Mini Normal 1923: BooneyToonz IV - Five Weeks in a Boon END

[Gamma Emerald]

Hi
Was I wrong about you in Creature's game? I remember some alignments but not all.

[Gamma Emerald]

Serge giving me scumtingles rn lol

It'll go away some time soon, no worries

VOTE: Mulch for thinking i could be scum

This seems forced :/

Liking this for now

[Gamma Emerald]

Realized that you guys might use green when doing reads. Sorry for the inconvenience. I'll switch to this xd

I use blue when I do reads as well, can you switch to something other then green (town), red (mafia), or blue (undecided)?

I use yellow for undecided

[Gamma Emerald]

This thread is going to be filled with garbage in no time. That's for sure.

This reads towny
Doesn't look like fake frustration

[Gamma Emerald]

Early townread: Serge
Early scumreads: Tchill, Klazam

Following with
Early townreads, Mulch and TChill

[Gamma Emerald]

Hi
Was I wrong about you in Creature's game? I remember some alignments but not all.

I was wrong about you too. Leys never fight again

I mean it'll happen someday
But I'll try to be more open opinion wise about you

[Gamma Emerald]

I refuse to have less posts than you this game Serge

<3

Am I sensing a challenge?

I'm kinda hoping this is a thing

[Gamma Emerald]

Scared his reads list only contains the people who have posted. It's a not so obvious joke apparently.

That's like so not an issue
But this concern doesn't seem fake
TChill is really Town here

[Gamma Emerald]

Taco. Mulch. Shut up and let people post. Noise = bad

Feels a bit forced. Not really scumread-worthy but noting it's not like TChill's

[Gamma Emerald]

*goes silent*

No random bullshit to fire back at me?

Ewww
This feels really fake

[Gamma Emerald]

Gamma are you town :thonk:

Yeah
But I'd rather get working on sorting other people

[Gamma Emerald]

any reason?

yes

Shit it's a troll player

[Gamma Emerald]

Not sure on that yet but okay

[Gamma Emerald]

MULCH IS HERE

Idk if serge is this good at scumplay tbh loool


@Serge can you link me a scum game

Honestly, I wanted to be sarcastic and link this game but is that even allowed? xD

Might be Town idk

[Gamma Emerald]

Hey everyone! Just want to say I'm genuinely excited to play with you all and have enjoyed the read so far.

Keychain, talk me through your decision to post about the number of pages so far. Are you hoping that by making that comment people will slow down their posting? Had you read the game yet?

Fykus, what is terrible about voting for you at this stage of the game? Is it likely to result in a lynch?

Klazam, is there a reason why you seem uninterested in other people's reads on Mulch/Taco from the first 7 pages of this game?

Its a terrible vote because its based on the fact we just finished a game together where i was scum so now he auto assumes i must be scum again.

So it's shitty meta

[Gamma Emerald]

Hi DeasVail. Are you liking the tone of Mulch and Sergtacos so far?

I lean town on them, but I don't find anything from the first 7 pages hugely alignment-indicative. It would take some effort to change my mind on them but not a ridiculous amount.

Also your post about me is very reasonable and there is no offence taken.

I'm uninterested in taco and mulch because of previous game we were in, they spam a lot. I'm leaning town based on irl meta for taco, and mulch seems a lot like the previous game, so there.

Taco, you don't know how M and I roll.

My main issue is that you encourage Maestro not to read the first 7 pages as he didn't miss anything, however it doesn't sound like your reads are strong. Why would you miss out on the opportunity to have someone you are familiar with read the first two pages and offer their opinion on mulch and taco's alignment?

---

Fykus, is he auto-assuming you must be scum? I didn't get that impression.

This analysis is like hella good

[Gamma Emerald]

actually nvm that, i know enough to know youre town.

who do you wanna pursue?

If I were a simpler man I'd call this a scumslip, but I can tell it's just poor wording

[Gamma Emerald]

Eh , I'll just do it now.

To me, Klazam is giving off the impression of his posting being for show rather than actually sincere. There's a lot of talking about how he needs to get a read on Maestro and then the following 'woe is me' period where we stuffed it up guys! We stuffed up his grand plan to get a read on Maestro even though he wasn't trying very hard. I mean, he told Maestro to ignore a large portion of the game because he's somehow the authority on what is worthwhile reading and what's not? And wasn't interested in what Maestro thought of those pages?

But now we have a magical town read on Maestro so it's okay.

And now there's a lot of engaging with Maestro trying to get him to lead things without providing much in the way of contribution himself. Which would make sense if he was trying to get a read on Maestro but Maestro is apparently definitely town so he's not.

My scumread is fairly week all in all and the above is much more a collection of rambly thoughts than a case.

DV this actually looks fairly good! Might need a bit more clarity on the future. The "so it's okay" creates a mixed message I feel.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think pausing 1/4 through is alright for now

[Gamma Emerald]

Hey Vedith
Sorry about Large 203

[Gamma Emerald]

2 problems with that: I like my reads, and you don't have credibility yet. Both of those have to change for that to possibly happen.

