Newbie 1799 | URW 4 | Finally Over OMG

[Elbirn]

I still need to do more thinks and I've got work to do and also I'm still feeling hungover from last night so I'm not doing my best mental thinking work

The thing that's doing my head in right now is that, with drixx being at L-1 for like over a week, should have meant that either

1. Drixx was last scum
2. Scum was already on the wagon

Because I don't know how else scum-Raya doesn't take advantage of the opportunity to take a free mislynch. I went into a bit of a tunnel on Raya considering what I viewed to be some scummy behavior, and admittedly it's quite possible that scum-Raya is too timid / admitted herself that she thinks optimal scum play is to avoid suspicion and maybe thinks a hammer would draw too much attention

So I need to go think about that some more

I'm also needing to think about the implications of nk'd itlepip, and what motivations go into that. He was apparently townread by all so not really mislynchable, making him an obvious target.. but also consider who becomes the most mislynchable person depending on the night kill, and who scum wants to take to lylo. If scum is key, this is the exact lylo she would want, if me and Raya seemed set to go against each other. If scum were raya...well, if I were her, I'd have shot me, not itlepip, I think.

Idk, back to anime and drinking water

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 4.01

Start of a home and our new raft.

---

Lynching

With 3 votes in play, it takes 2 to lynch.

Everybody

(L-2): Nobody

Not Voting

(3): Elbirn, keyenpeydee, Raya36

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Raya36 is V/LA until today
keyenpeydee is V/LA until 13 July

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-07-22 14:00:00)

[/area]

[keyenpeydee]

Guys seriously, we need to talk.
I don't know, honestly, who is the last scum. I want to recheck things, too, but I'm on V/LA and I'll do it when I have the time.

[Plotinus]

Keyenpeydee has been nudged (unofficially prodded).

[Elbirn]

Raya, did your VLA end? Come play
So lonely

[Elbirn]

Enclosed below is a spoiler of vote counts that may or may not matter. I'm going to think about them later.
You really don't need to bother opening the spoiler it's literally garbage and no commentary and is entirely for my own information because I'm at work on phone and no where to save

I'll say that the Day 1 fighting between key vs. Flog as dueling wagons, followed by the lynch on whatshisnameburgerkingmaybe is the key here, just have to analyze it

Spoiler:

Official Vote Count 1.05

Almost done the house! Maybe I can kill this elk.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

ZZZX

(L-5): Raya36

Platinum

(L-5): Rikku

Rikku

(L-4): platinum

bombcat

(L-5): ZZZX, keyenpeydee, Burgerking

Burgerking

(L-1): bombcat, shuffleplay, ZZZX, Raya36

shuffleplay

(L-4): Burgerking

Not Voting

(3):

shuffleplay

, Drixx, keyenpeydee, Rikku

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.09

Finally caught something in a trap! I know it doesn't seem that long to you guys because it's only been 10 pages but this was four entire months of gameplay.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-3): ZZZX, Raya36

Raya36

(L-4): Burgerking

Bombcat

(L-5): TheFlogScrogger

TheFlogScrogger

(L-5): bombcat

keyenpeydee

(L-2): bombcat, keyenpeydee, TheFlogScrogger

Not Voting

(3): Drixx,

keyenpeydee

, platinum, shuffleplay

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Drixx is V/LA until today
Keyenpeydee is V/LA until Monday

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.10

I got a dog and named it Snežana

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-3): ZZZX, Raya36

Raya36

(L-4): Burgerking

keyenpeydee

(L-2): bombcat, keyenpeydee, TheFlogScrogger

Not Voting

(3): Drixx, platinum, shuffleplay

Mod notes

: Keep it fun! Personal attacks are not okay.

Drixx is V/LA until today

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.11

Finally! The elk provided 179 cuts of meat so now we can stop buying food at villages. Also maybe we can finally make some skis now that winter is almost over. The snow is deeper than our waist so it will be worth it.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-4): ZZZX,

Raya36

Raya36

(L-4): Burgerking

keyenpeydee

(L-2): bombcat,

keyenpeydee

, TheFlogScrogger, Raya36

TheFlogScrogger

(L-4): keyenpeydee

Not Voting

(3): Drixx, platinum, shuffleplay,

keyenpeydee

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.12

Finally another quest.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-4): ZZZX

Raya36

(L-4): Burgerking

keyenpeydee

(L-2): bombcat, TheFlogScrogger, Raya36

TheFlogScrogger

(L-4): keyenpeydee

platinum

(L-4): shuffleplay

Not Voting

(2): Drixx, platinum,

shuffleplay

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.13

Exhausted from travelling homewards in the snow, I stopped to light a fire to rest, but the dog interrupted me by barking in alarm. I cancelled the task and zoomed out a little to see what was going on and there are robbers in the tile I zoomed in on. I guess I'm about to lose the net I got a discount on at the village. I'm way too fatigued to win this fight but I will try.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-4): ZZZX

