Mini 1393 - Oh, what a year!

[charter]

Vote Angry Pidgeon

[charter]

Just got back into town, will post tonight, dont want to be replaced!

[charter]

Voting is THE way to get answers and defenses for peoples votes and actions through pressure. If I see someone say something scummy Day 1, I'm going to vote for them. Day 1 is going to inevitably end in a lynch based off of WIFOMY evidence, weak cases, conjecture, gut reads and wild guesses with no real evidence to go off on. It's the INTERACTIONS' from Day 1 that matter. And it's going to be a lot easier for the players in this game to see where I stand when they can see where my vote has been.

Unvote, vote smashboard

Let's see what kind of response you give (though I do completely agree with your post).

Here is the scum.

Vote Metalmarsh

On top of this contradiction of a post, all his posts are pretty much wallflower posts.

The Thor and AngryPidgeon argument is a colossal waste of time.
Thor, your read on metal? Your read on Bacde?
Smash, anything to say other than raging about how you weren't labeled town?

[charter]

I see you've given a read (obvtown) on Badce, Thor, is it the same or has it changed?

[charter]

Charter is mainly a scumread for calling us town V town.

Where did I call your back and forth town v town? I said it was a waste of time. I don't find either of you town.

Metal is most definitely scum. AngryPidgeon is looking pretty bad for defending him while there was still a chance of Metal not getting lynched today and then voting me for catching Metal.

Why do you want Thor's read? Are you mafia and looking for the opinion of a townie to try and back your claim?

I want to get a better read on Thor, which I can do by seeing what he thinks on scummy/townish players.

Thor, please explain:

What's the Metal case?

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 8#p4473928

There - that should head off your 'but where's the case' immediate next reply after another few days of lurk.

[charter]

AngryPidgeon is looking pretty bad for defending him

When did I defend metal? I didn't even really notice him in this game until this page >.>

Unless you mean attacking you, in which case :

Fine, if you think Thor and I are not town, why are our posts useless? Surely there is something in them indicative of alignment?

Charter could be scum. Oh, Voldemort too.

Not feeling Metalscum right now

, Slandaar could you explain your Metal scumread?

Your posts are useless banter severely clogging up the thread. I saw nothing between you two indicative of alignment, did you (I don't really see a definitive read one way or another from you on Thor)? I don't actually care to debate this point any further since it's entirely irrelevant and you're just trying to use it to try and save a little face because your vote was so bad.

[charter]

So your what's the metal case was referring to Bcade's vote only?

[charter]

It doesn't matter to me, I'm fairly certain Metal is going to flip scum, and you're making the case to lynch you next even easier for me.

[charter]

Bacde, if Cooldog is such a great vote for not posting, what's your read on Slandaar and Senjai?

[charter]

Bacde, if Cooldog is such a great vote for not posting, what's your read on Slandaar and Senjai?

Bacde, please answer.

[charter]

Denis, why do you think Thor is scum?

[charter]

Its my gut feeling Charter.

Gut feeling isn't a read one way or another on Slandaar or Senjai.

[charter]

What do you want me to say charter? I already said I don't have a read on them.

I don't see where you've said that. I see you single out Cooldog for lurking, but you actually don't give a damn about lurking because you ignore two bigger lurkers.

I eagerly await Denisatp's reasoning for thinking Thor is scum. It had better be mindblowing to have to wait so long for it to come.

[charter]

That's clearly not true. I was going to wait for your Thor reasoning before voting, but it sounds like you don't have any.

From what I can tell, this is the case on Thor:

VOTE: thor

he's a huge fag

Anyways... In other news;
Thor is scum

VOTE: Thor

Thor is scum with Metalmarsh because a) he is bullshitting around, and b) when all the pressure first happened on Metalmarsh happened, Thor completely ignored it.

Lynch these clowns.

So, Voldermort has actually given a reason, but this is far from a strong case. And "outing it at this point would be just telling him how i want him to act and allowing him to AtE" is bs.

Unvote, Vote Denisatp

[charter]

What am I scared of?

[charter]

Yeah, let's all sheep AP, he's clearly a genius

[charter]

Ugh. Of the Thor, Cooldog, and AP wagons, AP is the only one that doesn't have scummy people on it.

Unvote, vote AP

[charter]

If you're not pushing your case (which none of you three are), then your vote is useless.

[charter]

Oh look, 10 pages later I find out what I'm scared of. Why should I be pushing thor?

[charter]

The lulz!

[charter]

Anytime you guys want to lynch Denis, let me know.

[charter]

olloolololololol

[charter]

So I can't help but notice, but we still have four useless voters. I'm pretty sure that was the case five pages ago, so.... Get on with the useful voting or something.

[charter]

AP has claimed scum twice on one page! That's probably the record.

[charter]

I'll be honest, I'm pretty much done reading the thread until day two. Absolutely nothing of value has come from the last 10-15 pages, and I'm not going to read another 10-15 of this crap.

[charter]

Here's why I'm not cool with the Voldemort being our white knight: he just popped in out of nowhere.

Only after Mastin called him out for not posting.

[charter]

What am I scared of now? LV?

[charter]

you've been playing this game for 5 years and you're incapable of appearing or acting anywhere close to town.

You've been playing this game for 1 year and you're incapable of discerning anyone's alignment.

CWUTIDIDTHUR

[charter]

Was out of town for thanksgiving, should be able to post tonight.