[Gamma Emerald]

Wow wasn't trying to be belligerent there.

[Gamma Emerald]

Great argument, I now have you as town.

VOTE: Mulch

Your emotions seem real but your pushing me for bullshit reasons and the keychain slot was scummy as fuck.

Not sure what to think about you.

Great argument, I now have you as town.

VOTE: Mulch

This feels fake btw

Explain this, you are calling his emotions real and fake at the same time.

[Gamma Emerald]

Well, in that case we just have to find those who possess radioactive names.

I've heard Tchill13 is a new nuclear compound that is getting developed by mad scientists.

So i say we prevent everyone from getting cancer and lynch him right away.

VOTE: Tchill13

Game's out of rvs, so scumhunt.

Could be scum

[Gamma Emerald]

That refers to Creative
But eh Klazam too

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Crystal

Why did you adopt his typo?

[Gamma Emerald]

like what I want right now is to listen to the people who haven't posted any thoughtful content, any thoughts of their own

also im fairly positive klaz is lynchbait and town at this point; like even if klaz wasn't town he's not the lynch for today

I wanna hear about this. It seems way too early to say this and it seems like you're covering Klazam.

[Gamma Emerald]

like im pretty sure Creative is trying to stir some kind of aggressive emotion-fueled paragraph from me which is fine

but if these are actually ur reads then you need to like re-evaluate your entire principles of getting reads

also I like saying like a lot

(hue)

Oh god it's a valley girl

[Gamma Emerald]

Emotions seem real but it seems fake?

[Gamma Emerald]

So you're saying the past emotion looks real?

[Gamma Emerald]

Sergtacos is probably right with his shitposting being NAI
But the way he keeps saying how town he is is weird. Is that usually part of how he does things?
VOTE: Sergtacos

Bad vote. VOTE: Keychain

Your pinging me huge

BAD VOTE KEYCHAIN BAD VOTE!

VOTE: Sergtacos

Mulch, you keep voting keychain while I vote Rivia. Let's lynch them both at the same time.

VOTE: Rivia

Holy shit the OMGUS is strong with this one

[Gamma Emerald]

actually nvm that, i know enough to know youre town.

who do you wanna pursue?

Then this?

I forgot my vote is RVS at the moment.

VOTE: Klazam

not anymore.

You're a headache and a half but you're Town

[Gamma Emerald]

What makes you say that?
Also I guess I might go back and reread his posts. I try to avoid reading on meta though, only using it as a "this doesn't work for X" thing. I believe you saw that with me stating Titus doesn't read when replacing as both alignments during Large 203.

[Gamma Emerald]

UNVOTE: Mulch

VOTE: Klazam

Votes Klazam, then I can't make out of his other posts, shitty reasons/explanations or none at all? Idk, but looks to me, shitty explanation. Then votes me, no explanation. I looked at his ISO, all of em simple. TOO simple.

Logic seems alright here but I wanna see more. What do you think of Stay away right now Sergtoacs?

[Gamma Emerald]

Anyone you think has a lesser chance of being scum?

[Gamma Emerald]

SAIHAG is one of my top town

I don't understand how.

They dont give a fuck what people think about them

Don't give a fuck? The guy was insulting and bitching about his wagon. He seemed to me was under pressure, I honestly think you two are scum.

Its tiehr Fygus and Veditih or you and SAIHAB.

Why Fykus and Bedith?

[Gamma Emerald]

There's not enough information to go by with Klazam. I still need more.

if you want more information from him then pressure him until he does & u can re-evaluate later

me = confused rick

UNVOTE: Klazam

VOTE: Sergtacos

Sergtacos I like your read on stay away I have a gf. Read his iso after you pointed out why you scumread him and at this point I agree with you.

VOTE: stay away I have a gf

I kinda have Stay away as Town rn
Nothing strong but his posts feel off the cuff

[Gamma Emerald]

tchill I get the gut feels ur town if ur town hold out with me and sheep my vote thx

How is Tchill town to you? There is no explanation. If you're town, you would tell us how he's town so that we can try to see what you're seeing because frankly I can't see him as town right now, so please, do explain.

Because of this, I'm thinking the scum team so far is Tchill, Klazam, and stay awa I have a gf.

like if I have to explain every fucking single post of mine and repeat it to you again then im going to contract hypertension in the next few months

i said it was a gut read that he's town; look at some of his posts esp #348. Creative pushes on Tchill and he responds with a decent answer that is pretty logical, analytical and not manipulative. If this was scum!tchill I'd expect some kind of half-assed omgus or maybe a dry cut one liner that doesn't say much. Even 329 is pretty decent in and of itself so idgaf why you think tchill is scum

like tacos your reads have been all over the place in the last couple of pages; maybe try to consolidate some kind of hierarchy within your reads instead of trying to grasp at straws at the ppl you find scummy?

Well Sergtacos shit posted a lot in our last game. So the fact that mulch knows this, says he's gonna post a lot then also states he's gonna attack anyone who votes him seems nice. I get the idea that maybe, maybe mulch would take advantage of Sergtacos shit posting by engaging with him and mucking up the thread. This is really the only read I have so far on anyone. I don't think it's enough to create a wagon on. I'd rather see other slots before I try to push a realistic lynch on someone.

