Open 612 - Bad Poets Society - Game Over - Town Win

[The Fire Hermit]

Goddamn, I was really considering making a

page top

with that last post.

Mine

[St Constantine the Hermit]

ONE MORE THING...

I was just thinking that for Klingoncelts rage to be serious, she would have to be equally angry at Ika and other slots which have lurked up to now and offered much less than I have, even if some of my posts are not exactly super serious.

[The Fire Hermit]

Lol, sorry firebringer, I was posting out of hydra

[Vedith]

You're supposed to be the fucking Town Leader, but you're nothing but a dumbass troll.

Since when did an IC have more knowledge than us? It's day 1, you won't ever have everyone with the exact opinion, regardless if confirmed town or not.

Hello Town Vedith, lovely day isn't it?

It certainly is, my town friend!

I repeat, you two really need to replace out.

Just because you don't agree with someone doesn't mean that they should replace you pleb.

Just makes me believe this is fake raging. I find it hard to believe that any player here, especially you in particular, would overreact to a post like that without it being intentional.

I can see this... An early discredit to the IC.

Scum are also going to exploit my reputation for their advantage.

What is your rep?

[The Fire Hermit]

Hold on buddy, my ass gets kissed enough by people in real life

[The Fire Hermit]

Not answering that question either. Don't see any reason to talk about

me

. I am not important, and that is kinda my whole entire point.

Klingon probably wants to exploit me, and you are giving me the impression that you are out to do the same for town credit.

[Vedith]

Hold on buddy, my ass gets kissed enough by people in real life

Who's this at?
My comment wasn't to stick up for you, but to show the fault in the comments given.
Don't jump too far ahead.

[Vedith]

Not answering that question either. Don't see any reason to talk about me. I am not important, and that is kinda my whole entire point.

Klingon probably wants to exploit me, and you are giving me the impression that you are out to do the same for town credit.

I think that you have the wrong end of the stick again.
I asked because you decided to bring it up. imo, if you bring it up, you want to discuss it.
If I want town credit, I can easily get it today/tonight, I don't need you for that.

[goodmorning]

That doesn't mean I don't agree with you either, Klingon. It is true that Fire Hermit has been a pretty trolly IC, even extremely so, but don't flip out over it.

tbqh they are a lot less troll-y than the last time i saw either of them play

so

You're supposed to be the fucking Town Leader, but you're nothing but a dumbass troll.

Since when did an IC have more knowledge than us? It's day 1, you won't ever have everyone with the exact opinion, regardless if confirmed town or not.

The IC actually has less knowledge than the rest of us; we all know the roles of 2 people (4 for Scum), they only know 1.

Ika Musume - Ika straight-out claims to be playing by his Scum meta. Does that mean he's Scum? If it does, then he's playing against his win condition. Town.

You're going to townread him based on WIFOM?
Newsflash: people claim Scum as Scum all the time. It doesn't go against anyone's wincon.

The last time I saw a scummy claim her alignment she got modkilled and ate a ban.

Kc

You know, I didn't even notice that you ignored my most important sentence here: I've also said I'm playing to my Scum meta. If you're townreading Ika for that - and it must be for that alone, because he hasn't done much else - why aren't you townreading me for the exact same thing?

You also didn't answer my question about the mod, so I've answered it for you:
NS modkilled elusive in NY181 for being a dick, basically.
ika modkilled NJ and elusive in NY180 for p much the same reason.
Monkey modkilled RIP in DS9 for quoting from his role PM.
Micc modkilled Whatisswag for claiming Scum. I assume this is the one you mean? He literally claimed his entire role, made it abundantly clear that he wasn't joking, and

asked to be modkilled

. That's a far cry from this or any one of the trillion other times I've seen people claim Scum.
tbqh I probably would have just let them lynch him.

I literally had to go through all your games for that, so thanks for wasting my time!

[duppin]

@Vedith, Hermit's point is that there is no reason to discuss it since he is confirmed town and I agree.

I like most of Brunneis reads, but not entirely sure what to think of the town read on me. It does feel a bit like buddying, but meh.

[Vedith]

@Vedith, Hermit's point is that there is no reason to discuss it since he is confirmed town and I agree.

Then I'm not sure why he brought it up.

[goodmorning]

Oh, and here's the reason he ate that ban, btw:

Whatisswag has been banned from all Mafia games for a month for sending a player in an ongoing game an unsolicited PM with reads and commentary on their play. His PM access has also been revoked during that time period.

So thanks for misrepresenting the situation!

[MaxwellPuckett]

@Vedith, Hermit's point is that there is no reason to discuss it since he is confirmed town and I agree.

I like most of Brunneis reads, but not entirely sure what to think of the town read on me. It does feel a bit like buddying, but meh.

I'm guessing you missed my question, which is understandable.

Are you favouring Trivium or Brunneis more for scum right now? Also, do you have any concrete reads based on the current gamestate?

