So I consider these more or less confirmed town:
-Ranger (I believe she is the vig, according to wiki SKs normally kill with knives, ARS was shot. Also I cannot see why Ranger would claim vig as scum here. And it makes sense from Rangers readlist)
-pisskop (He got a guilty check on Makoto. I believe him, as there is no reason for scum to claim this at this point in the game).
Then we have scum:
-Makoto. Given pisskop is not lying, or something have messed up his night action on Makoto (he claims someone visiting her could have messed it up for instance).
Given Makoto is scum I think it is most likely that we find the last scum in between:
-Klingoncelt (Makoto have no read on her. Klingoncelt got a lean town on Makoto, and her post 656 seems like she is trying to discredit the pisskops guilty on Makoto)
In post 476, Klingoncelt wrote:A Royal Saint - Town - is scumhunting and being sensible.
Davesaz - Happy Birthday! - Town - is scumhunting and being sensible.
Firebringer/(Gameplay506) - Gameplay was useless and deserved the lynch, too bad he was unlynchable. Firebringer's better, but that vote restriction is as much a pain in the ass as mine. I'm going to give him a Lean Town
Makato Nayaya - Nice altslip. Into the game and seems to be enjoying it. Reads are reasonable. Lean Town
Scorpious - Seems okay. Lean Town
Davsto - Call it gut, but I'm not getting a strong Town vibe. Null.
Ranger - Null
The Silver Bard - Lean Town
Pisskop - FAKED his post restriction. Wants to PL me. Lots of fluff in his posts. Lean Scum
The Jester - Reads are about opposite of mine. Lean Scum
Expedience - The pushes seem contrived. Says my post restriction is fake. Votes for me, tries to get others to. Scum.
Hiplop - Declares Expedience to be Town. Says my post restriction is fake. Rest of his posts are short & crappy.
Way Scum.
-davesaz (Makoto townleaning him. davesaz joins the wagon at a time when the Lynch on Maoto is inevitable. May be they discussed this in scumchat and decided he should bus. It also seems like davesaz have been softdefending Makoto like in post 195).
In post 195, davesaz wrote: In post 182, The_Jester wrote:
VOTE: Makoto
My main suspect, mostly gut but I don't like that she posts almost exclusively fluff, tries to look useful but really isn't, doesn't take decisive stances. Looks like cautious newbscum to me.
If this wagon doesn't gain traction I'm gonna switch but I'm the most comfortable with my vote there atm.
This has to do for the time being.
First question, have you read all of Mokoto's posts? The question goes to the newbscum angle.
TBH I would have to reread to confirm the observation you're making here. But for the sake of argument let's stipulate your characterization of the posts is accurate (if it's inaccurate then we have a different problem and it is you). Is being fluffy and not taking stances really alignment indicative? I have seen others say that gut means you see something wrong but can't put a finger on it, so let's explore that a bit. If there is a plausible scum motivation for being fluffy in this case then you might just be onto something. Perhaps the lack of a definitive stance you're seeing rings alarm bells because of what else is going on at the time. Does that jog help you with defining it better?
-Scorpious (A null read from Makoto. Also haven't interacted or mention Makoto at all this game. Instantly joins the wagon, which is in his favor, but this might be scum thinking Makoto got caught and that he need to bus ASAP. He laters unvotes as soon as pisskop tells town to wait with the lynch. Seems to me like a rushed vote from scum, now trying to backtrack at the first oportunity).
I find it less likely that Firebringer, The Jester and Davsto is scum with Makoto
