Newbie 1910: Aerial Photography [Game Over!]

[brassherald]

Is that intent to hammer?

[northsidegal]

VC 1.11

votes

[4] Junk

:

the worst 195, GrandWazoo 216, GuiltyLion 306, brassherald 313

[2] GrandWazoo

:

computerfan0 87, YyottaCat 256

[1] computerfan0

:

YellowSnow 160

[2] Not Voting

:

JunkoChan 336, Junk 349

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-01-09 08:02:59)

Mod Notes

: Please remember to remain civil.

[JunkoChan]

is he at L-1?

[brassherald]

is he at L-1?

I believe so.

[JunkoChan]

he is not, he got 2 votes on him for what I can see (I'm trusting last northsidegal's vote count)

[brassherald]

he is not, he got 2 votes on him for what I can see (I'm trusting last northsidegal's vote count)

Oh, you're right, it's 5 to lynch today, not 4... Math hard.

[JunkoChan]

he is not, he got 2 votes on him for what I can see (I'm trusting last northsidegal's vote count)

Oh, you're right, it's 5 to lynch today, not 4... Math hard.

no no you are correct I was loking at 355 thinking that was the last vote count

votes on nineja/junk: the worst Guiltylion brassherald and Grandwazoo

[JunkoChan]

VC 1.11

votes

[4] Junk

:

the worst 195, GrandWazoo 216, GuiltyLion 306, brassherald 313

[2] GrandWazoo

:

computerfan0 87, YyottaCat 256

[1] computerfan0

:

YellowSnow 160

[2] Not Voting

:

JunkoChan 336, Junk 349

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-01-09 08:02:59)

Mod Notes

: Please remember to remain civil.

Yes seems correct

[the worst]

We have a little bit of time to play with. If he finishes his catchup and still looks scummy, a claim is appropriate.. otherwise I'd rather he holds off.

[JunkoChan]

So yes it's an intent to hammer now that we got a few days, I guess we can sit on this for a bit

p-edit tw beat me to it.

[brassherald]

Oh, we got a 48 hour extension, I even asked about it and had already forgotten.

[GrandWazoo]

Yeah I'm fine where my vote is. Junk is all noise no signal.

[YellowSnow]

I checked a recent scum game from the worst and he replaced out and only posted a couple times in the mafia PT.

I take it the worst really doesn't like being scum. This doesn't look like his scum game to me.

[YellowSnow]

I really don't think Junk would be so agressive as scum either.

[the worst]

I don't replace out because of rolling scum. I think I was burned out & busy irl and had to replace out due to time constraints there.
here's some examples of my actual scumgame where I got to play past a few pages fwiw

open 733
supp 2017 mafia
starcraft mafia (ended the other day)

you're correct in that i don't enjoy playing scum and my tone/playstyle is very different. but it's not to the point where i can't post at all/replace out due to rolling scum.

brass has seen my scumgame quite a few times and can testify to all of this i think, lol.

[Junk]

I really don't think Junk would be so agressive as scum either.

If this guy is town you guys should be listening to him

[Junk]

Oh and he's also voting for computer

Nice, what a cool guy

VOTE: computerfan0

[Junk]

I skimmed the other posts. They weren't that interesting and not that different from how to players initially acted.

me
brass
the worst
yellow snow
grandwazoo
yotta cat
junko chan
guilty lion
computerfan

I know I'm town.

Brass is my top town due to their aggresion, emotions, frustration, and bristly-ness. I'd think scum is more likely to try to be more polite, to fit in with people. Even if it's not due to manipulations, scum know that townies are town. So scum being rude to town isn't something easy to do, since they know that the townies are being real and genuine.

The worst for similar reasons. Also I trust YellowCat's meta that they don't play as scum. Also, when they were pushing me, they said something like "Yeah, I shouldn't be expecting much from Junk on his first forum game, but still man, i think it's scummy...". This looked pretty silly to me, and I attribute it to town tunneling. If he was scum, he would probably try to be more reasonable.

