You brought up the point that Dayvig-flavor IC was strange; my counterpoint was that Davig-flavor godfather wasn't any less strange.In post 1810, Kagami wrote:If Dayvig-flavor godfather is strange to you, why were so gung-ho on scum-wisdom? Does 1381 still represent the depth of your (former?) wisdom scumread?
Ah.In post 1811, Kagami wrote:Exploding Rune
My frustration with him tunneling me here is less of a one game thing and more of an extended game to game to game sort of thing. I am scumreading him, will elaborate on that when I have a little time in the future.In post 1812, farside22 wrote:Are you scum reading him?
I ask because all I saw in catch up was accusing him of tunneling, which is hypocrisy at best and wrong at worst.
I'm more skeptical than you of this at this point.In post 1815, Kagami wrote:MoI did not allow for a reasonable chance that the game ends N1, which is highly possible if we take the current situation at face value.
I'm not sure how MoI would approach this, exactly. I think there are a couple of routes he could have taken; I don't think he would place significant information within flavor intentionally and I'm sure that he's not naive enough to fall into a "all good guys are town and all bad guys are scum" type of trap.In post 1815, Kagami wrote:There is no suitable flavor on the scumteam for the stabbing, so for wisdom to be scum, MoI deliberately designed the role to deceive the Town and went to the trouble of pushing that through bulb's death scene.
To 736?In post 1824, Kagami wrote:I want to entertain wisdom-SK, but I don't think it makes sense for there to be a killing penalty then, and I don't think MoI would have added the last bit to 730 if there weren't one.
That's nice. Do you have a summary of your thoughts that would be suitable for Mr. Cakes glazy eyes?In post 1855, Nachomamma8 wrote:Kagami, I think you might be getting way too lost in flavor/setup speculation.
its hard to explain these nuances but im certain he's scum. he feels different for a lot of reasons, but what makes me comfortable keeping my vote on him is his reactions to being called scum here are unique to what i know him to be like. like yeah...sorry im still shit at explaining why people feel different to me when they do...im just confident he'll flip scumIn post 1772, Nachomamma8 wrote:What do you think of him compared to Real Folks Blues? I disliked him that game because it felt like he was just sort of floating along, and he feels pretty similar to there; the only major difference in my mind is the reasons I'm bothered by his interactions with me.In post 1537, kraska77 wrote:Either way I still prefer lynching cakes first. Idk why the stuff I said on him got dismissed as bs earlier...cakes has been in almost all my recent games, nothing he put out here looks like a product of a scum hunting mindset. There is not a single novel/personal explanation he provided for the way his readlists morphed throughout the game. I look at the way his readlists changed and can't help but think this is scum following changes in the game and putting together readlists as uncontentious as possible
I wonder why that could be....In post 1867, Wisdom wrote:Nacho, i see you defending farside, defending me, defending yourself to Tammy, and discussing with kagami and infinity about things.
What i dont see you doing is scumhunting. You dont seem to care at all about finding the remaining scum.
I think that Cakez and Peregrine is scum. I think there's something off with the Leon situation but am not particularly inclined on exploring it right this second.In post 1867, Wisdom wrote:Nacho, i see you defending farside, defending me, defending yourself to Tammy, and discussing with kagami and infinity about things.
What i dont see you doing is scumhunting. You dont seem to care at all about finding the remaining scum.