Really excited for this one
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
Kinda busy irl today, but will be around tomorrow!
VOTE: towlie hiya bork and notsci!!!
~ skitter
i don't know, but i also don't know why town-mm do this whole thing, and i don't believe their scumread on gamma is real.In post 776, Wisdom wrote:Why do scum MM even do this whole thing
like none of this makes sense, it's looking for reasons to call gamma scummyIn [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13080936#p13080936]post 727[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:Gamma is never widely townread like this unless he's scum and that was just a failed scum gambit. I disagree with pooky that he did it to get town cop killed. I think he did it to look like wrong town which people take pity on.
i dont' really think he stumbled in early game, and i think that this doesn't look like scum-himIn post 791, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:I've noticed what you're saying about Dunn, but the early game from him stumbled HARD and I'm unwilling to give it a complete pass. I'm curious what you see there that overshadows, or maybe even explains(?) the early garbage play.
fwiw i think you're conflating 'being very confident in my reads' with 'i know (due to my role pm) that 2 people are tvt'In post 797, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:Wisdom, it's not a scumread. You literally cannot know that for certain on Day 1 unless your role PM is red. This is a logical necessity. The only way you can derive that information is if you know the alignments of all players involved.
The only way you know the alignments of all players involved is if you are scum, since there are two factions and you know all the scum.
QED, if you state that with certainty those two are TvT, you are scum.
Do you state with certainty that those two are TvT? Make a stance, don't deflect or use weasel words. Yes or no.
i think you should have stayed on bears but this is a decent alternative
ok sure, let's talk abt it more when ur on a computerIn post 800, Towelie wrote:Skitter i have stuff to say to you but it probably has to wait till i have a comp again. So much of your stance on m&m seemed like it shouldnt have contributed to a scumread and i dont like that you ended up voting there after the blurb you had
no offense but i think ur reading too much into itIn post 819, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:I made it very clear that I was referring to the latter, while making room for him to claim the former. That he didn't is concerning, in my eyes. I made it abundantly clear what my meaning was and even hinted to the correct answer, but here we are.
especially since i don't think scum-wisdom says to all of us 'i know it's tvt because of my red role pm'In post 821, Venus Fly Trap wrote:no offense but i think ur reading too much into itIn post 819, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:I made it very clear that I was referring to the latter, while making room for him to claim the former. That he didn't is concerning, in my eyes. I made it abundantly clear what my meaning was and even hinted to the correct answer, but here we are.
~ skitteR
i don't like thisIn post 827, Something_Smart wrote:Yet you want to vote me?In post 822, Wisdom wrote:id rather lim skilled scum
heya notsciIn post 832, Towelie wrote:@skitter- what did you think of Dunn coming off of LLDs reveal
I felt very underwhelmed with it despite not having an issue with the earlier posting from him last
-notty
what don't you like abt it?In post 189, Dunnstral wrote:Was still catching up.
LLD I wasn't wrong to vote you, you were making things up about your role and aggressively pushing on me which made the game about you vs me.
UNVOTE: Lady Lambdadelta
interested in seeing this tomIn post 850, Something_Smart wrote:Gonna call nope on this. But I will look at the other two.In post 849, Critter wrote:Bears v Gamma
In [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13081842#p13081842]post 851[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:well that's a little hypocritical of you....In post 771, Venus Fly Trap wrote:Lady Lambdadelta - obvscum (i jest before people yell at me)
>.>In [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13081844#p13081844]post 852[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:Wind back a couple seconds and we have this here ://In post 771, Venus Fly Trap wrote:the whole trolling thing is kinda disappointing and annoying.
again, i said this earlier, it's not inherently your cop claim, but how you're still pushing gamma afterwardsIn [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13081848#p13081848]post 853[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:meh. ok why. lets pretend we haven't claimed cop. why are we scum. you agree gamma's cc was bad. why is it weird for me to find it scummy when the cc is directed at me and extremely unreasonable?
fwiw i actually cean't tell who's posting whenIn [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13081869#p13081869]post 857[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:can people stop calling me pooky wtfIn post 781, Critter wrote:Pooky was clearly trying to eat a nightkill with that claim trying to give LLD another day.
sorry, i meant to say i called you town more than once, not sure why i wrote thatIn post 866, Gamma Emerald wrote:What does this meanIn post 863, Venus Fly Trap wrote:i called gamma scum more than once
Don’t recall you calling me scum inthisgame, is this about past games?
you're either absurdly tunneled in a fit of capricious pique or just scumIn [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13081894#p13081894]post 867[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:The cc was bad. I literally have no reason not to push it and to not think gamma has been consistently role fishing for my role.
