a) Math I can provide you like 4 town games where I've made the exact same argument. I even wrote an article about this.
(
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=13710) come on dude. COME ON.
b) Can be faked is obviously a possibility. I was asking you if you really think its what's most likely. Do you think I'm really faking setup spec in order to bring it up when someone attacks me on gut later on? Again, check my meta. I'm not sure but I think you'll find I never do this.
c) What is the scum motivation for pointing it out?
d) I'M NOT ASKING FOR TOWN POINTS. I'm saying "is this action more likely to come from town or scum" if you say scum than you're an idiot, straight up.
Stop with the confirmation bias, pls.
Motivations are pure. You look to who the play helps in order to determine what it is more likely to be the alignment of the person doing it. You can "fake this" sure, but its hard because if you play against your win condition enough you lose the game.