Not Quite Normal Multiball II (Game Over)

[MalcolmTucker]

As for Malcolm

Going from no votes to eliminated with 11 votes in 8 hours
Without getting a chance to post
Without a claim
And without most of the wagon

explaining why they are voting for Malcolm

Regardless of what Malcolm flips here, this wagon was obviously sketchy

I'm town but don't blame people for wagoning me, my contributions have been useless and I'd probably make a decent compromise.

All I'll say is you should get some very, very interesting stuff from my elimination should it come to pass.

[Nashville Dreams]

In fact, let's go through every reason person on the wagon had in their ISO re: MalcolmTucker. To see if my theory holds.

~Titus

[MalcolmTucker]

If I'm not to be eliminated immediately, give me a bit of time and I'll try to assess the wagon on me.

[Nashville Dreams]

As for Malcolm

Going from no votes to eliminated with 11 votes in 8 hours
Without getting a chance to post
Without a claim
And without most of the wagon

explaining why they are voting for Malcolm

Regardless of what Malcolm flips here, this wagon was obviously sketchy

I'm town but don't blame people for wagoning me, my contributions have been useless and I'd probably make a decent compromise.

All I'll say is you should get some very, very interesting stuff from my elimination should it come to pass.

You've been hammered. Can you at least give final reads, even if reasonless?

[Nashville Dreams]

Reasons ppl were voting MalcolmTucker

Nero - I don't think I need citations here.
mastina- 7137
StD- 7020
Klick- 7389 but arguably could be worrying given other spots in his ISO
Nashville- 6524
Monkey- Fair for reasonless using Control F.
SCP- 6066
Ydrasse-Clearly passive voter sheeping viable wagons
Tictac-1769 arguably weak here given the sparseness of the iso, but has agreement Malcolm elim and conflict with in a few places
Sword- 660 Very early SR, hardly no mentions later
Enchant- Known hammerer

[Dunnstral]

Mastina does not give a reason there
Your own reason is very shaky and I barely believe you were actually thinking about that. Looks like retroactive justification to me.

Quoting 1769 and 660 is basically meaningless

[Dunnstral]

OK mastina said compromising

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: NeroCain

Bit of a gut read but why not.

Lmao.

Technically a vote, but on a vanity wagon that has no shot and Malcom gives no reason.

~Titus

You are claiming that you voted Malcolm due to this?

[Nashville Dreams]

VOTE: NeroCain

Bit of a gut read but why not.

Lmao.

Technically a vote, but on a vanity wagon that has no shot and Malcom gives no reason.

~Titus

You are claiming that you voted Malcolm due to this?

Partially, yes. I don't like slots that don't vote major wagons. I just went through to grab the latest comments that people said rather than through entire ISOs.

[Nashville Dreams]

@Monkey, Can you explain the reads on Well Done, MalcolmTucker and SwordsofDucks?

Well Done - active an engaged, agree with their posts for the most part.

MalcomTrucker - Not really active, but their posts seem like they are trying to sort a little.

SwordofDucks - low content posting.

What do you specifically agree with Well Done on?
Where is Malcolm trying to sort?
If SoD's "low content posting" was a problem, why didn't you support my push prior to being FoSed?

Mala and I need to talk on Mastina. (Hmu discord.) I don't believe mastina's claim

but I believe she's town

. No, I will not say how that works.

I can see the reasoning behind a Meg wagon and would support it.

@Malcom, my issue isn't where your vote was, but the fact you didn't even FoS Sword until you were run up. You left me pushing alone without acknowledging me or my push.

I'll look at the rest momentarily.

CSF reads as town to me, and I'm generally agreeing with pretty much everything Butterchurn is posting.

Saving this for the future to see why MT feels CSF is town.

I feel differenty.

butterchurn - Moderate scum
Nashville Dreams (Titus & Malakittens) - Moony Town
Cat Scratch Fever - Was lean town but fell down, likely not fault of their own. Memory issue here
Save The Dragons - Strong Town Lean
Toogeloo momo - Strong Town Lean
Sword of Ducks - I personally feel scum. Gamestate town.
cassowary - Who?
Nero Cain Wallflower - Prob town
SCP 682 Tracer Bullet - Second biggest TR
The Keeper - Frustrating as hell
Dunnstral Well Done (Dunnstral & Lukewarm) - Punting but I don't like their repeating of things I already answered but this again could be gamestate.
MegAzumarill - Almost certainly scum.
catboi - Needs to flip soon.
MalcolmTucker - Viggable.
bnuuy - Goal to sort tmo.
tictac - Likely scum with butter and possibly catboi.
MonkeyMan576 - When I start to feel town here, they say something icky.
Klick - Need to see more than punish FL.
Enchant - Should be vigged.
mastina - Can't explain without being antitown. Lean town.
Flavor Leaf - Biggest TR
Menalque - Lean town, minor VCA problem.
Ydrasse NorwegianboyEE - Didn't like EE push on me but Ydrasse towned up the slot. Plus wagon reactions suggest Ydrasse town.

Also - Monkey raised this possibility briefly but is there a chance SCP/Flavor can be a team together here?

No. This just plummeted you in my reads. FL and SCP do not fight for control of the thread to that extent if teamed.

Also, I still feel Meg should be the elimination, but I'm not about to turn this into yesterday again. I don't have a TR on CSF.