[The Fire Hermit]

@Vedith
Yeah, what duppin said...
I do not see why you asked me about my reputation, because it really doesn't make a goddamn difference anyways.

[duppin]

Sorry Maxwell, I missed it.

I'm not entirely sure yet. The town read on me feels like buddying. Trying to determine whether that is the case or not. I don't know who I would vote for at the moment though.
I do have other reads yes, but you'll have to wait.

[duppin]

I just found your post now. About the "telling players to prove their towniness", you are reading too much into it. It was simply me calling her out because I wanted to engage her.

[goodmorning]

what up with all the false dichotomies in this game eh?

[Errantparabola]

how so, gm?

[Errantparabola]

also, I'll do some more things with this game in a few hours
sorry about my lack of acctivity.

[MaxwellPuckett]

Sorry Maxwell, I missed it.

I'm not entirely sure yet. The town read on me feels like buddying. Trying to determine whether that is the case or not. I don't know who I would vote for at the moment though.
I do have other reads yes, but you'll have to wait.

Alright, I'll do so.

I just found your post now. About the "telling players to prove their towniness", you are reading too much into it. It was simply me calling her out because I wanted to engage her.

Yeah, by the end of that I figured I was, kinda. The phrase itself just brings bad vibes for me, I guess. I'm glad you responded, though.

[Errantparabola]

ONE MORE THING...

I was just thinking that for Klingoncelts rage to be serious, she would have to be equally angry at Ika and other slots which have lurked up to now and offered much less than I have, even if some of my posts are not exactly super serious.

I think it's more of her perception of you as the town leader and her higher standards thereof. That being said, she has yet to answer to your response (being you don't have to be the town leader, etc. etc.)

Varsoon goes from 128 and 234 to 260 and I am strongly interested as to what he has to say about this inconsistency.

VOTE: Varsoon

[goodmorning]

how so, gm?

Well, the big one I'm seeing is Trivium vs Brunneis. Do you not?

[The Fire Hermit]

Yeah, definitely scum between the two.
I got firebringer to cave in and compromise for a Brunneis lynch. That means our vote will not be changing at all, which also means scum or any holdout townies just need to give up and join the wagon.

[Brunneis]

Finally gotten around to post my part, this week has been an emotional rollercoaster, and I'm still a bit busy... :/

I read it, but my opinion is that none of them are very helpful for me to come up with scumreads.

Well, I have a very similar feeling back at you, does that mean I'm scum because of it?

I could definitely see Ika being scum.
Especially with association now to Brunneis.



Fire

Not quite; I haven't gotten the chance to speak my say on the readslist.

I agree with Klingon, but I don't see Ika as town, and I don't like how Gray looks either.

And even though I agree with the rest of her townreads, Max is the only townread I am pretty confident about.

Brunneis (Klingon)
I am going to level with you, I don't think you are scum like my other head does.
I think you are town, I wanted to test you a bit on reactions. I don't like your reactions at all, but I think they seem genuine althought that has fooled me before.

I don't like your scum reads, the only one I agree on is Trivium. I think one on GM is bad and Ranger is pretty obv town.

Thats where I am at right now,

-Fire

@Firebringer

I know you wanted Kling to respond, but you, Max, makara, and every other lurker in the game are the only people who haven't stated that my (Taly's posts) posts as either scummy, useless, or "just to

defend myself and push others

- clear myself as town" - so I feel like I could speak to you.

But my vote is on Trivium. Personally, I am not liking the idea of GM being town, and I've seen games where early aggressive "town" have flipped scum, so I can't say Ranger is town either. Trivium has bugged both heads of this hydra the entire game - and I don't really trust what they say because I keep picking up some very odd phrases - and I don't think people are acknowledging that.

(Which I've stated some in 288)

I'm not going to argue with your other head, Fire. It has been inquired on why he thinks I'm scummy - by myself - most of all, but nobody has gotten a reply - and he likes to think that their 3rd vote on my wagon is the one that is leading my wagon. The only thing I understand about this is that it is harming town, but I'm not excusing anything I - my other head - or anyone else who could have contributed to that.

In any case, the deadline is in 2 1/2 days, I believe. We need to begin solidifying our votes

>>>>

And I'm speaking to everyone with this statement.

I'm not opposed to a Varsoon lynch if nobody sees Trivium a conducive enough lynch to push against him at this point.

And yeah.... This is where

I am at

, right now.

[makara]

Here's where I'm at. I think Ika is probably scum.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Ika

pie head here. my major priority game-wise just ended and i'm free tomorrow, so i should be able to

catch up

take over the world then.

promises to catch up and then posts like 3 fluff posts since then

It occurs to me that ika's kinda playing to his Scum meta atm.

Kinda? I'm 100% doing ym scum meta intentionaly i was waiting for ppl to realzie it.

Hi gm how ar eyou

this is such a shitty defense I can't even


If I had to choose between Brunneis and Trivium I would say that Trivium is more likely to be scum based on his awful defense. However, I think it's pretty scummy to make today's lynch a choice between these two players.