Battle Mage and go back a long time! Also he's town.In post 44, Gypyx wrote:Why me and DGB exactly? DGB didn't even postIn post 35, Battle Mage wrote:yo gypyx, DGB, get on board!
But yeah, choo chooVOTE: pob
VOTE: pob long
Battle Mage and go back a long time! Also he's town.In post 44, Gypyx wrote:Why me and DGB exactly? DGB didn't even postIn post 35, Battle Mage wrote:yo gypyx, DGB, get on board!
But yeah, choo chooVOTE: pob
This is spot on. Fidget is town.In post 229, Fidget wrote:I feel like half the game is speaking a foreign language that I do not understand.Confused.In post 177, Titus wrote:Fidget, what's your Leia read?
I think there's the potential for her being town but I don't really agree with anything I'm hearing from her. It's sometimes hard for me distinguish where she is joking and where she isn't. Like, if she gives 1 real reason to suspect tayl0r among 4 joke ones, it's like :/
Tempted to vote because she really is just making up stuff on tayl0r at this point which I could potentially see as a "Don't vote me, vote them!" dishonest kind of reaction from scum.In post 206, Princess Leia wrote:Also, her running away when I proposed my real-time question test is scum-indicative. Town are more likely to see it as opportunity to show their worth, while scum will think of it as a "ugh, I can't be bothered with this" and disappear instead.
I am puzzled.In post 294, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i for one need further explanation, although i can kinda see how shelly and leia could be scum maybe?
It's called casting a wide net of possible votes.In post 306, Fidget wrote:I also somewhat thought shelly looked town for outing so many scumreads.
SO MUCK AWKWARDIn post 38, shellyc wrote:yesterday someone told me that the c stood for Cult Leader...In post 31, Princess Leia wrote:Did you make this account just for this game? Does the c stand for Consigliere? That's just the type of bold move I'd expect scum to make.
time to make an alt I guess
PL very aggressive towards shellyc here, it looks likeIn post 94, shellyc wrote:To prove that I have played games on this account, and therefore have not created this specifically for this gameIn post 88, Princess Leia wrote:Why are you pointing me to your signature? Is there a town or scum game you want me to examine there to compare to this game?
Very true but does that make Titus scum?In post 326, Tayl0r Swift wrote:yeah, iunno titus. i dont see fidget as scum here. and i think you're reaching. i dont know that you get to scumread people for sheeping you. especially since the reaction test was so obvious that it seemed like it wasnt a reaction test - it almost seemed like you wanted it to be obvious or something. im far more inclined to agree with vecna's take here. VOTE: titus
Bolded part does seem like complete BS.In post 315, Titus wrote:By the way, Fidget is lockscum. Taylor is town.
There was no "scumslip" at all.I was testing the fluidity of the wagons entirely.Fidget was sheeping scum based on wagon momentum before but this seals it.
I have no read on shelley but I know Fidget is scared.
Vecna is well Vecna.
VOTE: Fidget
I know I said you're town earlier, but this stinks of bus'ing.In post 323, Fidget wrote:I've never played with Titus where she was scum, I don't think. You do make a good point that she's following the pattern I guess.In post 320, Tayl0r Swift wrote:so does that mean you think titus is town because as town titus always falsely suspects you?In post 317, Fidget wrote:Why does your VCA always implicate me? It's astounding to me that you've suspected me in every game we've ever played together, except for the one I was scum in.In post 315, Titus wrote:By the way, Fidget is lockscum. Taylor is town.
There was no "scumslip" at all. I was testing the fluidity of the wagons entirely. Fidget was sheeping scum based on wagon momentum before but this seals it.
I have no read on shelley but I know Fidget is scared.
Vecna is well Vecna.
VOTE: Fidget
It mostly means I'm getting irritated for no reason though.
An actual good point being made.In post 334, Marashu wrote:That said, when I saw it, it was meant to gauge the towniness/scuminess of the person being targeted, so it strikes me as weird to do this to someone who is V/LA, or at least not waiting that it was fabricated until the person got back to see if she got nervous.
Something is VERY OFFIn post 405, Tayl0r Swift wrote:so titus and fidget were just distancing? this reconciliation reads really strange to me. but maybe thats just because its past bedtime.
aka "caught for the wrong reasons?"In post 426, Gypyx wrote:Basically, paranoia generated by a scum mindset like, an "oh shit he's onto me" moment you see?In post 424, Marashu wrote:What does that mean? Wouldn't scum paranoia be fake paranoia? So, does it feel like paranoia or does it feel fake?In post 414, Gypyx wrote:Hmmmm i think figet's reaction to titus's reaction test feels like paranoia, i'd say scum!paranoia but not sure about this one
In post 431, Titus wrote:No. I don't argue what I did as VCA. As scum, I don't argue VCA early. I keep hidden the magical time where it becomes effective then more and more effective.
My townplay does involve more natural progression and is less cohesive than my scum play. My scum play has less holes but still frquently advises town of the best answer (unless forced into otherwise).