Raya36

(L-4): Burgerking

keyenpeydee

(L-2): bombcat, TheFlogScrogger, Raya36

TheFlogScrogger

(L-3): keyenpeydee, Drixx

platinum

(L-4): shuffleplay

Not Voting

(1):

Drixx

, platinum

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-10 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.14

Yeah, I didn't even get one hit in.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-4): ZZZX

Raya36

(L-5): Burgerking

keyenpeydee

(L-1): bombcat, TheFlogScrogger, Raya36, Burgerking

TheFlogScrogger

(L-3): keyenpeydee, Drixx

platinum

(L-4): shuffleplay

Not Voting

(1): platinum

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-11 14:00:00)[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.16

yessss another elk

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-2): ZZZX,

ThinkBig

, keyenpeydee, bombcat

keyenpeydee

(L-4):

bombcat

, Raya36,

Burgerking

ThinkBig

(L-3):

keyenpeydee

, Drixx, Burgerking

platinum

(L-5): shuffleplay

bombcat

(L-4): shuffleplay

Not Voting

(2): platinum,

ThinkBig, keyenpeydee

, ThinkBig

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-11 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.17

It is the end of Soil month, aka March, and I have finally managed to make some skis...just in time for spring which starts in Swidden month (April). The snow will be melted by late April / Early May (Seedtime month) but anyway we have skis now yay.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-1): ZZZX, keyenpeydee, bombcat, Raya36

keyenpeydee

(L-5): Raya36

ThinkBig

(L-5): Drixx, Burgerking

bombcat

(L-1): shuffleplay, ThinkBig, Burgerking, Drixx

Not Voting

(1): platinum,

ThinkBig

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-11 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 1.19

A bear! So, bears are dangerous! Bears will fuck you up. Don't go messing with bears. But if you have to mess with bears then ranged weapons while it's in a trap and can't get you are a good start. If you don't have any ranged weapons and don't want to go buy some are bored to throw rocks at it until it dies then tie your dog to a tree because your dog will defend you to the death and it's not going to win, and engage the bear but back up and walk away as soon as you get more than slightly injured.

There's a recent change that trapped animals don't live forever anymore and will die of natural causes after a little while in the trap but I am going to try to kill it a little bit on my own first, but if it injures me then I'll retreat and let it die on its own. Bears can one hit kill you but they don't always, especially if you have good armour (which I don't).

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Burgerking

(L-0): ZZZX, bombcat, Raya36, keyenpeydee, ThinkBig

<-- LYNCH

bombcat

(L-3):

ThinkBig

, Burgerking, Drixx

Not Voting

(2): platinum, shuffleplay

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

shuffleplay is V/LA until Friday

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-11 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 2.11

Code: Select all

<Plotinus> urwbot, start
<URWBot> Custom - too easy, named Reko, 6) Koivulainen, Male, 1) Spring, 3) Unfortunate 
                  hunting trip. First reduce each skill as much as possible, then increase these 
                  skills: sword, swimming, tracking, weatherlore, club, herblore, hideworking, 
                  carpentry, cookery, stealth, axe, survival

---

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Raya36

(L-2): keyenpeydee, nancy

keyenpeydee

(L-4): RadiantCowbells

Not Voting

(5): Drixx, Raya36, ZZZX, ThinkBig, RadiantCowbells

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Drixx is V/LA for medical reasons.

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-26 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 2.12

Heading west to settle on the shore near Sartola. We were near Reemi before. Gonna try to get a quest from one of these villages.

---

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Raya36

(L-3): keyenpeydee,

nancy

itlepip

(L-4): nancy

nancy

(L-2): Drixx, ThinkBig

Not Voting

(4):

Drixx

, Raya36, Elbirn,

ThinkBig

, itlepip, nancy

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Elbirn is the new ZZZX! itlepip is the new RadiantCowbells!

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-26 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 2.13

Success! People dress differently in the western cultures. There's a wounded adventurer here. We'll talk to him and then go get his weapon back for him.

---

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Raya36

(L-1): keyenpeydee, Elbirn, nancy

nancy

(L-2): Drixx, ThinkBig

itlepip

(L-4): nancy

Not Voting

(2): Raya36,

Elbirn

, itlepip,

nancy

Mod notes

: Keep it fun!

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-26 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 2.14

Here it is! Now to bring it back to him and continue our journey west.

---

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Raya36

(L-2): keyenpeydee,

Elbirn, nancy

, Drixx

nancy

(L-4): Drixx, ThinkBig

Drixx

(L-4): itlepip

ThinkBig

(L-0): nancy, Elbirn, itlepip, ThinkBig

<-- LYNCH

Not Voting

(1): Raya36,

itlepip, Elbirn, nancy

Mod notes

: A lynch has been achieved!