I think creatives statements are town motivated. He's getting himself some attention by trying to stir the pot and bring on conversation. I doubt scum would introduce themselves into the game the way he has.

and yes mulch is right I think this deserves a vote right now

VOTE: Keychain

What was the thing involving TChill here?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm having a little bit of trouble keeping up with the pace of the game.

I like what i'm seeing from Mulch,i don´t like what i'm seeing from Vedith.

Tchill questions have felt in general weak, and i don´t feel like he really cares about the answers.

Somehow i think the replacement for Geraldt has degraded my read on the slot. But will stick to my initial read on Gerald.

Can you explain, like,

all

of these?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm having a little bit of trouble keeping up with the pace of the game.

I like what i'm seeing from Mulch,i don´t like what i'm seeing from Vedith.

Tchill questions have felt in general weak, and i don´t feel like he really cares about the answers.

Somehow i think the replacement for Geraldt has degraded my read on the slot. But will stick to my initial read on Gerald.

Can you explain, like,

all

of these?

Well you are very different from gerald, you talk in absolutes, like when you said Sergtacos is town. Also his game analisis was much more emotional based, and i tend to associate moods with the slots, so when people get replaced it takes a while for me to register new way of reading a certain slot. I'm having a bit of trouble re-figuring out yours, so i will stick to my initial read on the previous player for now.

Tchill has interjected here and there, asked me some stuff. I felt like i gave some weak answers, was expecting him to come back at me for it, but i don´t think he cared about it. Maybe just my feeling but it just felt like he was trying to portrait to care instead of realing caring.

I think Mulch has invested himself in the game, and altough i think his emotions are jumping around like madness, and even though he has received some flak for it i think he stands by his reads even when others are attacking him. So i think this is towny.

While i don´t actually have anything inherently scummy on Vedith, everything he does seems self-centered and not going towards advancing any town meta, so that by itself is enough to generate my dislike.

Thanks. Seemed you were saying things with little backing so I wanted logic behind your reads.

[Gamma Emerald]

What

[Gamma Emerald]

ur a dum dum witcher

Why did you say this?

[Gamma Emerald]

What

What is your question?

Not really a question just what you said looks like it would go in scumchat

[Gamma Emerald]

tchill I get the gut feels ur town if ur town hold out with me and sheep my vote thx

How is Tchill town to you? There is no explanation. If you're town, you would tell us how he's town so that we can try to see what you're seeing because frankly I can't see him as town right now, so please, do explain.

Because of this, I'm thinking the scum team so far is Tchill, Klazam, and stay awa I have a gf.

like if I have to explain every fucking single post of mine and repeat it to you again then im going to contract hypertension in the next few months

i said it was a gut read that he's town; look at some of his posts esp #348. Creative pushes on Tchill and he responds with a decent answer that is pretty logical, analytical and not manipulative. If this was scum!tchill I'd expect some kind of half-assed omgus or maybe a dry cut one liner that doesn't say much. Even 329 is pretty decent in and of itself so idgaf why you think tchill is scum

like tacos your reads have been all over the place in the last couple of pages; maybe try to consolidate some kind of hierarchy within your reads instead of trying to grasp at straws at the ppl you find scummy?

Well Sergtacos shit posted a lot in our last game. So the fact that mulch knows this, says he's gonna post a lot then also states he's gonna attack anyone who votes him seems nice. I get the idea that maybe, maybe mulch would take advantage of Sergtacos shit posting by engaging with him and mucking up the thread. This is really the only read I have so far on anyone. I don't think it's enough to create a wagon on. I'd rather see other slots before I try to push a realistic lynch on someone.

I think creatives statements are town motivated. He's getting himself some attention by trying to stir the pot and bring on conversation. I doubt scum would introduce themselves into the game the way he has.

and yes mulch is right I think this deserves a vote right now

VOTE: Keychain

What was the thing involving TChill here?

SAIHAGF please answer

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay
Yeah I like stay away

[Gamma Emerald]

hey @gamma, what do you currently think about vedith and his flip-floppy stances currently

Could be scum
He seems to be like "you are asking me questions I'm gonna be a tool bag"

[Gamma Emerald]

Where are you up to on your catch up gam gams?

I'd say 1/3 through
Got some solid reads on a couple people. Like, if it's a strong townread I have faith in it. Scumreads are a little more unsure.

[Gamma Emerald]

FYI my most confident townreads are DV and TChill
Serg a little less so but still high
Creative and stay away are middling townreads
Mulch is eh. I townread his entrance but recent posts have not impressed
That's everyone who's hit my towndar

[Gamma Emerald]

I only try to use meta as a "this is just what they do" check, not to form a whole read

[Gamma Emerald]

No
I would bet the game on Deavail being town

[Gamma Emerald]

Any final input?

