Large Normal 229 | Manatee's Musical Mafia | Game Over

[Alisae]

ego will play later

[Alisae]

UNVOTE:

[Alisae]

Alright I think I’m going to give this game a read

[Alisae]

Anyone here that can tell give me the gist of what happened so far?

[Alisae]

oh fuck we have less then 48 horus left
im questioning why i replaced in tbh

[Alisae]

fuck i'll just try to find the latest vc and read that don't mind the stonedposting thanks

[Alisae]

ok so lead wagon is norwee
well shit now's a time to read the game then any lol

[Alisae]

First 200 posts coming up

[Alisae]

VOTE: Town Looter

Reason:

Shot through the heart and you're to blame.

This is my first game out of the newbie forum. Question: "The townvmafia numbers are confirmed to be 16v5," so this is definitely two factions? No worrying about more than one mafia or a serial killer?

i hate asking questions when catching up on the first 10 pages but this actually bothers me
why did you ask the thread instead of the mod?

--

he believes i'm skilled at playing as scum.

It doesn't seem like something scum!him would just casually put out there if it wasn't a real worry for him.

???

--

By the end, I thought Almost50 was one of the best scumreaders I'd seen.

OH MY GOD

--

VOTE: Bell

penis

So happy to be out of newbies and brushing shoulders with the great minds of mafiascum.com

Hey Lapsa, what do you think of Bell's line of questioning? Is how someone responds to a role PM alignment indicative?

this is alright tho

--

And now, can we start calling eachother scum so that we can have meaningful discussion, please? This debate about lynching and shooting basing on activity isn't alignment indicative, and we've basically killed RVS' significance here.

yeah why aren't you trying to do this instead of just complaining?

I mean...not really in love with the explanation b/c it doesn't make

that

much sense to me. You have a light town read and then someone points something out and you are like "my opinion is changed!" but it really didn't? Like I guess you are just arguing that your light town read was bolstered to a stronger town read but that's not really a change in opinion, at least to me. So it seems like just shit word choice.

LQ is fine here.

--

In general, unless you’re really, really, really sure you know that player is scum you don’t shoot n1.

We need early vig shoots because right now we’re fighting the wagon dynamics almost more than scum itself. I played in a large 50 game before and we needed 26 votes to get a lynch in D1. Do you have any idea how much of a pain in the ass it is to convince 26 people to lynch a player?
We need to lower the player pool ASAP, and hopefully by eliminating scum along the way.

Plurality > Majority honestly

--

VOTE: Marshall

I'd rather vote Fwesnid, but both are in my low info scum pool.

There's no previous mention of Marshall in your ISO this is weird

--

Haha this wagon sucks! Instead let me build a case on someone else with 5 pages of RVS!

Yall sound very eager to throw shade while you are both doing nothing sitting on RVS votes

See, god didn't give you a brain just to not use it ya know.

--

I like jokes. Jokes are very funny.

I can't I'm dieing


--

I strongly disagree but its game theory so no point in arguing about it and cluttering up the thread. Lets lynch stan or at least talk about him. What is even that fuzzy alien avatar?

He's an escapee from Area 51, isn't it obvious?

--

Idk it kinda feels like an cop-out from you Stan. You say the back and forth between me and Superbowl was forced like you’re suggesting it was a fake argument between scum. And when asked to elaborate you just said you wanted to see if "other people saw what you did."
It’s kinda icky.
VOTE: Stan1ey

The escapee is wrongly accused he's fine and honestly the people wagoning him aren't amazing (yourself included)

[Alisae]

off the top i liked sj i liked marsh i liked cat scratch i liked bell i liked lq
stan is probably fine
looker is weird, nero is scummy, and norwee isn't townie yet

might be a few others but those are the notable ones

[Alisae]

ima order food brb

[Alisae]

actually i don't think that was really worth posting a peepoleave but i like these emotes they're cute
ima read some more ig

[Alisae]

Are we really reading into the reasons for which people read other games when they were bored? That looks like a prototype of NAI thing to me.

This reads like busywork to me. Fake attempt at looking like town doing things useful for town. Bell is my first scumread so far.

LOL, voted for the wrong player.

VOTE: MM Choo choo!

I actually missed this Norwee post so this guy is probably fine i think but i doesn't feel like town!norwee atm

--

Do you have anything else on Bell besides that he's lamisting? Convince me i'm wrong

This comes from scum more often than it comes from town.
If anyone wants to wagon superbowl, I'm on it.

do u still believe this if so why if not why

--

or interpretation or w/e.