My personality is changing since my divorce though, which naturally carries over to how I play mafia. So meta circa 2017 should not be used to read me.
"Girls you're both pretty" or "it's town vs. town" is more likely to come from scum than from town.In post 371, shellyc wrote:Townleaning fidget and Titus. Titus reaction test is pretty indica to ice of a solving mindset and fidgets posting gives me a good vibe (this is more gut)
He's a weak player???In post 454, Titus wrote:So a weak player with a right read gets wagoned based on faulty reasoning from a town slot.In post 452, DrippingGoofball wrote:Pickaxe Pete's iso is pretty bizarre with the shellyc obsession... but at the same time his points against shellyc are on point.
This has been my point.
In post 454, Titus wrote:So a weak player with a right read gets wagoned based on faulty reasoning from a town slot.
If Pickaxe Pete is right about Shellyc, why aren't you voting shellyc? I was assuming that you were.In post 461, Titus wrote:Fidget. I'll probably move when I see the VC unless all major options are horrible.In post 459, DrippingGoofball wrote:In post 454, Titus wrote:So a weak player with a right read gets wagoned based on faulty reasoning from a town slot.
Related,
who are you voting for, right now?
It's a big boisterous show of appearing solvy but in reality solves nothing. But it's just enough for a scum to poke their head out with a classic "above the fray" stance of calling them both town.In post 463, Tayl0r Swift wrote: i dont see what about titus' reaction test seems solvy
Titus, who do you feel about having a pet in the game? Is this grovelling from scum or town?In post 467, Fidget wrote:Do you want me to make an unofficial VC for you Titus
I could get on board with that.In post 522, Battle Mage wrote:Princess Leia's ISO also looks worse than it felt in real time. Deliberately obtuse/disingenuous style decidedly anti-town. I hope we can eliminate that slot today, so I dont have to actually go through it again and explain why it is so scummy.
Stalling scum right here, ladies and germs.In post 551, shellyc wrote:I WON'T FALL FOR IT LMFAOIn post 536, Battle Mage wrote:shelly, that's -1, if you have a town PR, time to claim!
I have a curse that I get to E-1 in all d1's I've completed
It's just another perfect example of meta trash.In post 686, Titus wrote:Eddie, since when is DGB a troll slot?
Like you, I was hell bent sure Shelly was lockscum so maybe there was confirmation bias.In post 684, Pickaxe Pete wrote:This post bothered me at the time because 1) I wasn't feeling Titus's VCA and 2) it seemed a little too complimentary from DGB.
TvT comments are often made by scum. Yes I believe that. Join date: 2005. I have seen it many, many times.In post 692, Pickaxe Pete wrote:This post didn't make sense either. TvT is more likely to come from scum? She can't believe that.
You don't trust me to do it?In post 707, Titus wrote:If I die, force Taylor to do it.
"The posts I read on this game day are very townie"In post 732, Vecna wrote:acting very towny today? WUT?
I'm town, just to make things easier for you.In post 743, Tayl0r Swift wrote:is anyone else seeing scum everywhere? i prefer to townhunt and its really difficult here.
so far town are vecna, pickaxe?, dgb?, and fidget??
Scum would say that. But you're not being gladiated, so there's that.In post 745, Gypyx wrote:Ok wtf, is everyone in this gladiate scum or what
In post 740, Vecna wrote:At that moment it was based on the gimmicky reaction test. I dont really have any strong paranoia for titus, but thats probably also because I think ive only encountered her as scum when she replaces in (and she's usually pretty obvious in those cases, but id imagine she puts in more effort if she rolls scum in a fresh game).In post 736, Pickaxe Pete wrote:Vecna, earlier you said we were looking at scum!Titus. Was that past-game paranoia or was that legit from this game?
I keep going back and forth on Titus. She's def not lock-town yet as ive seen her be on a bunch of occasions. Her voting record and thought process is incomprehensible to me, but thats par for the course
Judging by your performance in our last game together, that probably means that Titus is town and Nos is scum.In post 741, Vecna wrote:I think Nos is probably town. I can almost taste his happy stoner face flapping about as he ridicules' people their reasoning.
The iso is kinda skimpy but the tone reads honest to me - more honest than Nosferatu. Have you compared them? Maybe I'm wrong. Let's analyze.In post 749, Gypyx wrote:So you just decide to ignore his incredibly scummy Day 1?
You pay attention to the actual meaning of Vecna's content?In post 779, Titus wrote:Why is Vecna town to you when he outright accused you of doing nothing?
It's a tragedy that this guy didn't make the gladiate list.In post 835, pob long wrote:Plusjoy makes it hard to chose the right answer here...