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-06-26 14:00:00)

[/area]

Official Vote Count 3.05

Took a few tries to light the fire, but we did it! Now we just need to sit next to the fire until we're no longer freezing to death. I'm going to make a hole in the ice and try some fishing while I wait!

---

Lynching

With 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to lynch.

Drixx

(L-0): itlepip, keyenpeydee, Elbirn

<-- LYNCH

Raya36

(L-3): Elbirn

Elbirn

(L-2): Raya36

Not Voting

(1): Drixx

Mod notes

: A lynch has been achieved!

keyenpeydee is V/LA until 13 July

Deadline

:

(expired on 2017-07-09 14:00:00)

[/area]

[Plotinus]

Raya36⁶ has been prodded. Since this is her sixth prod, she is also being replaced. If she posts before a replacement can be found, she can stay.

[Elbirn]

Raya36⁶ has been prodded. Since this is her sixth prod, she is also being replaced. If she posts before a replacement can be found, she can stay.

[keyenpeydee]

RAYA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[keyenpeydee]

Elbirn, do you think Raya is scum or do you think I'm scum?

[keyenpeydee]

VOTE: Raya

[Raya36]

I'm back! Sorry, a lot came up so I wasn't able to get on. Promise I'll post stuff after work.

[keyenpeydee]

UNVOTE:

[Elbirn]

VOTE: Raya

What was this?

[Raya36]

I still need to do more thinks and I've got work to do and also I'm still feeling hungover from last night so I'm not doing my best mental thinking work

The thing that's doing my head in right now is that, with drixx being at L-1 for like over a week, should have meant that either

1. Drixx was last scum
2. Scum was already on the wagon

Because I don't know how else scum-Raya doesn't take advantage of the opportunity to take a free mislynch. I went into a bit of a tunnel on Raya considering what I viewed to be some scummy behavior, and admittedly it's quite possible that scum-Raya is too timid / admitted herself that she thinks optimal scum play is to avoid suspicion and maybe thinks a hammer would draw too much attention

So I need to go think about that some more

I'm also needing to think about the implications of nk'd itlepip, and what motivations go into that. He was apparently townread by all so not really mislynchable, making him an obvious target.. but also consider who becomes the most mislynchable person depending on the night kill, and who scum wants to take to lylo. If scum is key, this is the exact lylo she would want, if me and Raya seemed set to go against each other. If scum were raya...well, if I were her, I'd have shot me, not itlepip, I think.

Idk, back to anime and drinking water

I agree that this is the perfect lylo for Key. I think if you were scum you would have shot me for the same reason you said I would have shot you. But at the same time this could be you trying to lead us in the wrong direction.

The more and more I think the more sus I am of Key but I still don't feel good about Elbirn. Aaahhh I don't know what to think anymore Dx

[Raya36]

VOTE: Raya

This vote really doesn't help my suspicions. Care to explain?

[Elbirn]

Raya what do you think about key and Flogger wagoning each other on day 1? If you have time, can you reread those posts/pages and give me some thoughts? It's also...interesting, where key claims scum and tells flog to stop bussing her. Repeatedly.

For example, I don't know whether or not to conclude that "oh, they did some elaborate distancing/bussing play right there" or to conclude "okay lol they can't be scum together"

[Raya36]

That's a good point. Thinking back now that we know Flog was scum it seems a bit odd for town!Key to say that Flog was bussing him then by coincidence Flog actually turned out to be scum and could have actually been bussing him.

You were the one that claimed to be unaffected and posted a meme. I am here to finish the fight. I will not back down.

I was attacking your playstyle because you keep on bussing your scum partner, who can't respond to pressure and who hasn't played scum for a long time.

This post also seems really genuine knowing now that Flog is scum.

I think a theory could be that it was distancing play gone wrong. I think Flog was meant to push a little and it was supposed to be in a more joking tone and Key was supposed to joke back and defend himself which ended up backfiring with a frustrated scum claim from Key and possibly Flog backstabbing his partner in hopes that bussing and creating a wagon on him would take any sus away from him and give him some towncred.

The strength of my town read on Key came from the interaction with Flog but now that I look back I'm a lot less confident that they couldn't be scum partners.

[keyenpeydee]

I honestly don't know why I did that but all I know is that I want to end the game because this is seriously getting boring especially if Raya was replaced.

Elbirn, you've been really helpful a lot lately and I would really give you town points for that, however, I don't really trust your slot. Maybe because it was a ZZZX slot.

Raya, I know that I've been scumreading you so hard Day 2, but honestly, I am really townreading you at this point and since when you gave that ThinkBig case. I still don't trust you though and I would be really frustrated if you really turned out scum this game, but I would assume that you're town here.

