In post 296, Thor665 wrote:Zyf assuredly counts as defense, and Loop was defending her also.
It's also a duck of a question, you're acting like lack of defense equates to town (which is already a shaky reality, for example, I've defended Hark, I'm town, so it has no bearing on him being scum - ergo the tell is empty) and then choosing to rule out yourself and others without actually clarifying how much defense is needed.
Zyf put her at L-1, he didn't resist the wagon. Period. Surely I can see Martha's wagon was not that hard to defend, so why at least one of her supposed scum partners wouldn't try to release some pression on that wagon?
I don't say lack of defense equates to town every time, but in this specific game, given the way that wagon formed, I'm leaning to think she's town. Ergo the tell is not empty, because is not a generalization but rather a specifc tell on how things happened in this specific game.
Why are you even talking about how much defense is needed? It's not like there's a number or something. It obviously depends on context. It may happen that there's no defense at all, and still get a scum flip.
So, no, I'm not basing my read on that slot only on the lack of defense towards his wagon, but also on her reaction, with seems to me like genuine frustrated newbtown.
Still working on it. As I said I need to reread, but my focus is in {Thor, Harko, BBT, Naru, Io}.
In post 296, Thor665 wrote:Well...for starters, byher own admission she wasn't new.
But even if she was new (which is factually untrue) what prevents her from being frustrated newbscum in your eyes?
Really want an answer here.
She said she was an alt, she said she played in another site. I still think she's new to the standards of this site. I've seen this kind of frustration from newbtown before.
I might obviously be wrong and maybe that slot is scum, but my stance for now is that she's town. In fact texcat posts also feel town.