NY 184: a help (done)

[Kinetic]

Apologies. Had a rather sudden V/La situation. catching up now.

[Lostaway]

Apologies. Had a rather sudden V/La situation. catching up now.

Kinetic, you made a rather neat dissection of RC's inconsistency in your 153, but in your 268 you voted Jake. It seems rather... inconsistent.

[Flubbernugget]

Yeah you were voting me over an oversoul post

I never fucking made

by your own admission my posts are open to interpretation. why did you jump to scumread instead of requesting clarification?

[Flubbernugget]

Yeah you were voting me over an oversoul post

I never fucking made

by your own admission my posts are open to interpretation. why did you jump to scumread instead of requesting clarification?

[Flubbernugget]

Feel's good to be ninja'd

those posts were directed at matt

[Elyse]

VOTE: Elyse

Heya! Can I get an overview of your thoughts on the game?

No.

Why are you ok with Lostaway's waffling when you say that my reads lack commitment?

I'm curious to see The Bulge's catchup post. Just the way that wagon formed and ended makes me think it's on scum. As someone (idr who, Oversoul maybe) pointed out, three of the players with the biggest reputations backed in and no one really bought into it because of the RC/Jake shit. And then it awkwardly faded out.

Flubber is a fine lynch at this point too. I feel like I don't like his play more than I think it's scummy so I'll stick with Bulge atm.

[pisskop]

Bulge wagon was weak. But I'm curious as to why he's been a complete noninfluence on the game thus far.

[pisskop]

If anything I feel more apt to scumread the people on the wagon for poor pushing/followup than him. At least, for the wagon itself.

[Elyse]

Well it's hard to push someone who's barely in the game.

[Elyse]

I guess that's why it fell apart. It just seems like a wagon that would usually take off early in the game and I think it's weird that it didn't.

[pisskop]

We have too many lurkers. By design or circumstance, too many.

[MattP]

Yeah you were voting me over an oversoul post

I never fucking made

by your own admission my posts are open to interpretation. why did you jump to scumread instead of requesting clarification?

You stated to RC that RC could make a scum case on OS but wasnt. I am asking you WHY YOU SAID THAT.

I'm not even going to engage your last paragraph. What did you mean in 425

[MattP]

Rc the worst part is that you could make an actual scum case on him right now and aren't

Why did you say RC could make a case on OS if you yourself didn't think OS wasnt scum

This is just the worst thing I've ever seen

[MattP]

This is the scummiest thing so far this game

So many people soft scum reading flubber but not voting or pressuring him is psychotic to me

[MattP]

You are saying:
1) you are not scum reading OS
2) you can't rationalize scum intent from OS
3) the worst thing going for RC is that he

can make a scum case on OS

but isn't

Like just lmfao

[Oversoul]

I'm such a topic of discussion

[MattP]

And then theres oversoul being equally as disengaging of any actual meaningful discussion happening this game

If only I had to dayvig shots
But idk if a 2dayvig + gunsmith town would be too overpowered, what do you think OS, lookin for an expert opinion

[MattP]

Two dayvig shots*

[Kinetic]

The Bulge (3): MattP, Oversoul, BROseidon

I'm just gonna throw out there how this wagon managed to gain 0 traction and relatively little mention over 10+ pages despite it being driven by:

1) 3 players who are all pretty universally town or null read
2) 3 players who are probably the players with the strongest reputations in the game.

4 if you include me, but I'm not on it right now.

Apologies. Had a rather sudden V/La situation. catching up now.

Kinetic, you made a rather neat dissection of RC's inconsistency in your 153, but in your 268 you voted Jake. It seems rather... inconsistent.

Because right now I'm reading RC is anti-town, but not scum. Its a fine line, her play leaves something to be desired, but I'm not reading... scum feelings from it. Some of her frustration seems genuine, just ill-placed. It reads as someone reacting poorly rather than calculatedly. I'd place her neutral, leaning town on my feelings.

Between 153 and 268, I felt more scum vibes from Jake. While I read genuine frustration from RC, I started reading more calculation from Jake. As I was catching up, I've been up and down on Jake and RC. RC's latest 5-8 pages of content has been stronger. I really like my vote on Jake right now.

Of the other players in the game:

Town Reads (in no order):
Vyse
Bro

Neutral (leaning town)
RC
EPM
Oversoul
PK

True Neutral
Matt
Grimm
Bulge
Lost
Elyse

Neutral (leaning scum):
Flubb
Jake

I really don't have any SOLID scum reads yet. I like my vote on Jake where it is. I'm caught up now, and shouldn't have too many V/LA issues for the time being.

[MattP]

Kinetic, are you fully caught up

[Kinetic]

Kinetic, are you fully caught up

Indeed. I skimmed some parts but I've read the whole thread.

[Oversoul]

And then theres oversoul being equally as disengaging of any actual meaningful discussion happening this game

If only I had to dayvig shots
But idk if a 2dayvig + gunsmith town would be too overpowered, what do you think OS, lookin for an expert opinion

Dayvig? Nah. Probably night Vig.
Means scum have RB though.

Also, are you assuming the first post means it is in the game? I asked the mod if that is what it meant and he said no. Why did everyone assume that?

[MattP]

Aw man not diggin your reads list

Pedit: I was being snarky OS

[Oversoul]

I mean sure. Flubber is lurking/coasting/not giving any content. Would I cry at his lynch? No. Would I support it if I had to? Sure.
I find it odd that Flubber is the first player you go after. I would think you would go after someone who is tougher to lynch (although Flubber seems to be difficult to corral interest around).

Depending on town power, this might be 10:4, but I think 10:3

[Oversoul]

I am curious how Jake will respond to me when he gets back.