In post 907, BlackStar wrote:If everyone is aging "I think FA is town" it wouldn't be hard for anyone to say that they investigated you and you're probably town. It doesn't really prove anything. If he is consistently right about people's roles then he'll be the confirmed cop.
I very much see the point here. Why would an investigator choose to pick FA for their 1st night action anyway? She was being read as town by the majority, and EVEN IF they suspected her themselves it would've been very hard to push a lynch on her if they got a positive result w/o lynching them first. I -for one- would've refused to believe him if he said she was scum.
Let me try to think of the possibilities of each one's alignment for some time, and maybe I will be able to find something.
The thing is during D1 I had more suspects than the maximum possible number of scum.
During the night (that's after the Wednesday flip & before the night action results), I had just about narrowed it down considerably.
Upon the night action flips though, and coupled with the role claims I have less lynch targets than the "assumed" number of scum left in game.
My lynch candidates WERE: Persivul, Jackalk & RC (in that order). Persivul is still arguing well enough (not cornered), Jackal RC'd and is leaning town, and RC is very townish according to FA.
This leaves me confused and undecided, so I DO need more time to think it over.