[Gamma Emerald]

tchill I get the gut feels ur town if ur town hold out with me and sheep my vote thx

that's bcs im patient with people not with blockheads

tacos trying to advocate my lynch in the shittiest way possible

by associatives on day one

yeah man ur such a good a player

There's not enough information to go by with Klazam. I still need more.

if you want more information from him then pressure him until he does & u can re-evaluate later

me = confused rick

UNVOTE: Klazam

VOTE: Sergtacos

Sergtacos I like your read on stay away I have a gf. Read his iso after you pointed out why you scumread him and at this point I agree with you.

VOTE: stay away I have a gf

Why did you call sergtacos out but you didn't say anything about me? I'm voting you for the same reason. The fact that you only had 3ish votes and showed a lot of frustration doesn't help your case.

Because if you two are scum, thats why. Scum buddies.

Me no like this
Is this an actual accusation

[Gamma Emerald]

What benefit would that give us if we were both scum and I pointed that out? You're looking into this with a biased perspective that I'm scum. At this moment I believe SAIHGF is the scummiest slot in the game. Why do you want to imply I'm scum?

Bussing, thats why. But hey, I could be wrong though. I believe SAIHAG is the most scummy here right now but you're on lean scum to me.

Well you're wrong on TChill so \_O_/

[Gamma Emerald]

1) As scum I would be powerwolfing your asses, just ask Boonskiies

2) The activity is cause day 1 is useless anyway and I haven't had time/willpower to put in effort

The term is powertown, and while you did it before I think you have a limited time for that run of luck.

[Gamma Emerald]

While we're on that page DV's reads are pretty good

[Gamma Emerald]

like if you actually want to push my wagon maybe compile some reasons as to why im scum

instead of saying shitty statements like "you don't react well to a push"

I like

[Gamma Emerald]

Like I really hate day 1's

This is getting old. Can you stop saying this, we get it.

[Gamma Emerald]

Vote Count 1.09

Stay away i have a gf [2]:

Geralt of Rivia, Assemblewotrs

Klazam [2]:

Keyser Söze, Fykus

Sergtacos [1]:

Keychain,

Keychain [1]:

stay away i have a gf

Geralt of Rivia [1]:

Mulch

Fykus [1]:

Klazam

Not Voting [5]:

Maestro, Creative, DeasVail, Sergtacos, Tchill13,

With

13

alive, it takes

7

to lynch.

Deadline ends in (expired on 2017-07-11 13:30:00) on

July 9th.

Mod Notes:

Keychain has asked to be replaced. Searching for a replacement.

You know I don't think any wagons really got traction
Probably means scum are active lurking or something. I feel if there were more Town presence there'd be more drive in the game.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Mulch
Not caught up but feel good about this lead rn
Started by DV I see, interesting

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd rather not have that yet
I catch up better when I can quote posts, respond, and have that as a reminder of where I was

[Gamma Emerald]

Is that because he's your buddy?
Don't think I forgot you Klascum.

[Gamma Emerald]

I aint scum here.

Thing is, way he played early on, feels town to me.

Same here but he was fairly towny early on in the game I played as his scumbuddy

[Gamma Emerald]

the people who i earlyread as town is just ugh in this game. One majorly tunneled someone else who im reading as town, one is all over the place, and one ISNT EVEN HERE to play. thats just bullshit.

Who is who

[Gamma Emerald]

Got it

[Gamma Emerald]

Please no
That hurts my catch up

[Gamma Emerald]

UNVOTE:
Didn't wanna have to but I'd rather unvote than catch up overnight tbh

[Gamma Emerald]

You got reactions anyway from me and Klazam

[Gamma Emerald]

Good point
I remember someone talking about scum reacting to death a certain way that Town just don't do

[Gamma Emerald]

So I just isoed gamma over the fact he jumped on the mulch wagon when I mentioned I might vote him. It was a very weak statement from me mainly just to see what would happen. I have no intention of lynching mulch day 1 as I've already stated and I was very surprised there was little to no back lash on my last post. Gamma why did you vote mulch when it seems pretty clear to me you've got more reasons to vote klazam and you actually town read mulch early on? At what point did mulch pass klazam as a scum read for you? I feel pretty good about klazam being town because of how he reacted.

I didn't notice you said that
Klazam has less of a chance than Mulch today I think

[Gamma Emerald]

Also I've had Klazam as scum because his posts just don't sit well with me

[Gamma Emerald]

Btw can someone get me a face palming Picard avatar

[Gamma Emerald]

Less chance of getting lynched
Look at the vote count

[Gamma Emerald]

Not enough experience with you, mulch.

And I'm actually getting opposite vibes from that post. Taco knows his town meta. But again overthinking and shit.

Guessing I'd say town but I won't like it.

Interesting. Klazam you are feeling much different than last game, but not neccecarily in a scumm way.

*goes silent*

No random bullshit to fire back at me?

This with the fact he was scumreading Klazam early makes me think they're scum who decided to flip off the bus switch here
I like this

[Gamma Emerald]

Not enough experience with you, mulch.

And I'm actually getting opposite vibes from that post. Taco knows his town meta. But again overthinking and shit.

