiffy, you will have to remember why Beli is scum and explain it to us.

Last time we played, Nacho did the same thing to me and you didn't question it, and yoy won based on that--what is different about now?

I must admit that I'm leery of Nacho's slot, however, because Nacho has only spoken well of me as scum (Micro 126 saying I was a chessmaster and Newbie 1344 telling Sexcellence to treat me as though I was Nacho)

Flatter the Idiot is a valid stratagem for scum as long as said idiot doesn't know that they're an idiot. ..I've used it as scum before*, so I'd be fully willing to see it as a scum tell if I didn't think that was exactly what the scum wanted.

*As Hamlet, in a hydra. ..looks like I was the idiot in that game since he's still alive

[Wisdom]

Last time we played, Nacho did the same thing to me and you didn't question it, and yoy won based on that--what is different about now?

Nacho is Nacho. Majiffy has done nothing so far other than telling us that you're obvscum without a single reason why. He's not going to get away with it.

[Wisdom]

I think it's a scumploy to lynch the IC since an ace player would be most likely to have that kind of contempt.

And why didnt they just kill the IC and get Skullduggery lynched? Much easier.

[Majiffy]

frog's confirmed town, but I guess you weren't paying attention :3

Guess not. How's frog confirmed?

Hence the "pursuing this line of reasoning causes WIFOM."

If you want to hide behind laziness and lack of critical thinking skills, sure.

Is not explaining anything a requirement for ICs?

Majiffy, care to explain why Belisarius is scum?

And you didn't answer that either.
VOTE: Majiffy
Even you don't know why you're voting who you're voting.

Seeing as I wasn't around to post for the rest of the day phase... you're completely retarded.
And explain to me why coming into this day phase, placing a vote, and not having any reasons off-hand is a scumtell, or optimal scum play?

@Majiffy

Why do you have TSO as town?
Why

don't

you have Who as town?

1) Wagon positioning of flipped scum makes TSO highly unlikely partner
2) Dunno, just don't have a town read on him.

Majiffy, you will have to remember why Beli is scum and explain it to us.

I might get around to it.

Nacho is Nacho. Majiffy has done nothing so far other than telling us that you're obvscum without a single reason why. He's not going to get away with it.

What a pile of bullshit, eh? Wisdom you're smarter than this.

[Wisdom]

Since when do you consider me smart?
Nice try buddying me.