there is nuance in that post that I do think is lightly town-indicative, she ends by saying that dunn's contradictory stance on his flavor claim vs. toog's is more suspicious than his initial flavor claim which I agree with, but by then multiple people had expressed that point so it's not really a new and original thought. (I think bork said it first.)In post 881, Wisdom wrote:Id agree with you if she tried to convince LLD Dunn is town. But while she tells her that her points are wrong she then proceeds to scumread Dunn for other points. So the motivation is not to dissipate the tvtIn post 880, Venus Fly Trap wrote:ssbm echoed a lot of my thoughts on the dunnstral/LLD situation in 450 so I'm (very) lightly townreading that slot overall
last two paragraphs in particular:In post 501, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:You scum, mush town, gamma town, nora possibly scumclaimed but nobody else notices these things. Wisdom obstinate, need to review him and toog in iso real quick, as his vote sticking in place feels wrong. However it's not likely you and wisdom are both scum so wrong on at least one of thoseIn post 496, Critter wrote:Waiting on reads Kyo tick tock tick tock
Dunnstral idk, I've had vibes he was scum at times but he doesnt feel like he did in isekai and I tracked him to the kill completely by accident there, had no idea he may be scum. I was setting up to Watch him later and he happened to be killing that Night
SM feels like limbait so town. Flytrap is POE scum. Gonna check playerlist for the resr as others in game are escaping me.
i mean i understand this but:In post 910, Wisdom wrote:If the IC says stupid stuff like "Dunn is scum because he claimed his flavor" it gives scum space to attack them and fight them
That's precisely what I would do as scum
What's the motivation? Discredit a conftown, gain cred for actively posting stances, gain more cred for posting stances different than a conftown's
kinda wnat to hear more abt thisIn post 914, Gamma Emerald wrote:Looking at S_S’s ISO, he kinda pings town in a few spots for now
just gonna pick out the stuff i want to respond to:In post 919, Towelie wrote:Got a little time over lunch today so I'll start w/ talking to skitter about stuff and see where it takes me. I haven't really read in depth since ssbm entered.
honestly i don't remember early-tenet-you, was kinda busy having a mess of a 1v1 with your other half for most of that >.>.In post 919, Towelie wrote:I honestly feel like this is almost exactly like my tenet D1; mostly observation mode but picking up things where I could and generally starting to form reads around it without really being in 'attack mode' per se, but I don't really feel like harping on your take, perpetual ELO this isn't, for sure, but I also felt like there was a lot of meat there early game whereas here sans Dunn there really wasn't.
yeah i agree that the weird gotchas don't actually mean anything but i also don't think they come from scum, or that scum thinks they'll actually go far / get anywhere by pushing someone that wayIn post 919, Towelie wrote:re: Mush. Obviously there's thought there, yes, but ultimately I'm having trouble I guess seeing MUSH push on things that seem like they matter as far as alignment is concerned vs like weird gotchas that don't ultimately mean anything. Like this most recent wisdom push I loathe because nobody goes, internally, "Well as a town player my role PM doesn't say X players are town with me, so therefore I should not be at all hyperbolic about the certainty of my reads" and therefore wisdom is scum.
again, idk what their motivation is as scum, but i also think their play doesn't make sense as town and i don't think it makes sense ot double-down on gamma when they did.In post 919, Towelie wrote:Even so, what is their objective here as scum other than pushing a read you don't agree with?
his recent scumgame in radio buzz, wherein he coasted for ~2 dayphases on saying a lot of ineffectual nothings and never really sat down and provided reads or tried to solve despite promising to do so. think this looks like thatIn post 919, Towelie wrote:S_S: I am worried about being wrong on "being underwhelming" being a scumtell for S_S - you saw this firsthand in tenet, and I basically had the same (wrong) take there based on a prior encounter in illicit. I don't really know how to read S_S but I don't feel like he ever got to a point where he was "whelming" in tenet. Even in illicit he was probably limmable if I hadn't been an idiot and saw a PR tell that wasn't there. What meta stuff are you basing this off of?
i was actually reading emmi as a new player and not as a gimmick account, fwiwIn post 927, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:It's safe to assume EMMI is at least somewhat experienced because it's a gimmick account and I feel like those are almost always created by players with an established meta looking to have a more relaxing game where they dont have to play as hard to their established meta.
In post 929, Towelie wrote:In addition I was kinda hoping lilith could be a backdoor into sorting that slot by someone with experience there after my colossal failure to get it right in MELO
i don't think those are aiIn post 930, Gamma Emerald wrote:These are probably the posts I like best from you S_S
You’re being assertive about your feelings but staying calm, you don’t seem worried about stepping on people’s toes a little
bolded: not sure why you're bringign this upIn post 956, Towelie wrote:I've found pooky town to be very easy to pick out from time to time. It's not been a tool i can use in this game so far. Usually he'll get into it w/ someone by now. I'd more trust my ability to read him than noraa.
