14 from Pine is pretty scummy IMO- the vote was obviously RVS and it seems like he's trying too hard to look like he's scumhunting.
25 from Profii is towny.
27- We have now reached maximum Boonskiies.
32 feels genuine.
34- Yeah, I'm pretty sure nictis is town here.
43- I get the feeling that scum may be sheeping nictis on his read.
44 is actually scummy from TIAM.
I like
45.
51 from Beefster is scummy. Why are you thinking and taking into consideration the fact that people could consider your vote a chainsaw defense?
I don't like
74 either, the "Tip for next time, kid" part seems fake. However I heard pine is good scum so I'm not 100% on it yet.
99- I like the RF and profii TRs. I think FL is town this game.
I don't like
118, saying "this claim seems very meh to me." when referring to a literal ascetic miller claim seems fake.
124 makes me think profii may be scum after all.
135- I feel like TWIM is lynchbait town. Scum tries to look town and/or blend in- I don't think scum tries to draw attention to themselves in a way that doesn't make them look towny, like TWIM has been doing.
140 is horrible in ways I am unable to explain.
159 also needs to be cleansed with fire ASAP.
161- I just realised nobody is actually going to read this post. oh well.
162- Gamma scum?
170- I really feel like this whole reaction from Inferno is fake and designed to make him look more towny. He just doesn't seem genuine at all. I wouldn't be surprised if there was some coaching going on here and the interaction with pine was SvS.
172- OK, I believe Inferno and Gamma are scum together, and Pine is town. This is not a town post.
174- no, I'm pretty sure he didn't really fall for it, and the way he reacted seems not real at all.
231- there definitely could be 4 scum, so we shouldn't assume 5, although this is NAI stuff
244- this makes me lean away from inferno/gamma, although I do think one of them is probably scum still.
292- eh maybe Inferno could be town after all. I'm somewhat lost for scumreads if he is
297- yeah, I get the feeling I'm probably gonna have to make a summary of this thing afterwards. I understand not reading it, I guess.
301- I feel confident Nictis is town but I don't think anyone actually disagrees with that so whatever.
310 from Nos is scummy.
318- I'm gonna go out on a limb and say this post makes RF town.
334- this post is pretty meh.
346- yes this. Nictis has been towny throughout.
355- I'm confident profii is town this game.
364- this post is so scummy that I'm not even sure it's actual scum. what is it even.
374- yeah, theta is pretty obvtown.
379- So either FL talked about it in neighbour or scum thread. Either way assemble doing this is
unless he's referring to a previous game.
388- do people think this is valid meta? It looks like a good read but I've never played before with nsg.
409- I feel like this from theta is wrong but it's towny anyway.
419- if nsg is town, this is scum. I don't see how he can call her read forced here.
437- I think I agree with this.
452- Yeah I really think Gamma is scum this game.
471- what. How is that post even remotely scummy.
501- Tbh I just doubt this sort of post comes from scum. TWIM doesn't look like he's playing to be towny. He's surface level scummy but not really beyond that.
525- I really feel like Gamma is scum acting cocky. Like, it just feels really fake.
571- this is towny from RF.
574- Kinda towny tbh.
602- This feels like surface-level scumhunting- I really don't see why scum!TIAM does this at all. I think he's lynchbait town, and I don't know why people are pushing him despite the lack of scum motivation.
608- To be honest, I like this post from Inferno.
631- I don't like this from Flubber, it feels like he doesn't want to give real reads so he's basically just calling things NAI to make it look like he's doing something.
660- I do kinda like the ucv wagon- he really should have been posting at this point and I think both profii and TWIM are town. No idea what to make of the fact ucv actively decided to flake out instead of playing the game.
661- LUV slot could be scum with mulch.
687- I honestly feel like this is too scummy to be scum, but
689- ☭
699- penguin mafia; never forgive, never forget.
700- FL town
709- ok yeah I really just think FL is town this game. he's totally swindled me if he isn't.
713- Yeah I hardtownread profii.
725 makes me doubt my townread on RedFlavor. Why does scum try to push a mislynch on someone who hasn't posted, instead of someone who has scummy posts and people are pushing? The latter is a lot more common and more likely.
763- Mulch feels kinda towny so far.
770- This is pretty damn close to what I've been thinking, I definitely feel like Mulch is town now.
786- okay Mulch is locktown by now.
792- wait how can you even poe this game? loads of slots hadn't even posted content
798- This from gamma is kinda towny but not enough to change my mind.
839-
873- don't like this from Gamma, either. it feels like he's trying to look like a pro-town player, asking questions and getting responses, but there's nothing to respond to there.
890- this feels opportunistic from Flubber. Not sure why profii is "worth lynching" here.
908- I still feel like nictis is obvtown.
917- what. I don't get how that is what you get from 914.
919- I don't feel like this is accurate- I've definitely seen FL spampost as scum to the point where I couldn't even respond to him. I'm not sure where this meta is coming from.
933- Flavor/profii/TIAM kinda feels like an opportunistic scumpool from Inferno.
939- Inferno/gamma scumbuddies?
942- this is meh.
949- I don't like this post. Quick is pointing out the obvious to get towncred instead of looking for scum. This isn't close to how I've seen him previously as town.
953- This is a kinda scummy post but I think it likely doesn't come from a gamma/quick team. Could be wrong though. Describing Beefster's post as "A very nuanced thought" even though it really wasn't could come from a Gamma/Beefster scumteam, where Gamma is looking for reasons to push Beefster as a townie.
974- same
979- Being egotistical =/= being scum. If anything, annoying people is a TOWNY thing to do.
983- I'm finding it progressively harder to see Gamma as town here. Like, calling FL terrible just for TRing two makes 0 sense. It feels like Gamma is scum posturing to get the TIAM mislynch through.
1006- You know how we reached maximum Boonskiies on page 2? We have now reached maximum Mulch.
1012- HORRIBLE
1013-
HORRIBLE
1022- I actually agree with this except I haven't been reading Egg as scum. I guess he's null.
1023- what.
1037- The post Quick quotes here is wasted breath at best and I don't see why he likes it so much.
1039- what
1042- This list is bad imo.
1047- with context, the thing where people pushed Quick for """scumslipping""" is even worse and I think if Quick flips town the people doing this are very likely to be scum. However I do think Quick has been scummy individually, for reasons already discussed.
1081- see, now this is a good and towny case on Quick.
1095- I'm not sure if Gamma's playstyle nowadays really is to call literally everyone who disagrees with him stupid/idiotic, or if he's just doing that because he's scum and he thinks it makes him look towny.
1099- I STILL DON'T GET THIS PUSH. If the timeline of events is: Quick replaces in -> Quick realises FL is in the game -> Quick tries to policy lynch FL -> Quick replaces out, there is absolute consistency. I mean I think quick is scum anyway but.
1101- this post is pretty meh but not enough to outweigh profii's towny posting.
1106- what
1009- what
1112- what. Am I like really offbase this game or something? because all this from my townreads doesn't make much sense. Mulch is even townier after this I think.
1132- Actually, I just switched accounts, I didn't replace out. Same with flavor leaf -> Boonskiies.
1138- but did Quick have a wagon?
1140- what
1153- I agree with the first half of this post but I also think the second part is kinda scummy.
1163- ok yeah I still think profii is very town.
1164- why can't he replace in, then realise FL is in the game, then try to deal with him, then try to PL him when he can't, and then replace out once fed up? the way I read the series of events was NAI.