[charter]

Read up, so it's pretty obv I was Thor's neighbor. I'd vote metal, but I'll give anyone who wants to continue the day more time.

[charter]

Yeah, just us two.

[charter]

What are you smoking?

[charter]

Is smash really this dumb or is he scum?

[charter]

Vote Bacde

Total scum.

[charter]

I don't think Smash is scum. Prolly not mastin or maybe AP. That leaves PM or denis as his buddy probably.

[charter]

I think Mastin and Smash are town. Cooldog is town. I'm town. That leaves two of Slandaar, Matt, and Denis. I'll have to reread a little bit this weekend before I can tell which is the third townie.

[charter]

Please no one hammer anyone until I get a chance to read on sat.

[charter]

Vote Matt

Smash is town.

[charter]

Matt and denis are the scums.

[charter]

Ok, so smash is at L-1. I have role based knowledge that he's town. I'm confirmed town, and now Smash is too.

Matt is obvious scum, Denis is likely his partner, but this game is over.

[charter]

Ok, so Slandaar is conf scum. Looks like Denis is town.

[charter]

Matt confirmed scum too.

[charter]

I don't actually have any info, but Slandaar bit.

[charter]

If you're town, who is the other scum? Everyone else is townier than you, sooooo

[charter]

If you're town, who is the other scum? Everyone else is townier than you, sooooo

I'll figure it out.

Very reassuring...

[charter]

Mastin could be his buddy.

No

[charter]

Why is Mastin town?

The question everyone but you is asking is why are you town.

[charter]

When were you both at L-1?

[charter]

I for one think that matt is town

That would mean you are scum.

[charter]

So, I'm actually a cop. Slaandar is obvscum (though I didn't investigate him). I got a non town result on Denis (also scum) last night. Soooooo, this game is over. My neighbor topic was never unlocked since Thor died day one.

Vote Slaandar

If anyone cares, my other targets were Mastin, AP, and Smash. Obviously they are all town. I took back my claim yesterday since it was incredibly obvious who I investigated if I had died last night (though clearly Mastin protected me) and you all would have quickly figured it out.

[charter]

To expound a little, I took the claim back because it was useless at that point since Smash was already lynched.

[charter]

Matt, you're wasting your time, we just have to wait for Cooldog to get in here and hammer. Night could last 10 minutes for all I care, one of the three of us gets killed, and we lynch Denis tomorrow.

Nothing to do before Cooldog hammers.


I also love how Denis is pushing this stalker theory (of which I've never heard of a stalker) but he hasn't heard of such a common role as a miller, but that's neither here nor there.

[charter]

If you don't think Mastin was protecting me and got killed when I'm confirmed town and when I was so obviously a powerrole AFTER I CLAIMED A POWERROLE YESTERDAY TO SAVE A TOWNIE, then...... I shouldn't finish this sentence.

If I was scum, my motivation for trying to save Smashbard and outing Slandaar yesterday was ___________.

[charter]

And I was confirmed town since day one and made it to end game!

[charter]

Well, If you or Cooldog has anything for me, let me know, else I'm done posting until Day Five.

[charter]

Confirmed town since day one and alive at endgame!!!!!

[charter]

MOD, Prod on Cooldog please!

[charter]

MOD, Prod on Cooldog please!

Replace?

[charter]

Vote Count 61 (VI)

Not Voting: denisatp, projectmatt, charter, Slandaar, CooLDoG

Four alive, Three to lynch.

Slandaar is dead

Vote Denis

Still obvscum. Investigated Cooldog last night.

[charter]

and

prod/replace on cooldog

.

I think that is Denis's plan, count on cooldog flaking and somehow pulling off a miracle.

[charter]

Scumslip that Thor was the only mafia powerrole.

Keep comin' at me bro. I'll point out your mistakes all day long.

[charter]

I'm confirmed town.
I got a guilty on Denis.

That's my case.

[charter]

I was neighbors with Thor who was scum.

[charter]

You can ask, but I've already said, it was never unlocked since Thor died day one.

[charter]

MOD, what is the prod/replacement status of Cooldog?

[charter]

It. Was. Never. Unlocked.

[charter]

Are you thinking that me and Thor are both scum neighbors on the same scumteam? I don't think that's allowed in normal games, it's considered bastard.

I'm clearly a neighbor with Thor, he can't be a neighbor by himself, and I claimed on day two with no one ever countering. I don't understand what you keep trying to get at.

Mastin died protecting me, since he thought I was confirmed town and I claimed a powerrole. He can't have died protecting me if I'm not town. If you look back to the day Smash was lynched, it's so clear all I did was drop hints at my role and my info. If you look from day four on (really the first time I could post after day one), my play is glaringly town. Day one I was hesitant about lynching Thor because Thor getting lynched was the worst case scenario for me. Either he's town (and I wagered a powerrole since I was one too) and that immediately paints a target on my back, or he's scum and I die that night since I would be confirmed town and town loses a cop. Day two and three I think I had like two posts, so not much to go on there. For whatever reason, scum didn't kill me and let me fly under the radar to the end racking up investigations. That's what outed Slandaar and that's what caught Denis.

I think you're over complicating an easy vote.

[charter]

Because he is scum and claiming miller after being fingered is his only prayer.

[charter]

I was hoping you would.

[charter]

http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/XBN566LrqHYFD
Just for you Matt.

Good work town. Lynching Thor day one was crucial, that let us sail. Did you guys not realize I was confirmed town after that? Why did you never kill me?