BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[The Fonz]

@Fonz: Join us on the Conspire wagon?

Nah. Lurker wise I think GB is scummier by some distance, and I'd probably rather do BTE than Conspire as well.

[Auro]

Is there anything town-indicative you see from Conspire?

[BooneyToonzExpert]

snip...
But if they can stay alive long enough they will give us good info.
...snip

Imagine I don't have the vaguest clue about Nancy and explain why the above is true please.

In short, I think the Nancy head has better mid-late game reads and solves than her early reads.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

I sr any slot that votes me for what I think is bad reasoning.

This is an example of why Nancy's early game is not reliable. Nancy always gets lots of attention because of her number of posts and some people get paranoid and think they are being played. Later in the game those feelings subside on both sides and we get some objective solving from them and people will either SR or TR this slot based on the game alone.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

VOTE: George Bailey

2 unexplained lazy votes back to back.

I know I just said Nancy's early game is unreliable, but its ok to push this slot for now to see how it pans out.

VOTE: George Bailey

[BooneyToonzExpert]

Also,

I'm not trying to ignore Shiro. Honestly, I don't know who is assigned to V or M. I just assume Nancy always posts.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

VOTE: Titus

I think the way Xtoxm and Venus engaged was townie.

I can't really see why Venus and Booneytunez were town reading that Titus post and I still sustain my belief that this is most likely a scum slot.

I just suck at reading Titus so if someone makes a compelling case on that slot that makes sense to me then I may go. But I have trouble convincing myself that Titus is scum, especially on D1.

[The Fonz]

Is there anything town-indicative you see from Conspire?

Not a lot. It's a vibe, mostly.

[Auro]

Would you be able to explain why you get that vibe in some amount of detail?

[The Fonz]

Would you be able to explain why you get that vibe in some amount of detail?

It's a combination of cosmic seeming relaxed, and seeing the game the same way I do. Then the admittedly slightly forced push on chkflip looks like someone trying to get shit done without any strong pings to go off.

[jjh927]

Looking back at Conspire's iso I don't think I actually responded to Conspire asking about my Vecna and Nom reads which is awks but I guess I'll do it in a conversation

[Auro]

It's a combination of cosmic seeming relaxed, and seeing the game the same way I do. Then the admittedly slightly forced push on chkflip looks like someone trying to get shit done without any strong pings to go off.

"Seeming relaxed" - I don't recall the game consensus pushing them, is there a reason not to be relaxed as scum? With no concrete wagons anywhere, this is exactly the kind of gamestate where scum would be relaxed, no?
"Same way I do" - which parts, exactly?
"Get shit done" - Sure, if they're town, they're trying to go somewhere without strong pings. If they're scum, they're trying to appear town by making some push. What makes this more likely to come from town?

The lack of posts from the other head must be telling to some extent, no?

[Titus]

Catching up now.

[GeorgeBailey]

Alright, sorry for lurking. Work has been dumb this week. Right now I'm thinking nomnomnom.

VOTE: nomnomnom I dont see why over-explaining things make people scummy. It seemed like an attempt to bring the game out of RVS phase.

[Auro]

Multiple people attacked jjh for "over-explaining" - that say anything to you?

[Titus]

Ok I need a VC to tell heads or tails of this game. I want to see if Bailey Conspire and the Fonz contains multiple scum or not. The wagon motion is bothering me.

VC please

[GeorgeBailey]

Multiple people attacked jjh for "over-explaining" - that say anything to you?

Yeah, it could be a push from scum. Scum can slip sometimes when they both present the same logic that barely differs from person to person.

[GeorgeBailey]

I dont see anything scummy from the fonz tbh. He seems like low-activity null rn.

[Venus and Mars]

Ok I need a VC to tell heads or tails of this game. I want to see if Bailey Conspire and the Fonz contains multiple scum or not. The wagon motion is bothering me.

VC please

Titus is town, people. When I wake up, I’ll respond to more.

[Auro]

Yeah, it could be a push from scum. Scum can slip sometimes when they both present the same logic that barely differs from person to person.

So... you're saying multiple scum "slipped" by offering the same logic for a push, and that's more probable than the simple alternative of their argument holding some merit?

[Krazy Katz]

Ok I need a VC to tell heads or tails of this game. I want to see if Bailey Conspire and the Fonz contains multiple scum or not. The wagon motion is bothering me.

VC please

Titus is town, people. When I wake up, I’ll respond to more.

I'm convinced

VOTE: Titus

[Auro]

@Venus and Mars: Why is Titus town for that? Have you played against scum!Titus before?

[Auro]

Auro: I'm paranoid of Krazy's posts
Nancy: Oh so Krazy must be town then

Nancy: Titus is town
Krazy: Oh so Titus must be scum then

[Titus]

See, get Shiro. Thread is in Greek.

@Auro, Nancy Shiro and I go way back. Like years.

@Shiro, I need a cookie.

[Auro]

@Titus: Do you think their townread of you for that post is legitimate, then?