Death's Diner -Game Over-

[TiphaineDeath]

Hmm so you are suggesting slandaar scum rather than rofl scum?

[BROseidon]

^Is that to me?

[TiphaineDeath]

yes.

[Titus]

Here is the order of things:

rofl scumreads me in QT. A few days later, Slandaar also scumreads me. Right after Slandaar suggest that I'm scum, Zoidberg attacks me. Then entire QT scumreads me.

This would suggest that the Zoidberg suggesting Bro scum is a manipulation by one of the members in the deathy. Slandaar's statements could have been a trigger but it's more likely the scum gave Zoidberg a cue word.

Mod: Is the scum player allowed to share the link to the deathy QT with the other scums?

[Rift Adrift]

Here is the order of things:

rofl scumreads me in QT. A few days later, Slandaar also scumreads me. Right after Slandaar suggest that I'm scum, Zoidberg attacks me. Then entire QT scumreads me.

This would suggest that the Zoidberg suggesting Bro scum is a manipulation by one of the members in the deathy. Slandaar's statements could have been a trigger but it's more likely the scum gave Zoidberg a cue word.

Mod: Is the scum player allowed to share the link to the deathy QT with the other scums?

You seem to be assuming no scum day-talk here.

I wouldn't assume that. Syr says that in a prior 4nxiety game scum did have day talk in their QT.

[Baezu]

AJ - obviously my read on her has changed since her last post.

Slandaar -

I don't know if Jabs is scum or not yet. Given the urge to lynch him and the game hasn't really started, I'd go with town for now.

Who said anything about lynching him?

Stubbs was posting that he was voting Varsoon artificially inflating the count to those who weren't watching closely. Paranoia on you because you seem to really want Jabs lynched

lol

'if 7 more people came into the thread and voted Jabs without realising Stubbs was voting he could get lynched!!!' Never going to happen. Just playing the 'lets sound protown' card.

Again; Where did I say I wanted to lynch him?

Random votes are not votes with no reason. They are random in order to start the game. Reasonless votes are suspect, no matter how many are on the train.

Explain why you made a reasonless vote then;

Slandaar, my gut tells me that was not random.

VOTE: oriole

I like the way you are just making things up.

You over reacted for a mental note where even I said I was paranoid.

Well considering I voted you before that your 'argument' doesn't hold.

Very consistently town from the very beginning. Asking for clarification, clarifying misreads, scumhunting. No surprises there.

AA9-

Prod received.
I am here today..will put my thoughts

Her ISO is shit, she hasn't been participating even when she says she will, no reasons for votes, no real value to this game. Not necessarily scum, but obviously not interested enough in this game. Null

TD-

Somebody explain to me why you're all voting jabarkas before I vote Amrun?

Pretty much from the very beginning asks people to explain their votes. Consistent throughout the game about voting deliberately and not at random. Doesn't sheep and sticks to her guns. Town

PV-

peregrine vote zoidberg for towncred!

But I don't want to lynch him.

But,

peer pressure.

Vote: Zoidberg

Similar to AA9 - ISO is shitty - no justification for votes. This^^ which makes no sense whatsoever. Not much contribution or scumhunting. Generally not interested in the game. Null-leaning scum

Oriole -

Notes dump:







I apologize for my shitty handwriting. I'll translate them if required.

Handwritten notes that are very detailed along with a pretty consistent game. Town

[BROseidon]

Hmm so you are suggesting slandaar scum rather than rofl scum?

I would argue it implicates MS and GP more, because scum would want to jump on town vs. town paranoia in the QT. Not that it matters, given that it will all work itself out anyways.

[Titus]

@RA I wasn't assuming no scum day talk. If the scums have access to the deathy QT, they can discuss reads as they are forming. That makes Zoidberg's actions look much more suspect. Furthermore, a lack of qt would mean that Zoidberg could impulsively act to try and increase suspicion on Bro without discussing it with his partners. If they do have a mafia QT, then they planned the Bro FoS together. I'm trying to figure out which is which so we can see how many people might have too much information.

[PeregrineV]

Catch a RIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIDEEEEE!

Played that this weekend. Look that game!

[PeregrineV]

Catch a RIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIDEEEEE!

Played that this weekend. Love that game!

[PeregrineV]

Have to go home now. Top of 60.

[roflcopter]

unvote, vote: zoidberg

[4nxi3ty]

roflcopter (1) - ArcAngel9
Zoidberg

(7)

- Titus, Ghostly Penguin, Rift Adrift, TiphaineDeath, Aunt Jemina, BROseidon, roflcopter
Baezu (4) - oriole, Xiao Long, Amrun, Zoidberg
TiphaineDeath (1) - EddieFenix
Metal Sonic (1) - elvis_knits
elvis_knits (1) - PeregrineV
BROseidon (4) - Slandaar, StubbsKVM, Metal Sonic
Aunt Jemina (1) - Baezu

Not Voting (0) -

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.
(expired on 2013-08-09 10:28:34)

Mod: Is the scum player allowed to share the link to the deathy QT with the other scums?

