In post 663, pistachi0n wrote:The SS wagon is terrible.
Vote 1: SirCakez, who's been scumreading SS since the joke post
21. Also, I'm still scumreading Cakez, so I'm biased because of that.
Vote 2: Titus, also scumreading SS since the beginning, claiming he was caught scum early on. Same thing with the
21. I don't agree with her reasoning for why SS was scum--it was the infamous post 21, and "telegraphing," but didn't give thorough reasons besides those weak ones.
Vote 3: PhantomCobalt, because of "useless theory fluff." Didn't give an example of what the useless theory fluff was, didn't push beyond that.
Vote 4: Yonom, because SS was jumping to conclusions too fast and too randomly. I don't think this was as bad as the other votes, but I disagree with it. I think it's an issue of playstyle--we have people like Cerb who are stingy with their votes and don't use unless almost certain, and we have players like SS who move the vote around to indicate who their current top scumread is.
Vote 5: Extrapolated Eagle, who voted SS after he stopped scumreading Cakez. The vote seems largely arbitrary, EE is scumreading SS for a lot of the same reasons he's townreading AI. SS doesn't seem like someone trying to blend in.
Top scum-reads are Cakez, AI, and Titus.