In post 3648, PeregrineV wrote:
Then argue there are 3 scum, and thus 3 unknown.
Or argue there are 5 scum, and thus only one unknown.
Having no opinion on the number of scum remaining does not really point towards you "trying to figure out the game".
I didn't say I have no opinion, you are likely right about 4, what I'm questioning is your level of confidence. And I'm questioning why you're using circular logic to defend your confidence. (We should massclaim because we have exactly 4 scum, I know we have 4 scum based on information that will come out if we massclaim). And I'm questioning why you're holding back on information that would appear to help town.
Sinsun1 wrote:In post 3646, Riabi wrote:
I don't have any "math" because "math" requires dealing with known numbers, and that's the issue, we don't have any known numbers. Sure, I acknowledge that you claim to have known numbers, but that doesn't really help any of the rest of us.
Caught in a lie. That or stupidity. Math is about solving unknown numbers, hence this entire section of math called Algebra that deals with variables and branches off to much more complicated math to solve for unknown numbers.
Ask yourself a question... Why would Riabi put the word math in quotes like that if he was then going to use it in a slightly different manner than the word might be traditionally used?