Newbie 1779 | Spring | Endgame

[mhsmith0]

Rude

How? More rude than

Stop mewling, your day or reckoning is nigh

???

[mhsmith0]

Now, here's a game-relevant challenge for people: what do I think of mastina? Why do you think I think it?

Anyone who wants to try and get into my headspace, both in terms of learning in general (since this is a newbie game) and in terms of actually trying to solve, is welcome to give it a shot

Spoiler: one post that may be a hint to what I'm thinking and why I'm thinking it

My list at this point

Mhsmith
Dogwatch
Oldwino

RC
Pieg
Darklyn

Grey
Mastina

If you were making a similar list in your previous newbie games on MS around midday d1, where would scum have been?

[Icy]

Now, here's a game-relevant challenge for people: what do I think of mastina? Why do you think I think it?

Yea, I kind of get it that you think my read is wrong, but I have no idea why.

[Icy]

Hey PP

Thanks for the cake

[Icy]

You're making a strange implication here. I've seen plenty of games where scum

avoided suspicion all game

...

I've read a bunch of games here, and have never read such a game.

[RadiantCowbells]

I've seen plenty of such games.

Also Darklyn is a scumfuck

[Darklyn]

You're making a strange implication here. I've seen plenty of games where scum

avoided suspicion all game

...

I've read a bunch of games here, and have never read such a game.

There's a finished one on the front page m8

I've seen plenty of such games.

Also Darklyn is a scumfuck

u2 <3

[pieg]

tempted to replace out and let a newbie into this slot tbh

[Darklyn]

I will miss you

[pieg]

I value experienced conftown's thoughts, etc. and would like Icy to contribute as much as able because we know they are town-driven. But it's also true everyone needs to participate and generate as much dialog, logic, etc. as possible in an effort to expose scum, especially in retrospect during D2 and beyond. No one gets a free pass. Anyone loitering is suspect.

In my first game, I voted mostly based on fewest posts - so of course I help lynch townies on D1 and D2 and town lost fast.

So I'm looking at content now, scum-hunting content, and don't find much anywhere. Will focus on ISOing everyone and counting scum hunting posts, overly defensive posts, and 'avoidance' posts.

don't ever do the bolded as town. this lets scum forego scumhunting for lynching by activity. lurking is anti-town behavior, but it's nai. you have to look at WHY a slot is lurking. activity can be a valuable indicator but it should never be your primary or sole criterion. and, there's been plenty of scumhunting going on. if you aren't seeing it that is a problem.

[PenguinPower]

pieg has requested a replacement

[RadiantCowbells]

zzz

[PenguinPower]

lemonater replaces pieg

[lemonater]

Hi everyone!

[RadiantCowbells]

So I sorta came around on Mastina being town.

That leaves me with a pretty hefty townblock.

[Darklyn]

Well yeah, we're all town except you and your buddy

[lemonater]

Alright

I've read up on the game, will probably do a proper read through in the morning

Just so everyone knows, this is my first game on MS, though I've played a couple of games offsite

[-Grey-]

Welcome to the game, lemon.

Looking forward to your perspective.

[-Grey-]

As far as mine goes, it's mostly apathetic.

Being bitched at for posting too much by one player and not saying enough by another has given me a pretty much idgaf attitude right now.

[Darklyn]

Grey, do you have any thoughts on who is scum?

[-Grey-]

Apparently you missed post 593.

You should probably read it.

[Darklyn]

VOTE: -Grey- stop being a baby

[-Grey-]

That's no way to get what you want.

See you folks in 48 hours.

[oldwino]

I value experienced conftown's thoughts, etc. and would like Icy to contribute as much as able because we know they are town-driven. But it's also true everyone needs to participate and generate as much dialog, logic, etc. as possible in an effort to expose scum, especially in retrospect during D2 and beyond. No one gets a free pass. Anyone loitering is suspect.

In my first game, I voted mostly based on fewest posts - so of course I help lynch townies on D1 and D2 and town lost fast.

So I'm looking at content now, scum-hunting content, and don't find much anywhere. Will focus on ISOing everyone and counting scum hunting posts, overly defensive posts, and 'avoidance' posts.

don't ever do the bolded as town. this lets scum forego scumhunting for lynching by activity. lurking is anti-town behavior, but it's nai. you have to look at WHY a slot is lurking. activity can be a valuable indicator but it should never be your primary or sole criterion. and, there's been plenty of scumhunting going on. if you aren't seeing it that is a problem.

Pieg didn't read my post clearly enough. I learned that lesson (voting on low vote count only) in my first game. Yes, there is scum hunting going on here, but also lots of non-participation and s-posting. And some very effective hiding.

If no one else thinks Mastina is scum it's time I change my vote. Time is getting short and I won't be online at all on Monday, a day that could/should be critical. Can't help it, traveling and no internet until Tuesday morning (I hope). So I need to make my move by tomorrow. I'll ISO everyone and jump on whomever I think is most suspicious, someone not hunting but maybe pretending to do so. Anyone wanting to make a case, either way, now's your chance to try to influence me. Once I change my vote, I may not have the opportunity to do so again until D2.

[Darklyn]

That's no way to get what you want.

See you folks in 48 hours.

come back

If no one else thinks Mastina is scum it's time I change my vote.

If you're gonna change your vote just do it, waiting makes you look indecisive and opportunistic