In post 248, Cerulean wrote:Are Jason and mcstab your town reads or your scum reads? If scum, you should vote Jason.
Scumreads.
And I may. I'm going to sort out my reads properly tonight.
In post 248, Cerulean wrote:Are Jason and mcstab your town reads or your scum reads? If scum, you should vote Jason.
In post 210, Shadoweh wrote:Nost, who do you think had 'more misleading' content then Benmage at the point where I voted him?
In post 223, The Mini-Librarian wrote:
1. ("Contrived Reasoning". Heh, I see what you did there.) Anyway, it was the way he called for it. It was mentioned already and shot down. In his post he showed that he was reading at least some of thread so his call for name massclaim felt very weird to me. And as Benmage correctly noted Omar could easily want specific people dead.
In post 247, Cerulean wrote:The disagreement thing is something, I'm not real sure why you find suspicious, but is going to happen.
In post 125, TheGreatestAmericanHero wrote:dayne is town. his roleplay is the terrible-est, fakest reason to suspect someone ever. its not even hard to understand.
In post 149, Nostredeus wrote:@The Mini-L: Why don't you like Great American hero?
In post 113, SafetyDance wrote:Vote:Ser Arthur Dayne
I agree with Benmage. The RP is not helping and is annoying.
Bubbles is a scum CI anyway.
In post 254, Plessiezarus wrote:ChannelDeliBird: can you expound on 166 please? What suggests McStab has "a town mindset"?
In post 204, petapan wrote:vifam delivering one liners isn't relevant to his alignment that's just how he posts also he's p clearly posting content so ur dum imho
In post 209, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:In post 207, Vifam wrote:Peta always posts like that and you are really are dumb if you think that takes away from his statement
Hop with me on that-pretty-face-Jason?
In post 256, ChannelDelibird wrote:I don't see any difference there to the last time when I saw him [McStab] as town.
In post 257, ChannelDelibird wrote:As far as my posting style goes, it's fair enough if you dislike it, but this how I'm going to play. Brevity is pro-town; Walls of text aren't fun so I try hard not to write them and I don't read them either.
In post 257, ChannelDelibird wrote:I don't think my vote on SafetyDance for being too safe is hypocritical - him voting for Ser Arthur over the roleplaying thing is a really easy stance to take that requires no actual examination beyond the surface and would let him get lost in a crowd if the wagon built up.
In post 258, Cerulean wrote:Apologize for the length of the wall.
In post 258, Cerulean wrote:Tammy and others have told me in the past that Benmage prides himself on having "the best scum game on the site," and as such, he's much more aggressive and engaged as scum. He also tends to look down on people who are lazy or don't try very hard when they're mafia. As town, he's pretty much the opposite, I feel like he's a bit more passive and he can get pretty lazy and lurky. Regfan wrote a very concise summary of it here in ADwD, a game I feel he's playing very similarly to. I also took a look at one of his somewhat recent scum games here and I think you can pretty clearly see the difference (take a look at his interactions with MoI especially).
In post 258, Cerulean wrote:I don't see how SafetyDance's vote on Arthur in #113 is overexplained at all, in fact my problem with it is the exact opposite - it feels extremely lazy and undercooked.
In post 258, Cerulean wrote:Normally, I have a pretty easy time reading Arthur but I'm struggling this game I think largely due to his RP'ing. Tammy's told me his scum game has been improving, though, citing the recently finished Westeros game. Do you and Zar feel like he's playing similarly here or not (and why)?
In post 258, Cerulean wrote:Tammy found the intra-hydra back and forth regarding your townread on our slot to be genuine but I'm not so sure, I think something like that could be easily faked from you guys. I don't really trust myself to be able to read your slot given what I've heard about Zar's meta, though, so I'm pretty much delegating all of that to her.
In post 267, McStab wrote:Just a heads up based on setup spec relating to flavour; if a police character flips, they would almost certainly be the main scumteam. If an East-Side dealer flips, they are also probably a scumteam. I'd imagine we're either dealing with a two-faction setup like that (especially if this ends up being a Night-Action intensive game) or a large scumteam + SK (Omar Little as a BP SK makes alot of sense, for example). I know this is in the realm of speculation, but it's important that we interpret night actions correctly and people who are familiar with the flavour can likely help with that.
In post 251, DeasVail wrote:
Town
Cerulean
Benmage
Camn
Ser Arthur Dayne
TML
Shadoweh
Nostredeus
ChannelDelibird