Guessing I'd say town but I won't like it.

Interesting. Klazam you are feeling much different than last game, but not neccecarily in a scumm way.

*goes silent*

No random bullshit to fire back at me?

I like this

This with the fact he was scumreading Klazam early makes me think they're scum who decided to flip off the bus switch here

oops

[Gamma Emerald]

The thing that's pinging me up to 233 is that Fykus has barely posted, which is hugly similar to his game last game on meta, and deasavil has responded to him a lot but basically not needecly, almost as if the response is forced.


HUGE deasavil+fykkus scum team potential right now

This association is crap
Thinking Fykus is town since DV is a hard townread and I'd think Mulch would push his buddy first to give credibility to the association.

[Gamma Emerald]

Alias: Creative
Status: Thread Debut

Strenghts: Good at analyzing human behaviour and unbiased thinking.
Goal: To find the mafia and unite the town.

Hi, I'm in.

I LIKE THIS

WHY!

[Gamma Emerald]

Sounds pretty far fetched.
In the other hand, Mulch posts are much less elaborated and with a more fillery nature.
Sergtacos posts sounds more like he is excited to be in the game, might be an emulation, but that is the general vibe i'm receiving.

Even though this read is wrong, I'm hugely feeling this

Are you fucking Shulk now? Be clearer! What does "feeling this" mean?

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: klazam

tacos lets make a town bloc together

This is blatant scum claiming buddying

badbadbad
Possibility Serg might be Mulch's partner? I think he's one to throw a buddy into his scumreads.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Geralt of Rivia

That was dirty.

Or are you his scum partner coming to his defense?

I like this as laughable as it is

Might be Town
He originally voted Gerald for this so maybe this is him realizing " I can see how this conclusion was reached".

[Gamma Emerald]

If anyone disagrees with any of my reads or my townyness right now say now.

I will convince you.

Don't really care to be convinced but why the hell are you so hell bent on DV!scum?
Also why aren't you willing to bend to anyone else?

[Gamma Emerald]

No particular order read list.

TOWN
Maestro
Creative
SergTacos
Tchill13

NULL
Keychain
Assemblerotws
Deasvail
stay away I have a gf
Keyser Söze

SCUM
Geralt of Rivia
Klazam
Mulch

Mulch def scum, klazam scum or pocketed by mulch, not sure which. tchill def town. tacos had a good post somewhere.

Why are SAIHAG and DV null?

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Fykus

His tone in this game sounds like "what a drag, I'm scum again" idk, maybe thats just me? Mulch, Tchill, Klazam, your opinion?

This isn't right at all

[Gamma Emerald]

Like that wolfy as fuck asking 3 people with questions isn't even scummy it's just something I notice EVERY scum does and they ALWAYS include one scum partner as well.

Like at surface level it's not scummy but I just know it IS

So some bullshit tell
I see where my olde buddy Skold got his philosophy from.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Mulch is strong town now.

why

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Mulch is strong town now.

Why exactly?

Because he simply said he isn't scum.

That's not a towntell!

[Gamma Emerald]

Both, I had never seen anyone do that before, and wanted to get some type of pressure early

I'll ask my other question again, what type of weird? Is it just "oh, I've never seen this before", or does it pertain to the game in any way?

And @Twoface,
Is that a strike... For what? For pressure, or is that a "this is scummy" strike? Do you have legitimate suspicion on Mulch?

And good morning @Sergtacos!
Why RVS when you can get started now?

(also, I'm extremely active, it's summer and I've got nothing to do all day)

Carically second post

Oh great anecdotal evidence: "it happened once so it's a thing totally".

[Gamma Emerald]

Ur overthink this

I just want the hammer lol

Last person who asked for hammers in a game I played was scum.
See? Same as your 3 person tell on DV: total bullshit.
I personally find your actions indicative of scum who wanted to look careful but got called out and is struggling to explain.

[Gamma Emerald]

No!!!!!!!!

I'm officially telling you to stop this. It was cute early. Now it's obnoxious.

[Gamma Emerald]

The reason I'm not friendly is because I'm in a bad mood right now, and I want my reads to be taken seriously this game.

But our last game you weren't that concerned of having your reads taken seriously, why this game?

Cause I have a lock wolf

You know you bounce the word "lock" around with a 90% read and it feels so fake, like you want that escape route for later.

[Gamma Emerald]

The closer he gets to the lynch the less he tries to stop his own lynch. If he's town he's just advocating a mislynch with his lack of effort

Frustrated town with that claim. That's how I see it.

TBH that's the feeling I got too

[Gamma Emerald]

Think I'll stop for tonight

[Gamma Emerald]

Thats how u catch up, 57 pages like its nothing.

