Newbie 1454: Mafia Plain and Simple - Game Over

[Xayzeck]

Next page get.

I'd vote for Rach, should we wait for a claim first? Though we'd probably hear VT

[geraintm]

You know there are no more power roles.left in the game, right?

[T S O]

There's no point left claiming.

Geraintm and Xayzeck's non-hammering confirm Rach as scum.

[geraintm]

It doesn't. The two votes on could both be scum.

[pisskop]

im not positive who other scum is, but I wont lose sleep lynching Rach. If ger and tso are scumteam than they deserve cake.

[T S O]

It doesn't. The two votes on could both be scum.

But I'm not scum, so it's confirmed for me.

[geraintm]

True. Does anyone object if I am the hammer then? We could wait for rach, but, you know....

[RachMarie]

I have been in bed sick the past almost 2 days.

Before you all hammer me, give me a chance to make some reads

[Xayzeck]

How funny would it be if it were ger/pisskop lol

Should we wait? We have time but she may use it to confuse us

[T S O]

I have been in bed sick the past almost 2 days.

Before you all hammer me, give me a chance to make some reads

Do it within the next day.

[geraintm]

vote rach

no one objected. Honestly see no point in waiting for rach.

[havingfitz]

Vote Count 3.01

With 5 alive it's 3 votes to lynch.

Voting for:

*geraintm -
*pisskop -

*RachMarie - T S O, pisskop, geraintm [3]

*T S O -
*Xayzeck -

Not voting: Xayzeck, RachMarie [2]

That didn't take long to reach a consensus. At least town was consistent.

RachMarie was a

Vanilla Townie

Congratulations to TSO and pisskop on a perfect scum win.

Scum can post their QT at their leisure.

Here is the Dead QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/J7dCDWVVnrpV

Congrats scum!

[geraintm]

Bah. Will post more later.

[innocentvillager]

lol nice

I should've pushed more for TSO. Damn. He started giving me scummy vibes d2 especially...

Pisskop I probably only would've lynched if it got to the point of lylo. Heh..

Anyway nice job

Lol I hate how scummy Rach appears sometimes especially when she's town

What was the motivation behind killing me?

[Xayzeck]

danggg good job guys

i will hate you two forever now

[Xayzeck]

i just realised TSO was the one who called pisskop's werewolf

wow just wow

[pisskop]

Too smart you were. I was willing to kill geraint night2, but I knew what he would likely do. Mostly. Well kinda. Anywho he agreed on you, iv, and it was fine I guess.

Nithing personsal, Ger. I tried to ride you, and it probably should not have even worked good. It was a mistake I couldnt take back,and probably wont repeat it. Or maybe Iwill, but as town for the metagamers

gga.

And also finally, a new game. Thanks tso for the early help.

[Xayzeck]

yeah, gg. thanks for the help on my first game too guys..

..BUT MAYBE IF YOU ALL DIDN'T LOOK SO TOWN IT'D BE BETTER

lol jk good game

[T S O]

gg guys, I enjoyed faking pisskop's townslip.

I think everyone sorta suspected me, but it was never concrete. That's always something to watch for.

Enjoyed playing with all of you! Good work, pisskop.

[ObsessedWithCats]

The only way I could have been more surprised would have been if Xayzeck had been scum. Well played to say the very least :3

[NJAC]

GG TSO and Pisskop. Town was a disaster this game, but I can't blame the newbies. However OWC you should not self hammer ever as town. Xayzeck did fine. Rach is a disaster as IC.

@havingfitz: Thanks for modding.

[ObsessedWithCats]

I've been hearing 'never self hammer' and 'it was right under the circumstances' from all sides, sometimes from the same people. But if I hadn't I would effectively have given them another nightkill, so I'm not glad that I did but I don't reckon it made all that much of a difference.

[geraintm]

A glad I spotted pisskop was so scummy so early (give me a bit more confidence in future games), but I couldn't convince anyone else. Was a bad town, and I'd echo some of the comments about some of the players.
Felt it came down the last day that 2 out of the three of pisskop, Tso and rach were scum and I wasn't able to push it into a final day because I picked rach over Tso.
I think if town had gone to the last day we might have got it right.

Realise this is me trying to make things not look so bad considering scum had a perfect game.

The self hammer? I am against it. I cannot see a reason a town would vote to remove a town from the game. Just, odd to me. Maybe in some much more complicated scenarios, but not a newbie game. Doesn't send out the right message/tutorial to new players.

Did the new players learn from the game? Enjoy the game?

[BBmolla]

Right when I died:

Well clearly my reads were shit, and scum could have easily used that against me, so I'm a bit surprised.

Being nightkilled night 1 is nice though, makes me feel good

Posskip: Scum?

If so it's with either TSO or Rach, I feel like they'd be the ones to kill me here.

The hammer from Pisskop should have earned him a lynch tbh, but I'm not that unhappy with this game. We just got outplayed and I got the cop lynched d1.

wp folks

[pisskop]

I learned a bit, yup, esp about playing online with relative strangers and no body language.


Any specific advice, point of interest, or failings? Id like to wean all I can from this.