In post 2533, nn30 wrote:
My scum reading Shadow has less to do with you and more to do with his actions today. You pushing him adds a confusing wrinkle though.
I've got this big convoluted triangle bouncing around in my brain.
Shadow has been acting ridiculous all day - plenty of people have pointed this out. Not going to beat a dead horse. He feels scummy for this reason.
Beginning of the day you hopped onto my wagon (as the 3rd voter) with some flimsy reasoning and then wrote half a novel about why you hopped off. Felt weird to me - like you hopped on opportunistically and then hopped off when the lynch wasn't going to happen. You then move onto push Shadow.
Which makes me think you two can't be scum together.
Then there's the case on boring - which you have written at length that you simply don't agree with the reasons she's being scum read. This links the two of you in my eyes - it seems that, if you're scum, you're distracting from Boring by pushing Shadow.
Then Shadow is pushing me - which could also be a distraction from Boring.
Then there's Diefire who nobody has a handle on yet.
Truth is, I'd rate a 75% chance of the remaining scum being in these four. I just don't know how the puzzle fits together.
I will be honest; my vote on you at the start of the day was pretty lazy. I felt like had you pretty much pegged as scum off the wagon. I still had my strong town read on shadow, and while I wasn’t particularly keen on Penguin, I thought you were worse in comparison. I thought the likihood that you are scum was like… in the 90’s percentile. And if that doesn’t make me confidant, and a bit lazy, coming into today then I don’t know what would.
Hold on there buckaroo
, you wanted my current read on you. It wasn’t like that “half a novel” was unprovoked. Also gross word usage, if you consider four paragraphs half a novel then… idk, just seems like a bad description. You wanted me to respond with a read. If I said, “I think you’re town”. Would that seriously been enough for you?
If I had done that then you would be accusing me of being too vague right now.
I just find that you being suspicious of Shadow when I was the one who first called him out, while keeping me as top scum is pretty bad imo. You being perfectly happy to see Me, boring, shadow, and Penguin lynched makes me wonder if we are all town, and you are scum. You have Dierfire out there too, but given that town has four lynches left. It comes across like a back pocket read. Since lynching us in order of who you find most scummy would be Me<Boring<PengiunPower<Shadow. That mean you would not actually have to see Deirfire lynched. So you sayyou can't read him, and say he is probably scum for it, but you aren't willing to lynch him over the other four right?
This is part of the reason I could see a LUVxDeirfirexnn30 scum team btw.