Okay, so this is what I have.
Maverick1102
- I like the pushing Phantom. It could be a case of going for the primary lynch but he's spot on with his questions about Phantom - How is Phantom not lynched?! I do worry that you are tunnel visioned only on Phantom, can you provide reads of others? Remember, there are 2 scum.
reso
- I feel the reaction to the L1 was over exaggerated. What I didn't like though, was the voting before hand and putting RyanK and IV as his suspects with the impression that he doesn't care who is lynched from them. The reasoning was bad as well, because he used him in an example. I didn't feel that he was trying to pressure with his vote, so I'm not sure what he was hoping for by voting other than looking town. His stops voting IV (keeping in mind he barley mentions him, even though his vote is still on IV) and turns to Maverick briefly. Giving a 3 strike policy lynch rule is terrible and anti town. Policy lynches are always anti town imo (Go on, challenge me with that comment!).
96 /
103 I don't like how these posts are presented. It's like he was trying to distance himself from the wagon before the flip. If he was that angry, he would gave pressured instead of giving out a warning. Hammering so soon in the day is a strong scum tell generally(I don't believe that he realised it was a hammer).
0x40
- The "slip" is hardly a slip at all. VaxKiller is wrong, however, it doesn't mean that it's a slip at all. By your comment you are saying that you agree that RyanK is scum with VaxKiller. If that's the case, then why are you not voting RyanK instead of VaxKiller? If you doubt at all that RyanK is scum, then your entire argument here is flawed. Also, going by the comment, it can be taken in many ways... Town can be so sure (not a good idea, but happens) that someone is scum that they put all their bets there. This was mean that RyanK would be the better vote from VaxKiller based on your argument. Nothing else really stands out, I can see you have somewhat experience, but I'm assuming that slip ups occur differently from where you play.
Your other body did not post - Null
VaxKiller
-
362 - This post in town mindset. I don't agree with it, because his argument is why didn't Phantom pretend he didn't see? Town credit for a start. I like the reasoning and options he gave though. Issue here is, only issue is that he gave 2/3 scenarios where Phantom is scum but automatically went for the mostly likely scum action for the L2 vote alone. This read is currently null overall but I still really like the post.
Pushy the game forward getting people to look else where.
InnocentVillager
- His push was too quick. He opened the game strongly, he gave reason to discuss. Scum prefer a slow paced less talking town, it helps them hide, the fact he pushed this straight away is good.
His reaction to his wagon was perfectly fine. There was lack of reason to put him that far ahead instantly anyway. He reacted to the L1 from Phantom, which is good but I'm a little surprised he didn't back it up more.
107 - Basically poking the 2 people that could easily lynch him off if they want. As scum, there's no need to give multiple targets a reason to question you or vote you, here he was giving them a reason to push back on, which luckily wasn't taken. Would like to see a catch up post from IV as due to his V/LA content slowed down.
RyanK
- I quite like as a townlean. I like that he challenges HipLop and Maverick. And so right he should there. Personally, I like when a newbie challenges the IC. A lot would find them intimidating due to their status. As newbie scum, do you really want to get into a debate with an IC? (Keep in mind, I don't see IC as any difference to SE players on their knowledge with the site / games, but that's after you get a feel for the game).
HipLop
- Only person I've played with here. Standard readings I have trouble with him. I find his late game is stronger than early but not sure if I buy the IV meaning something else thought. Not a lot on here but I'd like to see more interaction.
Not a fan of his reads yet, would like to here his opinion on Colbalt.
PhantomCobalt
- In no way shape or form would Colbalt and IV be scum together, just want to throw that out there. Puts IV onto L1 (Yes I know this has been mentioned) and doesn't react to his own mistake, only to my other body. However, he has been caught out on a lie.
91 /
92 - He reacts as if the hammer went through. Keep in mind
both
posts are at the same time.
Then to follow up, he posts this -
93 /
108.
Now, who acts like that to putting someone to L1 and removes their vote?Keep in mind this slot is an SE, L1 happens all the time, and if you don't like it, you simply unvote and question to why they put them to L1, not react like this. Also, the first thing I did reading the game was look to see if my other bodies votes were ever taken, I suspect that the other SE and IC done this as it's standard on this site. I suspect that he fully knew that Rusty's vote didn't count and unvoted for the town credit.
You have to keep in mind this post
46 - He says here that SE's do not react to wagons as they know they will not be lynched 99% of the time. Why would it differ from lynching a newbie to an SE, the odds are still the same (if not less).
My other body left quite a while ago, Phantom didn't vote form him site flaking, as soon as I came in and said I will be voting him, he automatically pushes back to me with a weak reason (considering again, he is an SE).
His other reasons are POE - meaning he has decided who town is already, and the hammer that never worked is a terrible reason.
I see no actual scum hunting going on.
Link up wise... I'm not too sure. Possibly Cobalt and 0x40, but I feel that's too obvious. Plus I have stronger reads on Phantom and Reso for scum.
VOTE: PhantomCobalt
That is L1.