Reads reads reads:

Town:

Vecna
Mulch
Sergtacos

(yes, tacos and mulch are both town and need to stop the dickswinging contest)

Stay Away from my girlfriend

Probably town, but less certain than above group:

Gamma

(but really really only because of the way Geralt replaced out, Gamma's play himself feels very scummy so far and im probably putting too much weight on the cop claim)

Fykus

Scumpool:

Maestro
Creative
Vedith
Klazam
Maestro
Tchill
DeasVail

Most strong scumread:

Keyser Soze

VOTE: Keyser Soze

Some explenations;
Gamma feels really weird. His replace in is done in the exact same way as he did it in EverHope - where he just quotes a buch of posts as well and replies to them very briefly, and in a very detached way. I did my catchup at nearly the same time as he did. Nothing of the vibes he gives of sound familair. Nowhere did I go "oh yeah, I felt the same way about this as he did!". It feels fake. If it wasnt for the way Geralt responded to the cop claim id be all over this and trying to push for a lynch here.....but the response to the vig seemed to genuine, so im gonna have to sit on this for a while longer and think about it.

Klazam feels reasonably different from the last game I had with him. He was an easy read there, that is an easy TOWNread. Here I cannot do the same, he feels far away, like hes playing through the mist. Silly gorrila you.

Mulch, Serge, SAFMGF (dude couldnt you have picked a shorter name?) and to a lesser extent Fykus all felt pretty genuine while catching up. They all made statements that I felt I could get behind, or where I could recognise the reasoning. Not that I agreed with everything they stated, but most of it felt like it came from a good place. Klazam did have a few of these lightbulb-moments as well, but not as many.

Vedith Vedith. Why so aggresive this game? I didnt like Keychain, and I dont like your play so far. Suspicion. I have it for you, in abundance.

Tchill and DeasVail both feel like theyre not pushing an agenda. Not passionately at least, and it doesnt feel like theyre trying to figure things out.

Keyser Soze is basically a worse version of the 2 above. He just appears to be trying to say things that he think will sound good. There is no "soul" to his play. There is no emotion. He doesnt appear to be figuring things out, hes not prodding, he's not passionate about anything. Its just carefull calculation, meant to sound good without drawing any attention to himself so he can stay under the radar for now. This slot is scum, Im convinced of it.

How about you realize

it's how I catch up

. Also you're pinging my bullshit radar because I think I explained it to you in the past. Also, you say TChill and DV arent pushing agendas but have them in your scumpool at the same level as the others?

[Gamma Emerald]

No!!!!!!!!

I'm officially telling you to stop this. It was cute early. Now it's obnoxious.

'

No!!!!!!!!

Please
For my sanity

[Gamma Emerald]

Mug? What's a mug?

[Gamma Emerald]

Vecna seems pretty town to me.

BULLSHIT they are saying I'm obvious town and that your scum and your voting me

So? People can be wrong.

[Gamma Emerald]

Umm I really don't care if you lock me into a top town read. The only thing I care about is getting pressure on fykus, gamma and vecna. Fykus being my main scumread.

Those are your top scumreads? That feels odd, any assiatives or just individual? What makes you think so?

[Gamma Emerald]

What are they based on?

[Gamma Emerald]

We call our your post
You say ffs
What are you saying ffs about?

[Gamma Emerald]

Will you respond to my point then?

[Gamma Emerald]

That just because reads are bad doesn't mean you can't townread someone

[Gamma Emerald]

So why were you like "bullshit" at DV tring Vecna?

[Gamma Emerald]

The ditto tell huh? Interesting.

[Gamma Emerald]

Mulch doesn't scumread me

[Gamma Emerald]

Fykus scum confirms Deasvil scum, but Deasvil has a higher chance of being scum

And your vote is on Creative
VOTE: Mulch
This is L-2

[Gamma Emerald]

If you want to survive/"get scum", vote Fykas, your rival wagon (the player you are hard scum reading).

I'm not hard scum reading him, but he is around my third choice. I really don't feel like self preserving, but I will if neccecary. I'm gonna wait this out and se eif people can reinvent ways to scumread me without accusing me of self preservation.

Later in the day I will vote him if we can't get a deasvil or massive wagons

Massive?

[Gamma Emerald]

@Tchill it's almost completely composed of paranoia because I am towny as scum.

This is misrep. My vote is because your pushes feel scum motivated.

[Gamma Emerald]

No excusable way? So you think I'm scum?
Also who the fuck is this massive you speak of?

[Gamma Emerald]

Then how can there be no excusable way for me to think your pushes are scum motivated if it comes from a Town perspective?

[Gamma Emerald]

Dude
You act like I should magically know how to read you for some reason
And yet you used this same bullshit of "you should be reading me right" in Creature's game
How about you play towny instead of thinking I'll just get it if you're Town

[Gamma Emerald]

Tone? That doesn't mean jack shit. I'm reading motive here, not tone.

[Gamma Emerald]

Well I see DV as obvtown so I believe you're trying to lynch an obvtown to get rid of it

[Gamma Emerald]

His posts don't have any feel of deception

[Gamma Emerald]

My thought is they saw how towny they were and hoped they could strongarm the lynch without anyone calling bullshit

[Gamma Emerald]

LOL
Mulch just saying "keep defending me" is major scumpoints

[Gamma Emerald]

Dude
I also said there was more chance of lynching mulch from the current wagons
Do you want me to push a vanity wagon with deadline looming? We had like 4 days then iirc
Also I believe scum and Town treat people defending them differently. When I was in my first game and Infinity 324 defended me I was like "dude I got this". This doesn't feel a Town reaction to someone else defending since I've been in Mulch's shoes.

