In post 2049, VP Baltar wrote:Going to give my full take on the game because I think things have actually sorted somewhat clearly at this point already.
Not_Mafia
- hearing no counter to his vig shot, seems to be town. (There's no way a normal would put an extra killing scum's hands for a night would it?)
Geraintm
- his informed role about a strongman seems legit considering town had a roleblocker. He's either gutsy af scum, or just plain town.
Norwegian
- His push on George D1 seems pretty legit to me after I reviewed it. Could have been a preplanned bus, but I didn't get that vibe from his posting.
Luca
- He seems to be solving today. I'm not sure on the actual reasons people are saying they suspect him other than
~hand waving~
meta.
Anya
- lol, I mean whatever. Probably town, but I've got no clue.
AliceK
- Really haven't seen any substance here yet.
All the scum are likely in this pile:
innocent villager
- Not sure if it's just style clashing here, but I didn't like his waffling on Anya and George yesterday, or his kind of overstating his importance today. IDK. Something about him is just pinging me weird. I could be wrong here though.
Gypyx
- Lots of unexplained reads throughout the game, and doesn't seem to have a clear viewpoint on the game. Not looking great. Kind of camped on George without hard pushing it.
Iconeum
- Already stated why I think this is scum.
your NM townread is meh. his claim forces it, and is actually a gift here
geraint remains town, even tho i'd just *want* to scumread him ya feel - nothing special
same goes for norwegian, i doubt he's bussing that strong on day 1 but what do i know
luca is definitely in the wrong spot. maybe i'm biased, but i strongly feel he needs me dead here for reasons that go beyond just scumreading me
that you have anya as a nullread is fine, but aliceK should be scummier? Anya is doing things *her* way and kinda picked up after pressure yesterday
aliceK seems to be actively avoiding contributing anything, but i should need to reread ISO because i cant really remember much about this slot
i don't like the IV scumread, i think he's town. Switch with luca. He feels more solvey in any case. Less agenda-y
Gypyx goes higher as well - imo. Why? I don't really know. I don't scumread him. His posts don't feel forced.