Any QTs links are not allowed to be shared.

[Baezu]

BRO-

AJ what is your meta for PA being scum because this looks a lot more like town-PA than scum-PA to me.

He's seemed town most of the game to me. He has been asking for clarification, scumhunting, and participating. I'm not sure what exactly he did in the dethy to incur scumminess. I'm willing to believe that he really is scum and just a really good player but I don't feel I can vote him today because from what I can see of his game, he's seemed town to me.

Elvis-

I made a case for him initially, finding his posts scummy but at this point, he has not contributed in quite some time (his last post was #934) and even that post didn't give any reasons or evidence. atm he's moved back into the null pile and I'm waiting to hear more from him

Amrun-

Stubbs:

No.

I still have no idea what the fuck is happening.

I still want Titus to die

Tunneled on Titus in the early game, then has been on my case since then. Seems to play emotionally and base a lot of things on gut or emotionality:

Baezu wagon is good, but I'm emotionally attached to Titus wagon and I'm not unvoting for no good reason.

Nothing wrong with that imo and I haven't played any other games with her to know if this is her usual m.o. Otherwise, been present and posting and contributing but I really haven't seen her break down her reads on everyone (if you did, could you please refer me to that post?) So even though there's been a lot of content, I'm still null on her.

Zoid-

read moar better, are you going to pretend like those are my only posts?

Please quote where I indicated those were your only posts. I was merely highlighting similarities between this game and C&H.

then you dug up a "reason" so....

No, I legit voted you for the lols without having read the game. Then I actually read your play and saw no reason to move the vote.

Brought up some good points to support his voting.

On what planet is rofl town in this game?

This one.

VOTE: Titus

Think Zoidberg might have some sort of confirmation-bias type thing because of C&H.

:/ maybe.

I need to take a step back and be more objective.

Admits that he should stay focused on this game instead of comparing it to another one.

Titus is being a scumfuck

Can you lay out the case on Titus please? Not seeing it.

Asks for clarification and has overall participated in this game. I agree the timing of the reveal of the dethy and Zoid's reaction was poor. But I'm not convinced that it wasn't simply a coincidence. Nothing else in his posts so far indicates to me that he's scummy. I don't feel I can vote him today based solely on bad timing.

[TiphaineDeath]

baezu, you're not getting an AJ lynch today, vote zoidberg with us or tell me why you think he's town.

[Baezu]

Can you give me another reason besides bad timing that you feel makes Zoid scum?

[Amrun]

unvote, vote: zoidberg

Rofl

Explain it to me

I thought you were on my side :'(

But in other news... I like baezu's new content. Well, fuck.

VOTE: aunt jemima

[Rift Adrift]

unvote, vote: zoidberg

Rofl

Explain it to me

I thought you were on my side :'(

But in other news... I like baezu's new content. Well, fuck.

VOTE: aunt jemima

You are an evil temptress.

[Amrun]

[Ghostly Penguin]

unvote. Vote: AJ

I whole heartedly support this new wagon.

[Xiao Long]

Hey look, the wagon I wanted has fans!

VOTE: Aunt J

[Titus]

Zoidberg has been blatantly lurking when convenient buddying having, sheeping etc. I cannot think of a better candidate for a lynch. The bad timing was the clincher. I wouldn't have pushed the Zoidberg lynch if I didn't believe him to be scum.

I do find Xiao's reason credible because he's always wanted AJ, the others are frankly suspicious as hell with their timing. We were moving and pushing towards L-1 and then we aren't.

[Ghostly Penguin]

baezu, you're not getting an AJ lynch today, vote zoidberg with us or tell me why you think he's town.

Why are you so interested in dismissing this wagon? There's a number of people who have AJ as scum, it's something that should be pursued day 1.

You don't have to vote for it, but stopping talk on it, like Zoid's the only wagon today is silly and shaking my read in you.

[Ghostly Penguin]

Zoidberg has been blatantly lurking when convenient buddying having, sheeping etc. I cannot think of a better candidate for a lynch. The bad timing was the clincher. I wouldn't have pushed the Zoidberg lynch if I didn't believe him to be scum.

I do find Xiao's reason credible because he's always wanted AJ, the others are frankly suspicious as hell with their timing. We were moving and pushing towards L-1 and then we aren't.

1. I invite you to read my ISO sometime, then. I've always wanted an AJ push, PA's wanted an AJ push, we're pretty damn happy right now.
2. There's more than three days left in Day 1. Plenty of time for a counter wagon to form, and considering my options are Zoidberg, who I'm not totally vested in as far as the second member of the hydra is concerned, and AJ, which we both want and been pushing and despairing we don't have the votes for? I'm taking AJ and I don't give two fucks what you or TD think.
3. Stop the sophistry of Zoidberg being the only plausable lynch or we have to go all in because it's Day 1.

[Titus]

I didn't say Zoidberg was the only wagon. I said the timing of this counterwagon was suspicious. If y'all always felt AJ was scummy, why wouldn't you have gotten on an AJ train sooner?