In post 587, Amrun wrote:Twissted: why did you choose cp to replace?
some welcome I get for replacing into a 24 page game
I have a post coming up which will answer this question among other things. Be patient Anyún
In post 587, Amrun wrote:Twissted: why did you choose cp to replace?
In post 598, Equinox wrote:In post 596, Twistedspoon wrote:if you want a quick answer as to why I demanded that slot, it's because
1) after a brief skim of the first 7 or so pages I felt he was difficult to read and would like to know his alignment myself so that I wouldn't need to work it out
Did you like the answer?
In post 622, ScreamingHawk wrote:
I haven't any completed games on forum before. So no sorry I can't point you to a previous game of mine.
In post 622, ScreamingHawk wrote:
Also Trekker has just been/requested replacement. Your vote on him here seems like a cop out. And so enforces my feelings on above.
In post 622, ScreamingHawk wrote:Makes your lack of pressure on NS suspicious as a scum buddy.
In post 627, SleepyKrew wrote:Holy shit TS what happened to you?
In post 627, SleepyKrew wrote:
Anyway TS, read on NS? It seemed pretty fence to me. Also a tl;dr would be nice.
In post 628, bvoigt wrote:TS, I self-voted as a reaction test, but no one bit.
In post 635, fatlikepig wrote:
Dat WIFOM. To answer your question though, yes, usually obvious scum is obviously scum.
In post 635, fatlikepig wrote:
As for NS calling people "obvscum", that could easily be scum overcompensating for the fact that they haven't given any reads earlier. It's an easy mistake to make, or at least so I think.
In post 642, J wrote:
Uhm, the only name I recognize on the player list is TS but I doubt he remembers me since it has been months since I played on this site.
Anyways, I will try and have some posts up later.
In post 654, ScreamingHawk wrote:I'd really like to know why thoseNOTvoting for NS find whoever they are voting for more scummy. In particular those voting the recently replaced players.
In post 327, ScreamingHawk wrote:Initially thought I had. Sorry. Should start writing all my thoughts for this game down.
Going to have a read through NS past games. Good to join DJ wagon in sec.
In post 705, fatlikepig wrote:l
TS wrote:you lynched before DJ was replaced?
Something is fundamentally wrong here. >_>
This was what I was referring to.
In post 667, bvoigt wrote:
In other news, look at the VC. Nobody Special is our lynch today. Nothing else is happening. Can we get it done?
In post 678, J wrote:
Speaking of NS, I haven't really a big opinion on him. He could be scum but I honestly could see where he could be town. So that makes him null for me.
In post 696, J wrote:
This game needs some J spice to kick it into gear.
Unvote
Vote: Nobody Special
I had a change of heart. I'd rather wake up to a flip than rather wait all day at school, till after 6 to find a flip.
In post 738, pidgey wrote:Also didnt liked TS making cases before theres even a flip.
In post 719, Equinox wrote:
Since you seem to disagree, what do you think of the people who so far used meta to argue for Nobody Special-scum (i.e., Equinox and SleepyKrew)?
In post 720, Amrun wrote:As extremely terrible as that hammer was ... it probably didn't come from scum. *sigh*
In post 722, J wrote:
TS/Equi/FLP, if you had to choose one of Amrun/SH/SK to go next, who and why? If it was between Bvoigt/FB then who?
In post 712, J wrote:Replacement worry? Don't really see an issue because it could give the mod more time to search during the night phase of the game and also it'd just be another person trying to catch up desperately before deadline like myself and pidgy did. It'd be easier for the replacement to have some time to read during the night.
In post 711, J wrote:
For the first part of this quote, why do you keep saying "imminent town-flip"? No one knows the deffo answer till flip so....?
In post 696, J wrote:I'd rather wake up to a flip than rather wait all day at school, till after 6 to find a flip.
In post 726, Equinox wrote:If Nobody Special flips town, I'm probably going after Twistedspoon because the posts where he kept insisting Nobody Special was town based on meta without pressuring the people who used meta to argue for Nobody Special's lynch are scummy in this instance
In post 731, Equinox wrote:
I also wanna say there was something with a person like Hoplip/Ghostlin but my memory is a bit foggy.
In post 731, Equinox wrote:
We'll see when Twistedspoon gets back to me about the meta thing. In the game you played with him, did Twistedspoon have the same buddying kind of attitude? That's the thing that bothers me more than anything else.
In post 733, Fruit Basket wrote:
head 2 is sick and cutting down on games. You get more me for a while. fucking a star,
In post 737, Fruit Basket wrote:i
anyway Equinox TS paranoia looks legit and is a strong town tell based on what I know of her meta (which may range from an extensive knowledge to not very much at all), his whole roleplaying english gentleman thing is p usual for him, very baller indeed.
In post 740, ScreamingHawk wrote:
FYI I'm voting NS because of active lurking and zero contribution. V scummy. Though if he isn't scum, I don't see anything of value being lost (answer to answer question I missed answering either) as it's not like he was providing anything useful for town except another player slot.
In post 749, J wrote:
Absolutely did TS have the same attitude to people. Hoooowever, he has a really harsh whiplash on reads that he even buddies. Mine and Faraday's wounds can attest to this.
In post 753, bvoigt wrote:
I still find Twistedspoon, who replaced C_P, scummy. His catchup post was a massive wall, but it didn't really say much.
In post 760, J wrote:I think you were a bit over-defensive to that statement TS. Left a bad taste in my mouth.
In post 772, Amrun wrote:TS was on my team in team mafia, Equinox... that's KINDASORTA some experience. It's interesting that he didn't cite it and instead cited some mod experience, though...
In post 776, SleepyKrew wrote:TS, is that seriously your defense of Amrun? Please tell me you're joking.
