SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Miss Lane]

So you take one instance of me doing something for the lulz, when I've done a lot of lulz stuff this game, assign me the label of "strange" for it, claim I wasn't as town in one game earlier, and incorrectly claim that you read me correctly there; therefore you're comfortable calling me scum?

Good scumhunting, good scumhunting.

No. I take an instance of you taking a hard stance in one direction. You can't provide anything substantial for defending a relatively decent scum read of mine, and instead try to draw my attention to another place where you take an action that is awkward and out of place and honestly feels a bit scummy. When I come onto you for it, you bring up that you've been doing scummy things all game, and then accuse me of scum reading you for only one scummy thing and then try to make it seem as if that's a bad way to approach the game.

[Miss Lane]

I'm sorry, bring up one game where I've incorrectly read you.

[Auro]

And why is that my problem? What would you think town!Auro would say in regards to Mastina vs ETL?

[Auro]

I'm sorry, bring up one game where I've incorrectly read you.

Masons v Mafia.

[Auro]

The other game I recall having experience with you in where you "caught" me was BoP mafia where there's like a 2/5 chance of being right anyway also, my partner didn't follow the final piece of strategy I laid out, which enabled you to catch us by association.

[Miss Lane]

I've played with you twice. If you're claiming that you voting me in lylo as town at the end of the last game because I called you likely scum is me misreading you, that's just you making a major mistake in lylo. I had two strong town reads in lylo and had to sort between them, applying pressure to players that have been town reads all game is not uncommon in lylo.

[Miss Lane]

And why is that my problem? What would you think town!Auro would say in regards to Mastina vs ETL?

Town!Auro doesn't say or do nothing and try to avoid responsibility, which is what you're doing.

[Miss Lane]

The other game I recall having experience with you in where you "caught" me was BoP mafia where there's like a 2/5 chance of being right anyway also, my partner didn't follow the final piece of strategy I laid out, which enabled you to catch us by association.

1/12 != 2/5

I read you correctly individually from about midway through the game

[Auro]

You can't provide anything substantial for defending a relatively decent scum read of mine

What? Seriously? I gave my case for a strong townread, you said "Sure" - if you don't think it's substantial, why not ask me to go into more detail?

Like saying "sure" and attacking me for not substantiating is

Yes, I made a major mistake in LyLo because you scumread me. I was hypertown then. You claimed I was following a strategy that's gamethrowing for scum!me, because I wanted to win with style or something.

[Tchill13]

My point of disagreement, Tchill, is that you're saying ETL would have to be incompetent as scum to have played this way; and

I'm arguing that she doesn't need to be

. I don't think this put herself under any actual threat and I believe she would've changed her tune had consensus tried to lynch her.

yes she may find this strategy viable. Its something i personally see as a bad strat and I feel that it is overall a bad strat. Thats where the disagreement is and while I acknowledge its a possibility I'm not willing to change my mind about it.

she was under no real threat before she started acting a little odd in terms of self voting. Gave me the correct read on Miss lynch after detaching herself. I still think she's town.

[Auro]

And why is that my problem? What would you think town!Auro would say in regards to Mastina vs ETL?

Town!Auro doesn't say or do nothing and try to avoid responsibility, which is what you're doing.

What makes you believe I'm not taking responsibility for my Mastina defense and ETL attack?

[Auro]

yes she may find this strategy viable. Its something i personally see as a bad strat and I feel that it is overall a bad strat. Thats where the disagreement is and while I acknowledge its a possibility I'm not willing to change my mind about it.

Convince me on why it's a bad strat. She was under no threat of lynch when she played the AtE card, sitting at 4 votes.

[Miss Lane]

Auro, you don't explain your mastina town read anywhere in your iso from what I've seen. Why are you townreading her?
What changed across the line?

Tone, energy, approach to the game (especially this), mindset match on a lot of things.

Nothing really changed across the line, I find one read problematic ≠ I scumread them.

I read every post of yours.

You don't mention mastina much, you don't talk to her, you don't quote her, and you don't explain your town read on her, despite the fact that it's apparent she's been a major discussion point for the last several pages.

No, I don't think this is substantial.

[Miss Lane]

Auro, you don't explain your mastina town read anywhere in your iso from what I've seen. Why are you townreading her?
What changed across the line?

Tone, energy, approach to the game (especially this), mindset match on a lot of things.

Nothing really changed across the line, I find one read problematic ≠ I scumread them.

I read every post of yours

mentioning mastina

.

You don't mention mastina much, you don't talk to her, you don't quote her, and you don't explain your town read on her, despite the fact that it's apparent she's been a major discussion point for the last several pages.

No, I don't think this is substantial.

ebwop

[Miss Lane]

I think your read on her is awkward and convenient given circumstances.

[Auro]

1. I asked her Q's, she was off for a day and responded a few hours ago while I was asleep
2. No one asked me to explain the townread on her

Like I'm not going to explain every read of mine when I make it - I'll state my reads, and if you're interested in one of them, feel free to ask lol.

[Tchill13]

yes she may find this strategy viable. Its something i personally see as a bad strat and I feel that it is overall a bad strat. Thats where the disagreement is and while I acknowledge its a possibility I'm not willing to change my mind about it.

Convince me on why it's a bad strat. She was under no threat of lynch when she played the AtE card, sitting at 4 votes.

grabbing the spotlight d1 early for no reason on a play to AtE when its not needed makes sense how?

[Auro]

I think your read on her is awkward and convenient given circumstances.

Sure but I've always been townreading her.

Would you not be levying the same accusation if I had scumread Mastina and townread ETL? That definitely feels like the more convenient place to be in.

[Miss Lane]

I think your read on her is awkward and convenient given circumstances.

Sure but I've always been townreading her.

Would you not be levying the same accusation if I had scumread Mastina and townread ETL? That definitely feels like the more convenient place to be in.

Why does that seem like a more convenient place to be in?

[Miss Lane]

No, I wouldn't be levying the same accusation if you town read ETL and scum read mastina.

If you town read ETL and scum read mastina, I would vote ETL no contest.

[Auro]

grabbing the spotlight d1 early for no reason on a play to AtE when its not needed makes sense how?

I see your point, but a few power players began to push her hard, no? The wagon was starting to form with Nero, Mastina, Hoctac's first serious read, etc.

[Auro]

No, I wouldn't be levying the same accusation if you town read ETL and scum read mastina.

If you town read ETL and scum read mastina, I would vote ETL no contest.

Are you saying you'd intentionally just vote whoever I'm townreading then? In which case this engagement is entirely in bad faith anyway.

Or do you mean you'd vote Mastina no contest? In which case this is arguably the more convenient position to be in

[Auro]

If it's the former than don't bother trying to engage with me, if your play here is to just oppose my reads no matter what.

[Auro]

It's like every game people keep pushing Mastina for whatever reason while she posts transparently and responds to everything. I got a lot of flak defending her in Doubles, and I probably will to some extent this game too.

This is not a convenient position lol

[Miss Lane]

No, I wouldn't be levying the same accusation if you town read ETL and scum read mastina.

If you town read ETL and scum read mastina, I would vote ETL no contest.

Are you saying you'd intentionally just vote whoever I'm townreading then? In which case this engagement is entirely in bad faith anyway.

Or do you mean you'd vote Mastina no contest? In which case this is arguably the more convenient position to be in

No.

Actually I take that back. I wouldn't vote ETL based solely on the fact that you town read her.