@Alisae - I just want to confirm you mean RC was right about his scum reads of Grey near the end of D1?
@ Everyone
I've been skimming and reading and skimming. Much of Mastina's analysis is too dense for me and since she is convinced I am scum, and has been since page 1, I don't think I'll change her mind even if I could follow enough of her logic to try to counter it. And Dark seems determined to sheep Mastina, so they both will just go on thinking I am scum until the truth is finally revealed.
On to battles maybe I can influence. Grey is still my strongest scum lean, but some of that may be my dislike of his play style, his over zealous antagonism toward several players, his walls of ranting, etc. etc. But I am still suspicious because of his 6-7 vote changes, not slinging mud to see 'what sticks' as Mastina characterized it, but putting up votes of players he knew were town to see if he could gather any support to lynch any of them. Except maybe for his early vote on RC, which I interpret, in my Grey-RC scum scenario, as distancing, etc. etc. of his scum buddy.
No one has responded, I don't think, to my crazy scenario of both RC and Grey replacing out because they had a scum feud overnight and couldn't agree on WHO would kill Dark (or Icy, take your pick). I spotted this feud early on and asked Grey about bad blood between them from a previous game, which he denied. I asked him how he read RC and he said he couldn't read RC on D1. Just lots of pro-con attitude from Grey towards RC which made me, and still makes me, suspicious of the pair. Alisea seems more town to me than RC did, maybe because of my read of the Grey-RC battles and interaction. Alisea seems more genuinely helpful scum hunting than RC did. RC posted a lot of one-liners with no strong reasoning. He was strongest during twilight when Smith's fate was decided. Scummy RC, I thought, stay away for most of D1 then show up to watch the lynch?
Alisae seems much more town to me than RC did, but since it's the slot that matters, I don't know. Maybe she's playing better scum than RC did, maybe BECAUSE Grey isn't around antagonizing. A fresh start for that slot.
My other scum leanings are still Mastina, although her long absence during the last part f D1 made me less suspicious of her. I don't think she'd leave her scum buddy alone that long if her buddy was a newbie, but maybe she would leave Grey alone, figuring he could handle scum's interests well enough on his own - and get her out of sight for a while. But for some reason, ethics maybe, I don't think she'd leave even Grey alone near the end of D1 if they were scum buddies. That leaves lemonator and Dog. I think I believe Dog's townslip - much better players than me believe it. So that leaves Lemon, who I've leaned town on most of the game.
For me - it's Scum Grey, partnered with almost a toss up among, but in order, Alisae (because of RC's play and interactions with Grey), then Mastina, then Lemonator.
)