YellowSnow's read align with mine very much. And I know I'm town, so chances are he's town too. Also I like that he's defending me. I don't think his posts are that hard to fake as scum though, so slight tin foil there for late game, like final 3, if he's still alive, but for now he's town.

Grand Wazoo's attitude and bristlyness is towny in my opinion. Similar to the guy with the gnome avatar, through not that intense (therefore, not that intense of a townread they shall receive either). They weren't afraid to make posts that could be seen as weird/contrarian.

I haven't read any Yotta Cat's post but I really think moonythedwarf is townie. They were just doing their own silly thing. They weren't trying to look townie by your guys's standards. Their OMGUS vote

Voting for being a derp is rude.
Aaaanyways, why are you so insistent on voting me in the first place? Hmm?
VOTE: GrandWazoo

is pretty townie in my opinion.

JunkoChan is hard. I dislike their waffly-ness/safe-ness in their stances early game. But + points for them for the frustration at replacements, and the big amount of words they decide to type in the thread. I dislike that they wanna vote me, I'd prefer if they did not.

Also I just noticed that colored wall is a the worst post, not Junko. Yeah, the worst is definitely town.

GuiltyLion's flow seemed townie and carefree when I first skimmed it. I thought to myself - why not, this guy can be town. But they don't seem like a newbie player on re-read, and coupled with my better reasonings to townread other people, he is welcome to be a scum candidate by PoE.

computerfan0 is just a newbie scum in my opinion. I wouldn't cry if he's town either. He's a pretty good lynch in my opinion.

[Junk]

This also stood out as scummy to me -

as there is no real way to make an informed decision

feels like it could be scum faking being uninformed, and/or defaulting to an awkward vote justification. either way no bueno

buuuut it's also unlikely both are scum so I need to see more from both of those slots.

that's where I'm at right now. Gonna think a bit and maybe (probably) be back later with some questions after another read

computerfan I called out 48 yesterday but thinking about it now again I kinda like that he switched votes with no explanation? feel like scum would be afraid to do that and make some sort of attempt at justifying it

(some parts I cut out)

Could GuiltyLion be scum with computer fan?

If they are, his posts make sense wrt scum!computerfan.

First he distances from him, then he townreads him for a silly reason.

The second post is pretty silly. It kind of looks to me like a scum who knows computerfan0 is town actually. So I don't know.

[Junk]

But yeah I think that

Hi, im computerfan0, the worlds biggest noob.

Calling himself a noob on his first post is something that a newbscum would do. (If he's scum) he was probably thinking: I should call myself a noob to lower the bar of expectations people have on me

I'll just vote for Nineja, as there is no real way to make an informed decision
VOTE: Nineja

Again, nothing much to explain/analyze without trying to guess his alignment, BUT, if I assume that he's scum, I think it can make sense. The over-explanation "as there is no real way to make an informed decision" is weird and he was probably thinking "I should make sure I try to look like I'm portraying my thought process in the thread so people think I'm towny"

By the way, that's why I'm town. I didn't explain stuff in a "textbook" kind of way like some guys wanted from me. And this is WIFOM, but that's fine.

[Junk]

I think my last few posts have been townie.

If I was you guys, I would townread me for my aggression... well not aggression. I wouldn't say I'm aggressive. More like aggressively defending myself from rudeness.

[JunkoChan]

is anyone buying this?

[Junk]

is anyone buying this?

Stop tunneling me, please.

I have been mind boggingly obvious townie.

If you guys can't see it, there's nothing much I can do.

Also, I'm not going to claim my role. Hammer me if you wish.

[Junk]

Comouterfan0 > GuiltyLion > Junko > YellowSnow (if he's alive in f3 he's probably scum)

That's the game winning lynch order

[computerfan0]

I have school tomorrow. Sorry for not posting much on here, but I am managing 5 nations in NationStates, dealing with real life and also trying to play other games.