That's what I call a scumcase.In post 836, Gypyx wrote:Dunno about you but i find it hard to scumcaseIn post 808, Nosferatu wrote:isn't it crazy that 3 ppl on my wagon have been scumreading me since d1 but can't provide even an iota of a casean iso empty of readable content
You're not supposed to vote for the player you like the most
Openwolfing?In post 852, Fidget wrote:borderline openwolfing
You sound defeated.In post 844, PlusJOYED wrote:no im just lurkingIn post 842, Titus wrote:Plusjoyed hasn't posted in more than 3 days. That should say something.
i've decided on noseferatu but since we're all sus as hell im not gonna tryhard to manipulate the peoples choice
I just iso'd Gypyx, and your accusation is gratuitous and perhaps vindictive.In post 838, Nosferatu wrote:just keep doing what u do best, the absolute bare minimum while acting like uve got a prolific body of content urself
at the very least ive never actively lurked and proceeded to throw potshots at slots with half my post count
I was just looking forIn post 722, Nosferatu wrote:plusjoy has an outrageous iso that im insulted to believe comes from scum, and i honestly don't have that much of a scum read on dgb but i townread her less
PlusJOYED is voting scum, I think that's a solid point in his favor.In post 857, Marashu wrote:I'm not a fan of the nos wagon. Come join us on Plus.In post 855, Tayl0r Swift wrote:im willing to compromise on plus here if no one wants nos.
You do make valid points.In post 868, Fidget wrote:<3!He acknowledged that he was going to be scumread for hammering shelly, and has said he doesn't mind if we send him to trial.
He doesn't care at all if he's perceived as scummy and also made no attempt to solve with his vote yesterday.
Why would he say we would scumread him for voting shelly? Clearly he didn't think shelly was scummy then. So why'd he hammer her? Don't know. I guess he felt like it, and he later justifies it as "Well, I don't care how scummy I look cause going to trial sounds cool. But then I realized that's throwing so maybe I shouldn't do that"
So he doesn't realize he's throwing until after the hammer. >.>
You've got both "too scummy to be scum" and "too townie to be town" in there.In post 873, Fidget wrote:It's frustrating to me because I am not really confident in any of you being scum. It could be Nos sure. I don't see a good reason why but there isn't a lot for "why not?" either.
Plus gives us all that stuff which I just don't WANT to believe is scum. He could be town thinking that. Or he could be scum hiding behind "Ha I'm scummy on purpose".
And then there's you, which you haven't done anything seriously scummy either but out of the three you at least give off a sense of trying to help more than they do. Which ironically made me suspect you more. But I sort of buy that you were confirm biased by Titus' VCA. So.
In the first quote I agree with you saying that Nos' iso by itself is a scum case, maybe that's what you misinterpreted?In post 888, Gypyx wrote:In post 861, DrippingGoofball wrote:That's what I call a scumcase.In post 836, Gypyx wrote:Dunno about you but i find it hard to scumcaseIn post 808, Nosferatu wrote:isn't it crazy that 3 ppl on my wagon have been scumreading me since d1 but can't provide even an iota of a casean iso empty of readable contentIn post 865, DrippingGoofball wrote:I just iso'd Gypyx, and your accusation is gratuitous and perhaps vindictive.In post 838, Nosferatu wrote:just keep doing what u do best, the absolute bare minimum while acting like uve got a prolific body of content urself
at the very least ive never actively lurked and proceeded to throw potshots at slots with half my post count
Gypyx is an active participant, provides actual content, and is town.
It's bizarre that this is the player you are choosing to pick on.
Damn dgb, am I scum or town?
Yeah, I make these naked declarations a lot, like it's my personal notepad - not to convince others. When I feel it's a good time in the game to do so, I put everything together. Players are free to ask about my reasoning - there is always a reason.In post 927, Noraa wrote:No explanation again. I can see that as scum uninterested in solving but maybe its just playstyle since its quite consistent according to the ISO
I don't know if you realize or not - but the three of us are the only allowable wagons today, we are being gladiated. We do not know how we were chosen for this.In post 943, Noraa wrote:@the three biggest wagons today
The game is stalling bad, that is a cowardly move. We're going nowhere in circles excruciatingly slowly.In post 968, Tayl0r Swift wrote:id normally be compromising to plus at this point, but since we only need a plurality vote i get to be stubborn.
You're not even voting, come on. That's just ridiculously non-committal.In post 979, Fidget wrote:Hmph, maybe.In post 976, Vecna wrote:You mean scum whiteknighting, right?
Either way I can't choose DGB so if Plus is indeed town I'd have to vote for Nos for some chance of hitting scum
I'd quite like to just eliminate Plus but I'm not feeling terribly optimistic he flips scumNot that I can think of. Just caught in a dilemma. Plus probably doesn't have the highest chance of flipping scum, if I had to guess one player in the gladiate to win the game, I'd probably pick one of the other two.Vecna wrote:VOTE: PlusJoyed
I dno. You seem to be insinuating something without actually saying it fidget.
But eliminating one of the other two and seeing them flip town would just be annoying, cause then Plus is still in the game, and he will be eliminated another day almost for sure. And there'd still be no guarantee he's scum.