(Skitter in the game we played together it's kinda how i felt midgame when they were going back and forth w/ cakez)
-b
that's a fair point but for mm i just don't get why they double-down on gamma, i think most town backs off after the cc thereIn post 961, Towelie wrote:this is basically my holdup on M&M right now unless you just think they're trolling and are unconcerned with the strategy behind what they're trying to accomplish other than creating noiseIn post 957, Venus Fly Trap wrote:or that scum thinks they'll actually go far / get anywhere by pushing someone that way
-b
i guess ... i'm not sure i get this because this isn't really how i'd try to get to town-pooky at allIn post 965, Towelie wrote:contextualizing how i get to town pooky in a way only you are likely familiar with and that i'm not seeing it here so farIn post 962, Venus Fly Trap wrote:bolded: not sure why you're bringign this up
-b
no offense but i think this is kinda a flimsy reason to townread me hereIn post 969, Towelie wrote:ithinki'm ok w/ vft for now. I'd probably expect skitter to capitulate / promise to research my comparison of myself to my tenet self (and it's not like we're under pressure atm that she'd lose ground by ceding a townread to mollify me)
either that or she doesn't think i'll be able to catch her anywaywhich is probably correctbut gun to head i'd say town here
*winces*
-b
well you're not ic-levels of obvtown here or running the showIn post 977, Towelie wrote:no? because i feel like you did a ton of that in ELO (mostly when you found out kismet was me)
fair enufIn post 986, Towelie wrote:fine. don't like that we got here but there's clearly nothing to really be done on this front w/ this convoIn post 984, Venus Fly Trap wrote:either way noting that i dislike your present read on me
~ skitter
-b
i took a quick look at your iso and i see a lot of 'let's flip kyo' but not a lot of reasoning for itIn post 991, Critter wrote:She said something I don’t think town says.In post 987, Venus Fly Trap wrote:can u give me a tldr on the kyr read critter?Explaining more is antitown but in a few days it will be obvious or I will explain it. Combined with her intro and talks on flavor and extremely delayed reads while responding to posts reminds me of active lurking.
notsci, right?
????In post 1005, Towelie wrote:i'm not sure how to handle you at the moment and i'm not even remote fucking sure how we got here but i get the overall impression that trying to deal with you right now is going to not go well and i don't fucking get it
i think critter was objecting to the dunn push because he was townreading himIn post 1006, Towelie wrote:I for one love that its okay for LLD to make the choice when its someone not named Dunnstral, but when it was Dunnstral you started your Kyo push!
ok, i'll drop this interaction thenIn post 1016, Towelie wrote:i am getting the impression that me directly interacting with you will not be helpful is what i'm trying to say based on your demeanor/tone toward me atm. You've not crossed any lines i just didn't think we'd be here.
-b
i'm talking about at the time of the flavor claim, you were townreading him at the time, no? that's what i thougth we were talking abtIn post 1022, Critter wrote:What part of “I do not townread Dunn” do people not understand?In post 1020, Venus Fly Trap wrote:i think critter was objecting to the dunn push because he was townreading himIn post 1006, Towelie wrote:I for one love that its okay for LLD to make the choice when its someone not named Dunnstral, but when it was Dunnstral you started your Kyo push!
and now has some ~mysterious reason~ for scumreading kyo. idk what it is or why but there seems to be something underlying this push that he's not articulating
i don't see a contradiction
In post 1029, Towelie wrote:I dont like the kyo push, nor do I think kyo is scum here in general. I find a bigger contradiction in him being okay to cede control to LLD over MM, who he thinks is town. This is in contrast to how he tried to change things to Kyo, who as of literally posts ago he states being unsure about Dunn's alignment, yet he tried to derail the exact same conftown from Dunn. I don't think that makes sense from a town POV at all.In post 1027, Venus Fly Trap wrote:i'm not really sure i understand your issues with critter @notty
a few things:In post 1030, Towelie wrote:His professed scumread of kyo was for doing a catchup wherein she quotes meme posts from the RVS/LLD calling code red a confscum claim phase, something he attributes to his own scum meta without any thoughts of if kyo would play the same, is there a track record of kyo doing the same, or anything else. And instead STILL refuses to share the reasons for the Kyo scumread.
i don't know why he has that thought process but given that this seems to be how he's approaching the game rn the rest follows and makes sense to meIn post 1056, Towelie wrote:i mean "kinda fine" [excepting some things that don't seem trivial that you said you don't understand reasons for] i feel like doesn't result in w/ 999In post 1053, Venus Fly Trap wrote:his play seems kinda fine to me and i don't take much issue with it
-b