When I compare Timmer's frustration with not knowing what to do this game with Gimli's I don't think these feel the same
Timmer seems to be trying to work through his issues with the game and still contribute, whereas it feels like Gimli might be trying to use it as an excuse to lurk and not do much. I'm not really a fan of these two posts being so close to each other:
In post 560, DragonEater70 wrote:
1. Regarding kittie/Giml: Yes, that's true that town changes their opinions, however I don't see how this should affect my read on kittie? I just liked the thought process and critical thinking there, and Idk if I'm actually scum reading Gimli based off that.
Huh?
In post 540, DragonEater70 wrote:
Wow I LOVE kittie's case on Gimli. kittie has really won me over as being town.
So you didn't scum read Gimli based on Kittie's case? I interpreted 540 as you indeed thinking it was a strong case and subsequently agreeing that Gimli was scummy.
In post 560, DragonEater70 wrote:
1. Regarding kittie/Giml: Yes, that's true that town changes their opinions, however I don't see how this should affect my read on kittie? I just liked the thought process and critical thinking there, and Idk if I'm actually scum reading Gimli based off that.
Huh?
In post 540, DragonEater70 wrote:
Wow I LOVE kittie's case on Gimli. kittie has really won me over as being town.
So you didn't scum read Gimli based on Kittie's case? I interpreted 540 as you indeed thinking it was a strong case and subsequently agreeing that Gimli was scummy.
In post 560, DragonEater70 wrote:
2. I think you are wrong on Timmer being "classic newbtown". Unfortunately I am phone posting and tired so you don't get links, but please go check patchwork's and OMIGRON's ISO's in newbie 2112 or even Comet's, and compare to Timmer's ISO here.
Then have a look at elpis's ISO in newbie 2114 (elpis was scum) and also compare it to Timmer here. Please tell me which ISO Timmer feels most similar to.
I think it's a bit futile to compare newbie meta, no? Isn't the whole point of newbies that they're new and not going to have any kind of pre-existing meta to work with?
In post 560, DragonEater70 wrote:
2. I think you are wrong on Timmer being "classic newbtown". Unfortunately I am phone posting and tired so you don't get links, but please go check patchwork's and OMIGRON's ISO's in newbie 2112 or even Comet's, and compare to Timmer's ISO here.
Then have a look at elpis's ISO in newbie 2114 (elpis was scum) and also compare it to Timmer here. Please tell me which ISO Timmer feels most similar to.
I think it's a bit futile to compare newbie meta, no? Isn't the whole point of newbies that they're new and not going to have any kind of pre-existing meta to work with?
I disagree, I think you can slot newbies within a few specific archetypes and read them pretty accurately
-A
Plural | Nameless (They/He) and Alice (She/Her) and C (They/Them) and more
In post 562, TimmerRC wrote:
Considering that i just found that you are basically voting more than the rest of the game combined right now, I would say that you are posting a ton and know very well where the game is at? You are def my top scumread at the moment.
Hmmm... I think this is an interesting point. I'm going to file it away in my head for later.
In post 574, Afrayed Knott wrote:
but I didn't push back on you, I instigated the feel. You had virtually ignored me until I put you on my Lim list, as far as I can recall that is
I don't really consider being on a lim list as an active push. Also I'm pretty sure I had already had you on my lim list before you put up yours and posted a readlist where you were 3rd from the bottom so I wouldn't say I ignored you.