[Gamma Emerald]

Can we CFD creative

What is a cfd

[Gamma Emerald]

You're a scum lean for me. I don't agree with your reasoning for voting mulch. You came up with a very weak case after having to settle for mulch and not klazam when there's a good case to be made for his interaction with vedith. That's my issue with your vote on mulch. So is Fykus a town lean for you? If you believe dv is obv town I have no clue what your reads are on people.

Fykus is a townread

[Gamma Emerald]

CFD=chinese fire drill.


It means switch all votes to him

What about maestro?

Actually gamma is the way to go

VOTE: gamma

That's not happening.

[Gamma Emerald]

1) I'm widely townread
2) Deadline is close and I'm without a wagon.

[Gamma Emerald]

He says he scumreads me Vecna and you iirc

[Gamma Emerald]

Please pay attention to replacements dude
Tbh this change of course feels like it comes from town

[Gamma Emerald]

It mainly seems based on pocketing you
Anything relevant to us?

[Gamma Emerald]

Like there's the faked stances but I'm not sure about that

[Gamma Emerald]

Why are you asking that? Youre already voting Mulch. Wanting to jump off your buddy?

[Gamma Emerald]

Go on.

[Gamma Emerald]

I fucking swear
I hate you. Take the damn game seriously.

[Gamma Emerald]

So serious because there's no chance of me being lynched so voting me is just wasting your vote

[Gamma Emerald]

I s2g scum better fucking kill me night 1 so I don't have to deal with this shit

[Gamma Emerald]

say no more, you convinced me.

VOTE: Creative

Convinced by what
Quote the post

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh my fuck
GG scum. You've already won since this town is brain dead.

[Gamma Emerald]

Tbh Creative shows a level of insight I wouldn't expect from scum

[Gamma Emerald]

lmao so true

Yeahthis guys scum. He's completely walked back his townread on me after Serg said he'd go for me. TChill THIS is scum tagging along another's push.

[Gamma Emerald]

No excusable way? So you think I'm scum?
Also who the fuck is this massive you speak of?

It's not massive, it's creative.

And I don't think yur scum

Lynch Mulch

[Gamma Emerald]

No
I'm not letting you walk away from turning around on me because you couldn't bully me into doing the lynch you wanted.

[Gamma Emerald]

Deadline ends in (expired on 2017-07-11 13:30:00) on

July 9th.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd guess the counter is right

[Gamma Emerald]

One second
It's meme time

[Gamma Emerald]

Spoiler: Related images

did you think your actions lacked consequences? you cannot simply state you were joking when you said you wanted to lynch me and brush it under the carpet.
PS why the fuck doesn't Comic Sans work right

[Gamma Emerald]

That was to Mulch

[Gamma Emerald]

Klazam Wake up and smell the coffee
Vote Mulch

[Gamma Emerald]

Gamma too stubborn to actual find mafia and is throwing the game out of pride


GLGL town

Throwing the game
This ain't LyLo you twit

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: mulch

Scumclaim

[Gamma Emerald]

YOOO
I am like so fucking psyched
First I get easy game easy money win in another game now I got scum to selfhammer near DL
I guess I'll post final reads if I can

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah but we had plenty already today. Cutting us off now did nothing \_O_/

[Gamma Emerald]

Gonna take a stab at reading Vedith.
Town. His ISO looks genuine.

[Gamma Emerald]

Maestro what are your reads at?

[Gamma Emerald]

Reads:
DV and TChill top town
Vedith Serg SAIHAGF Fykus townreads
Maestro tbd
Keyser Klazam scumreads

[Gamma Emerald]

Maestro what are your reads at?

Who do you care about and I'll do ISOs before Boon gets in with ther VC / fliper

I'd say Keyser Fykus and Creative are good

[Gamma Emerald]

Btw
Creative goes in townreads for my read list

[Gamma Emerald]

UGH NOW MY FUCKING PEDIT ISN"T EVEN FOWKRING

PEDIT: oh but it will work for the shitposter, ok

Lol ninja'd

[Gamma Emerald]

Ha I love you Maestro
You can be Town

[Gamma Emerald]

Wow, Maestro is so naive, he's such an adorable derp
He doesn't realizes scum can lie

[Gamma Emerald]

Probably Klazam and Keyser. DV is practically conftown now btw. Mulch's reaching to scumread that slot make that so.

[Gamma Emerald]

naive

like, REALLY BOI

fuckign really

I didn't join last year

like somepeople in this thread

And yet you act like Mulch is doing some cardinal sin with his twilight posts.

[Gamma Emerald]

That's actually pretty funny. Might be a Kodak Moment.

[Gamma Emerald]

Kodak Moment is a Scummy category, awarded for memorable moments in games.