So that leaves "me", whom I know is town. If I were scum, this isn't the LyLo I would go for, instead, I would've killed Raya since I think that she can convince Elbirn/Itle's slot that I'm scum, she can also be a threat to me, and I want to get rid of her since Day 2, but she wasn't the one who was killed last night, so I don't really agree with the reason that this is the LyLo I want.

Sure that Flog's slot was scum, but I would never EVER really hardclaim as scum like that. Sure, I claimed scum, but not that I would really completely claim that I'm scum. I hardclaimed scum because Flog was insulting, frustrating, and manipulating as fuck, and I feel really defeated to the point that I just want out of this game, but I still tried my best to stay on this game. I've been really unhelpful with a lot of the games I joined in, and I don't really want that to be my meta, but that's just how I play.

Bussing is also not on my playstyle if I am gonna be scum, so if I were scum with Flog, then I wouldn't be able to bus and create a case against him given that I can't respond to pressure and I don't really give a case that much against a person.

Sorry if I've been unhelpful on this game and some events I may not remember since a lot had happened, so I'll try to re-read my ISO. I'm really lazy af.

Soooooooooo to be clear, I want to lynch Elbirn rather than Raya. Still hesitant on this, but this is the one I want to go for.

[keyenpeydee]

Raya, is it Elbirn that you think is the last scum?
Elbrin, who are you scumreading?

[keyenpeydee]

I really want some direct answers to my questions so I want to question this:

1. Raya and Elbirn, what's your read on Itlepip?

My read on itlepip is town, though I scumread bombcat.

[keyenpeydee]

Guys we have like 8 days and I wouldn't want to spend that 8 days without us being so inactive and shits

I think we should really talk and end this game.

I'm not really desperate to end this game, but I just want to avoid inactivity and replacements going.

[Raya36]

Raya, is it Elbirn that you think is the last scum?
Elbrin, who are you scumreading?

I don't know. I'm second guessing myself hard. My biggest problem with your vote for me was that if you aren't scum you just set the game up so that scum could easily hop on and hammer.

I really want some direct answers to my questions so I want to question this:

1. Raya and Elbirn, what's your read on Itlepip?

My read on itlepip is town, though I scumread bombcat.

Was Itle not nked?

Guys we have like 8 days and I wouldn't want to spend that 8 days without us being so inactive and shits

I think we should really talk and end this game.

I'm not really desperate to end this game, but I just want to avoid inactivity and replacements going.

I'm happy to talk. I'd like to figure this game out.

[Elbirn]

I really want some direct answers to my questions so I want to question this:

1. Raya and Elbirn, what's your read on Itlepip?

My read on itlepip is town, though I scumread bombcat.

What the fuck am I reading

[Elbirn]

I honestly don't know why I did that but all I know is that I want to end the game because this is seriously getting boring especially if Raya was replaced.

Elbirn, you've been really helpful a lot lately and I would really give you town points for that, however, I don't really trust your slot. Maybe because it was a ZZZX slot.

Raya, I know that I've been scumreading you so hard Day 2, but honestly, I am really townreading you at this point and since when you gave that ThinkBig case. I still don't trust you though and I would be really frustrated if you really turned out scum this game, but I would assume that you're town here.

So that leaves "me", whom I know is town. If I were scum, this isn't the LyLo I would go for, instead, I would've killed Raya since I think that she can convince Elbirn/Itle's slot that I'm scum, she can also be a threat to me, and I want to get rid of her since Day 2, but she wasn't the one who was killed last night, so I don't really agree with the reason that this is the LyLo I want.

Sure that Flog's slot was scum, but I would never EVER really hardclaim as scum like that. Sure, I claimed scum, but not that I would really completely claim that I'm scum. I hardclaimed scum because Flog was insulting, frustrating, and manipulating as fuck, and I feel really defeated to the point that I just want out of this game, but I still tried my best to stay on this game. I've been really unhelpful with a lot of the games I joined in, and I don't really want that to be my meta, but that's just how I play.

Bussing is also not on my playstyle if I am gonna be scum, so if I were scum with Flog, then I wouldn't be able to bus and create a case against him given that I can't respond to pressure and I don't really give a case that much against a person.

Sorry if I've been unhelpful on this game and some events I may not remember since a lot had happened, so I'll try to re-read my ISO. I'm really lazy af.

Soooooooooo to be clear, I want to lynch Elbirn rather than Raya. Still hesitant on this, but this is the one I want to go for.

This post was wishy washy garbage consisting of

1. Telling us what you would or would not do as scum, as if that's something that's not going to be biased, and comes across fishy as all hell. Very over defensive
2. Telling us that, basically, you have reasons to townread me and have wanted Raya gone for days...but you want to lynch me instead for no reason