The Mystery Box Of Silver 5: Clash of Cash death grips

[Auro]

You know Mastina could just NK someone else and have Yay prevent a lynch on her, right?

[ElevenThirty]

like if we assume mastina is town why does yay die
that's the part htat's confusing me

pedit but why does yay die over mastina if they're both town then ?

[ElevenThirty]

Your disagreement is that you townread Rhinox more than Mastina, yeah? What made Rhinox town, tl;dr?

thinking things at the same time we thought them + having similar thought processes to us

[Auro]

like if we assume mastina is town why does yay die

I don't necessarily see the advantage of Mastina over Yay as a NK, if you're town.
Was Yay townreading Pisskop?

[Auro]

There shouldn't have been a "confrontation" wouldn't the same-alignment thing work either way?

[ElevenThirty]

right, so my point is why does yay die and not mastina

irrel would have townread the other if one flipped, so why is yay the one that flipped

obviously this is from my pov but i know i'm town, and we all know that yay was town

which is better for scum:

a) mastina alive, who irrel townreads
b) yay alive, who irrel townreads, but who wants us dead

from my pov obviously scum prefer the latter but that didn't happen

[pisskop]

a) mastina alive, who irrel townreads

you answered it yourself when you called mastin an SK

[pisskop]

Do we have a missing NK?

[pisskop]

n3: zeebu is a vanilla townie; Wh4t is a vanilla townie; Old Dogs is a town 2-shot roleblocker

Did we ever talk about this?

[ElevenThirty]

i don't get it

and idk, really no way of knowing

[pisskop]

I think that zeebu was a kill from the 3 people in the hood.

[ElevenThirty]

old dogs could have blocked someone but i have no way of knowing that

nominally we could have been shot n3 and we didn't die since we became bp that night (was anyone visited by mastina last night?)
not very likely but technically possible

pedit sigh rhinox claimed it

[Auro]

ElevenTwenty, if you assume Mastina's town what would your solve be? Rhinox + ?

[pisskop]

But, assuming thats true, (and old doggo an obvious nk) and wh4t is a mastin kill.

Leaving mastin alive to shade for the sk/ afraid of targeting mastin because 'maybe sk'

[pisskop]

rhinox claimed it

idk what rhino claimed.

[ElevenThirty]

i don't know rn

you're scummier than pk but your pred was town and i don't know how to synthesize that rn

[pisskop]

your pred was town

thats a bad reason to not kill scum

[Auro]

Yup, it's plausible scum thought a lynch on Mastina would be easier than Yay - even if scum assumed there'd be a confrontation with ElevenForty today, Yay "coming around" would be dangerous in the long term.

[ElevenThirty]

rhinox claimed it

idk what rhino claimed.

ascetic townie who was given a vig shot and who shot zeebu; that's what prompted the mastina vote on him

fwiw krazy (pikachu of the yay hydra) thought the shot came from the trifecta to

[Auro]

you're scummier than pk

Can you go into why? Is it just "Auro's not doing anything" or something about my pushes?

[Auro]

There's a lot of "Auro is scummy" in this thread but no real reasons why.

[pisskop]

ascetic townie who was given a vig shot and who shot zeebu; that's what prompted the mastina vote on him

an sk mastin who is planning on only making one kill and claiming vig is skilled enough to do that . . ..

but i dont think so. tbh id want to think it over.

[ElevenThirty]

pk feels like he's solving (i think? from what i understand about the game, at least)
and i don't see you doing that really

[ElevenThirty]

*about his game

[Auro]

and i don't see you doing that really

After I offered a solve?