VOTE: CSF

From when I read CSF's ISO the other day I agree with Mastina that they seem townie. Not been fully up to scratch on the game but I keep seeing suggestions to vote CSF without a proper case.

this seems like a copout :upsidedown:

Malcolm's voting no one.

[Nashville Dreams]

Mastina does not give a reason there
Your own reason is very shaky and I barely believe you were actually thinking about that. Looks like retroactive justification to me.

Quoting 1769 and 660 is basically meaningless

Here it looks like you're seeking to deny people had reasons for voting Malcolm. It's not a reasonless wagon. There was only one person I saw that went from a TR to voting.

[Nashville Dreams]

butterchurn

Nashville Dreams (Titus & Malakittens)

Cat Scratch Fever

Save The Dragons
Sword of Ducks

cassowary

Nero Cain

SCP 682

The Keeper

Dunnstral

MegAzumarill

MalcolmTucker

bnuuy
tictac

MonkeyMan576
Klick

Enchant
mastina

Flavor Leaf

Menalque

Ydrasse

Best solve I can estimate at the moment.
Tictac and mastina wouldn't be aligned with FL, leaving Nero/Keeper/bnuuy/Enchant as possible Mafia.

VOTE: MalcolmTucker

This is the closest I come to a problem and he's not a good elimination.

[Nashville Dreams]

*they're not a good elimination.

[Nashville Dreams]

This is part of the reason I suspect you Dunn. You act as if you totally forgot how I play and selectively read posts. Anyone who knows me knows that I am down to vote or vig anyone who refuses to vote a major wagon. I'm too lazy to find even where I explained that in my ISO. Your slot ignored me responding to a question about how I analyzed wagons and you should have known that answer from years of playing with me.

Here, it feels like you're trying to create a narrative rather than look at people's history. Naked votes hardly equal reasonless ones unless in RVS and sometimes not even then.

[Nashville Dreams]

If I'm not to be eliminated immediately, give me a bit of time and I'll try to assess the wagon on me.

I find it odd MalcolmTucker places a contigency on him giving reads that he's not eliminated. He bails after I tell him he's hammered. No claim no nothing.

[MalcolmTucker]

If I'm not to be eliminated immediately, give me a bit of time and I'll try to assess the wagon on me.

I find it odd MalcolmTucker places a contigency on him giving reads that he's not eliminated. He bails after I tell him he's hammered. No claim no nothing.

Oops, I didn't see I'd been hammered, apologies. Guessing I really shouldn't be commenting now given I'm technically out. Here's hoping I played this well.

[MegAzumarill]

You are allowed to talk during twilight

[Enchant]

If I'm not to be eliminated immediately, give me a bit of time and I'll try to assess the wagon on me.

I find it odd MalcolmTucker places a contigency on him giving reads that he's not eliminated. He bails after I tell him he's hammered. No claim no nothing.

Oops, I didn't see I'd been hammered, apologies. Guessing I really shouldn't be commenting now given I'm technically out. Here's hoping I played this well.

Hi was you scum?

[bnuuy]

Is their post 7181 not different from what is said in 7186 and 7188?

I asked a different question
I didn't ask anything about parity cop
so idk about nashville but it makes sense I got a different answer than enchant did

[MonkeyMan576]

This isn't Malcolm's first rodeo he should know he's allowed to talk during twilight. He's probably just scum.

[MonkeyMan576]

In fact in this point he seems to knowingly post during twilight in a previous game:
viewtopic.php?p=13330096#p13330096

He may have forgotten but I doubt it.

[MonkeyMan576]

post not point sorry.

[Nashville Dreams]

Is their post 7181 not different from what is said in 7186 and 7188?

I asked a different question
I didn't ask anything about parity cop
so idk about nashville but it makes sense I got a different answer than enchant did

The answers aren't differeny. Bnuuy's is just more detailed.

Everyone says Vanilla cop can get Vanilla on Werewolf Goon or whatever it is.

The difference is Cephrir told Bnuuy that a Vanilla Seer could exist.

[Cephrir]

votecount 2.F

MalcolmTucker (11) | Nero Cain, mastina, Save The Dragons, Klick, Nashville Dreams, MonkeyMan576, SCP 682, Ydrasse, tictac, Sword of Ducks, Enchant

Nashville Dreams (3) | butterchurn, MegAzumarill, Cat Scratch Fever
Dunnstral (3) | cassowary, bnuuy, Flavor Leaf

Cat Scratch Fever (1) | Menalque
Ydrasse (1) | The Keeper
cassowary (1) | MalcolmTucker
bnuuy (1) | Dunnstral

Not Voting |

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to politely ask someone to leave.

Deadline: (expired on 2022-05-20 20:06:00).

[Cephrir]

MalcolmTucker was politely asked to leave Day 2. He was a...

Spoiler:

Town Hirsute Saint

Hirsute players appear to be a Werewolf to any Seer investigations.

A Saint eliminates the person who casts the hammer vote against them with holy power. If the target is Mafia, they have time to realize what is happening, pull out their gun and make one last elimination before they must flee. Werewolves and Town players are eliminated immediately.

Spoiler:

Enchant has been exorcised! He was a...

Mafia Goon

.

It is now Twilight 2. Enchant has 24 hours to select a player to take down with him. Because Enchant is considered dead, he cannot discuss this with his team.

I will need to receive an indication from cassowary and Menalque that they are still playing before Night can end, as they have not yet picked up their prods.