Equinox, what did I not read?
PEDIT:
WHOA WHOA WHOA
SCUMSLIP
In post 792, Quilford wrote:NS had explained that he was town. Pretty sure FLP just made a wording mistake.
In post 817, Equinox wrote:Blargh.
I was going to instavote Fruit Basket today, but I'm still here and I think they would have shot me if they were scum. I need to think about Twistedspoon, too. I'll go over my notes later today.
Twistedspoon, what's your read of SleepyKrew?
In post 865, ScreamingHawk wrote:@^ So everyone is null then? Except TS who is town. And bviogt who is null-scum. That's not a great analysis.
Also does the dead being in green mean they were town? It wasn't explicitly said.
If so the above on [J]AFTER begin NK'd is a little off.appearing town
In post 875, pidgey wrote:
Whoever thinks fat is town because he had a "slip" is dumb. He could be scum and could thought that. Or fake it. Or whatever. I myself thought we had to get all the scum since like 4 real life days ago, when I actually reread the opening post.
In post 879, Fruit Basket wrote:I can't find that post now. Am I confusing fat with someone else?
In post 908, ScreamingHawk wrote:In post 895, bvoigt wrote:
In post 871, Twistedspoon wrote:tbh, I think his reads list is quite genuine. I find it more townie at this stage to call a large number of players null as scum would try to make their reads as unoticable and generic as possible to blend in and stay safe. Jer's reads are neither generic or unoticable and I find that rather town in a small sense. I agree that a list of null reads is unhelpful and disappointing as well though.
My logic against the NS lynch was that scum wouldn't want to stick out as much and be as bold as he was. I think the same may be true here.
Doesn't a large number of null reads satisfy the notions of "unnoticable and generic"? A strong scum read or town read just makes it more likely that people will disagree and possibly argue with you.
I'm also reposting this because I agree whole heartedly and would like to see comment from TS.
In post 882, fatlikepig wrote:Post #3 in my ISO.
In post 914, Equinox wrote:so uh
Good news is that I'm caught up. Bad news is that I'm confused as all hell, and this game gives me a headache.
[/b]
In post 935, fatlikepig wrote:Pidgey's continual denial of the validity of scum tells isn't sitting too well with me at the moment. Seems like the type of thing scum would do, keep their options, etc.
In post 933, Equinox wrote:Vote: pidgey
pidgey claims that clearing people based on "slips" is foolhardy because it can be faked or scum can misunderstand the setup, too; in the same breath, he gives an example of how he misunderstood the setup. This does not compute.
In post 939, Equinox wrote:In post 938, Twistedspoon wrote:If I find you on two myslynch wagons equinox then I'm seriously going to consider you D3
*stares at Twistedspoon*
In post 946, Fruit Basket wrote:In post 944, Twistedspoon wrote:In post 939, Equinox wrote:In post 938, Twistedspoon wrote:If I find you on two myslynch wagons equinox then I'm seriously going to consider you D3
*stares at Twistedspoon*
so you'd find a player who had a hand in lynching 2 townies not suspicious at all?
can you explain your usage of the smiley here? thanks. (not interested in the rest, want to know why you chose to use this particular smiley)
In post 947, Fruit Basket wrote:In post 912, Amrun wrote:TS giving me townvibes... Having a hard time moving on from my intense c_p scumread, though.
^ bullshit and fake
In post 953, Equinox wrote:In post 944, Twistedspoon wrote:In post 939, Equinox wrote:In post 938, Twistedspoon wrote:If I find you on two myslynch wagons equinox then I'm seriously going to consider you D3
*stares at Twistedspoon*
so you'd find a player who had a hand in lynching 2 townies not suspicious at all?
No, I'd want to find out what part they had in those two mislynches. Let me ask you something, Twistedspoon. Now that you've basically threatened me to be right or die, let's suppose we mislynch today, and I'm not on the wagon. I've deftly avoided the lynching wagon to join some other one. What would you think of me then?
In post 961, Equinox wrote:In post 958, Twistedspoon wrote:It's more a matter of if you lynch town again then I'll review you again and not see you as town as I think you now.
Not sure I understand your question. If you don't lynch town again, I'm happy for now.
Okay, that's fair. Let me rephrase my question. Suppose we have a mislynch today, but I did not participate in the lynch. What would you think then?
In post 976, Amrun wrote:In post 971, SleepyKrew wrote:PEDIT: ILL DO IT TO AND OH LOOK AMRUN IS IGNORINGMY LATEST POINTS AGAINST HERSHES SCUM
Herpderp?
But all your other points suck just as much.
SKrew, I think you are town.
Just wrong.
In post 979, Amrun wrote:Gut and meta for the most part. I think he'd be a lot more likely to buddy me as scum than oppose me.
In post 989, ScreamingHawk wrote:In post 819, Amrun wrote:Torn between voting fruit and twistedspoon.
VOTE: fruit basket
It's interesting that TS expresses a townread and fruit tries to undermine it. Especially early game, that's a scumtell.
You voted FB after only making a (weak) comment about TS being scum. Why not vote TS then? What's your case on FB.
In post 993, Amrun wrote:In post 992, ScreamingHawk wrote:Just fyi Amrun. The best case I can see from you for C_P being scum is your very first post. Because of the quick lynch thing. Was that it? You make a couple more vague references to his appearing newbscum but that's all I can see. Please quote / explain otherwise because I've asked you this so many times before and your response to look but through your iso does not help me here.
There are SO MANY other reasons, many of which I noted. He was very inconsistent; at first, he was cautious, but then pushed to end the day with just as little cause. One indicates one type of newbie, the other a totally different type. You can't both be the cautious and incautious type of newbie. It's incongruous.