WhoIn post 2213, Nachomamma8 wrote:Lily generally seemed decently town, so Magua gets to skate a little bit by extension.
---
I defaulted to this thinking about Mala as well, but it lasted in my head only until I ran into this post:In post 2132, Sakura Hana wrote:No, mala hates scum roles, i dont think she'd have replaced into notscience's slot if she read it was a scum slot.
God this is so superAmishedtellterribad. It literally is saying "Welp I know that my predecessor was pretty scummy but that was them and this is me and I'm going to pre-emptively dismiss all of that." It's all very =/. I'm incapable of having a townread on notscience as a player, but I was really hoping that I'd be able to get an easy townread on Mala and I don't have it.In post 2161, Malakittens wrote:Man you are lucky ns is sick and replaced out because he'd be screaming his head off at you because he hates when people accuse him of scum when he's not and your reads have been so bad. You'll be sitting in the dead QT shaking your head when you see afterall that we are town and you hardpushed a town since you replaced in.
I can't defend myself from my pred's actions, so how about you actually give something that I have done scummy. You are attacking a slot who's owner is not here to defend themselves against anymore.
But Pim is still scummier, because Pim's posts are delays: "will get to this," "soon", etc, followed up with no follow through. Pim just feels like scum who is trying to drag but not actually wanting to post content to avoid tying to anyone. The only argument against Pim-scum that I've seen is "loldoublevoter" which, as someone who has had a scum doublevoter in a role madness game, I find less than compelling.
So.
I'm encouraged by Victor not voting Pim, that makes me super happy, and am discouraged by Malakittens voting Pim, so they balance out. I find Malakitten's discredting of notscience super-goddamn-scummy, way more than I ever found notscience himself. But both Pim and Victor are much scummier.
Sakura remains town, Varsoon remains town, vezok remains town (thank-fucking-god).
Scumwise, S->W it's Victor, Pim, Mala.