I naked voted him and he responded within 2 mins. He then asked what's the reason for a naked voted so yes I think he's a little freaked out over getting voted. That's my interpretation and I'm entitled to it. It's not a fucking misrep.

Ok so why is it scum indicative? From his POV. You just voted him and gave him nothing to work with what is supposed to do not hold you accountable?
Like holy Nero are you scum or are you just playing like fucking dogshit (which honestly wouldn't surprise me). Like as town why wouldn't he respond that way?
Like at this point in the game I don't think Norwee is doing anything significantly townie at this moment but this just doesn't make sense.
Why did you even place the vote on him to begin with?

--

how would you know if I've found scum or not?

??????
Jesus fuckin crist why did I replace in holy

--

I'm not really understanding why a naked vote is getting everybody up in arms. I'm not really hard scumreading him or anything but I had a little niggle and I didn't really want to leave my vote empty after I got off Stan.

NERO
ITS BECAUSE YOU VOTED HIM AND WHEN HE TRIED TO HOLD YOU ACCOUNTABLE FOR IT YOU PLAYED IT OFF AS A REACTION TEST

Like I would say this isn't townie thinking because I don't see why town from your pov would need to be voting someone at this moment if you're getting off stan but I mean its you we're talking about so who really knows here

holy im honestly probably malding over this because your town I don't think scum makes me mald this hard but who knows lol xD

assuming that I remembered correctly then that seems p similar to his scum game.

He probably makes those as either alignment but now I'm malding over why you're trying to justify it and also I'm malding over the fact that you're naked voting him over that that just doesn't seem truthful to me but its you we're talking about so who fucking knows!

--

norway, if you are town and you seem to think I'm town, do you feel like agrivating and ad hom attacking me is the best way to go about this?

I don't feel like playing like town this game. In fact i don't really care if i die early. It's a 20+ game.
Watching your reactions is much more amusing to me atm.

Town should always care about playing like town. Nice to have caught scum day 1.

If Mafia is not as black and white as you're suggesting it is.

--

I am mostly caught up, but skimmed a lot...

Spoiler: Fluff

here's my conclusion. Anime avatars are horrible.

+1

I like jokes. Jokes are very funny.

you know what I like? lynching LQ on d1.

Oooh, yes, LQ schooled me good in the game I played with them.

Ah yes, the scum distancing on pg 5 of a large game strat.

Ya this Marshall wagon sucks

use your words. It sucks b/c ?????

This argument between you two feels forced af

Is this scum playing both ends in the middle? He's basically accusing norway and super of scum theatre but was careful not to outright say that. Am I the only one that got this impression?

I agree with these trains of thought.

town looter is a good wagon.

Why do you say that?

Anyway let's stop talking about that. It will just waste time.
I'm reconsidering Stan based on NPOM's statement on them so i'll go back here for now. VOTE: Bell

In addition to aforementioned discussion on Norwegian's reactions, he also put a vote on someone who has gone VLA. That doesn't seem very productive in a large game.
VOTE: Norwegian

Bell vote makes sense to me

[Alisae]

Ima eat my food that just came in
i'm not sure what to think of nero, i want to townread norwee for interactions with those 2 later down the line, and I'm not sure about NPOM but if you had to put a gun to my head i'd say its probably not him.
looker kinda looking worse tho

[Alisae]

ITS BECAUSE YOU VOTED HIM AND WHEN HE TRIED TO HOLD YOU ACCOUNTABLE FOR IT YOU PLAYED IT OFF AS A REACTION TEST

no, I didn't dummy

how is you judging his reaction to the naked vote not playing it off as a reaction test?

[Alisae]

lets just vote Ali. If Ali is even town Ali will just be a drain on the town. He's that bad.

and how is what you're doing any better

[Alisae]

VOTE: NorwegianboyEE

I love naked votes.

kinda bettlejuicy bro

Nero just spill why you're voting me, i'm not up for your games. Get it over with.

Why are you freaking out over one vote?

or interpretation or w/e.

I naked voted him and he responded within 2 mins. He then asked what's the reason for a naked voted so yes I think he's a little freaked out over getting voted. That's my interpretation and I'm entitled to it. It's not a fucking misrep.

You're judging his reaction so ur playing it off like its a reaction test

[Alisae]

ok nero