In post 548, Slandaar wrote:Uh NakedJogger we were discussing how you are adamant that bad = scummy and I asked you a question. I see no answer.
(Don't worry we can skip that part)
Are you going to provide new reasoning for your vote?
I don't feel like I need to. There's no point in equating Moon's ability to play mafia to that of a 5-year old child, so I won't address any pseudo-arguments that stem from it.
I will however go into detail as to how I prioritize when establishing the extend to which a player is suspicious/scummy.
1. Cred - Involvement in getting townies/scum lynched
2. Quality of reasons and argumentation to vote/call someone scummy with regard to experience, perceived intelligence level and emotional constitution
3. What they talk about (scums tend to talk about meaningless issues, because they can blend in easily without the risk of slipping)
4. Interactions/Consistency/Curiosity/Possible Motive
Moon has shitty cred because he's been voting my slot and nobody else for a long ass time for bad reasons. He chose to talk about general probabilities and I'm under the impression that he's not very curious judging by hi lackluster scumhunting.
He seems fairly intelligent if not for his fail at math which can be faked as scum, driving a mislynch would be a sufficient motive. Furthermore he's an experienced player judging by his join date.
In post 541, WoodyWoodpecker wrote: In post 539, Ricastle wrote:Fellow town, I propose at the very least a policy lynch on Woody for his general antitown shit-stirring play and most notably the bullshit shown above. Nothing progressive will come out of his further involvement in this game and he needs to learn the hard way that he cannot go on with this behaviour.
Yes policy Lynch me for winning the argument and proving both you and elusive lied.
I am not "shit stirring" I'm responding to your accusations and proving you wrong in the process.
I've done nothing anti-town either.
I'd like to defend elusive's menstrual ragequit and what lead to it but I can't. All I can is provide you with an example of how a friend of elusive, MathBlade lied about something and tunneled me almost to death with it despite both of us being town. I even jokingly said that elusive and MathBlade are the same person because their gamestyle seemed so similar and pointlessly stupid. Maybe you can see where I'm coming from if you read this. Maybe not.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p6616080
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6638437
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6638587
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 9#p6638869
Believe it or not.. exactly what you call lying is a widespread occurrence among (bad) townies. If you're town just be glad she replaced out because she wouldn't have admitted to anything and the thread would have been drenched in flame and rendered unreadable. You have made your points and anyone who reads the thread has registered your arguments. Unless you bring something new to the table try to be concise from now on or else risk people ignoring your input; or worse loosing enthusiasm for the game. If you are scum go on.