[Gamma Emerald]

Wow this is insane
I really don't think Maestro would be acting like this as scum why just had a buddy lynched

[Gamma Emerald]

Kodak Moment is a Scummy category, awarded for memorable moments in games.

WHy is this memorable?

Because you went from scum to town because you selfhammered

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok. News flash: I'm town.

I did this self hammer as a cold blooded calculated move to allow town to get a unique perspective in a twilight realm that can be used totally late game.

It's very useful claiming I was scum, because scum literally KNOW I am town and still have to act like I am scum anyway, which is really interesting.

Maestro's reactions to this are extraodinarily fake and he should be scumread heavily for this. Klazam and Tchill and Fykus are near confirmed town because of it. Gamma's reactions are good as well.

Okay
Yeah looking back Maestro does seem very fake
Also DV isn't conftown now ;-;

[Gamma Emerald]

I mean it's not the worst case
We just need to correct course going forward

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah. I recall having this same fake outrage in my first scumgame when keyenpeydee selfhammered. Maestro is scum.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah. I recall having this same fake outrage in my first scumgame when keyenpeydee selfhammered. Maestro is scum.

I know M. Its not fake outrage here.

Then tell me how.

[Gamma Emerald]

Tchill and Fykus and Klazam should NEVER BE LYNCHED


If they are lynched town committed a cardinal sin

I agree with all but Klazam, tell me how with him.

[Gamma Emerald]

I know how he talks when hes actually pissed here. it lines up here.

Do you think he could fake that?

[Gamma Emerald]

Not advised but not a lost cause
Plus he's right, it's good for reactions. Tbh I should check something else real quick.

[Gamma Emerald]

Alright
Read everything now
Not much of importance in what I hadn't read
P much at the same spot in my reads

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay then
No result on Creative. That plus the kill on Keyser of all people likely means the mafia are blocking me while doc hunting. Or Creative is just mafia, but I don't think that's the case.
As for "why Creative", I wanted a chance to clear him since I foresaw a bullshit push on him.

[Gamma Emerald]

You say he obvtowned but are voting him?

[Gamma Emerald]

Also it would make sense mafia are doc hunting

[Gamma Emerald]

That push on me by Tacos looks so scripted
VOTE: Tacos

[Gamma Emerald]

That push on me by Tacos looks so scripted
VOTE: Tacos

explain scripted

Means he planned it - specifically over night 1.

[Gamma Emerald]

Both of our wagons were on town

how do you know the fykus wagon was on town?

mulch got lynched because he's the stronger town asset

WHAT. MULCH IS A BAD PLAYER MY GOD. THERE IS A REASON WHY HE WAS NEVER NIGHTKILLED AS FREAKING CONFIRMED TOWN IN 1919

Wait, Tchill scumslipped?!

No??? Opportunistic much? Fairly certain it was just a "well shit" response after Mulch said Fykus was Town

[Gamma Emerald]

And yet you concluded as such later

[Gamma Emerald]

Thought you did, must have been someone else

[Gamma Emerald]

reading more posts, I think you scum slipped and dude like i said before your posts seem so fucking scummy to me

Taco you say here that he scumslipped, explain why you're denying it

Fack
That's where he said it
I just skimmed and missed it when trying to find it

[Gamma Emerald]

Why Fykus over Serg? And do you think they could be buddies?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm pretty sure its between fykus and sergtacos, either one sounds fine for me.

But im going back to the one that should be lynched d1

VOTE: Fykus

Today's lynch should either be creative or Sergtacos.

Why those two only?

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay

[Gamma Emerald]

TChill I think you're engaging in selective hearing
DV thinks Creative is TOWN

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm gonna die of laughter if mulch flips town.

Hm
Actually this might be a scum post
I've made a post almost exactly like this as scum in the same scenario

[Gamma Emerald]

How the game currently feels to me, even though im not very involved and cant find myself caring a great deal (mainly because everyone seems to feel totally different about things than I do):
1 scum in Creative vs Maestro
1 scum in Tchil vs Gamma emerald vs Fykus
1 scum being Vedith.

Starting to feel slightly better about DV over time.

Gamma Emerald is still probably town, but its still possible that Witcher-guy just overreacted because he really did think he was being shot, so just panic-claimed the strongest PR. Im surprised not more people have been wondering about a cop-claim surviving the night, but just claiming a roleblock instead. Its ofcourse totally possible mafia would want us to doubt him and lynch him, or are afraid of a potential doctor being out there.....but why havent they made a move yet to try and raise suspicion about Gamma Emerald? (or did I miss it?).

Sergtacos seems like very obvious town to me. He might play like a tool, but that doesnt mean like he's scum. Most of his play seems very genuine so far. Still not getting the scumreads here, same as I didnt understand at all how people could scumread Mulch.

Still clueless about Fykus, could be scum, could be town. Slot hasnt done anything to push me one way or the other.

Serg pushed me
I think Creative did a bit too

[Gamma Emerald]

reading more posts, I think you scum slipped and dude like i said before your posts seem so fucking scummy to me

Taco you say here that he scumslipped, explain why you're denying it

Key word= "Think" Which is why i asked, dur.

Still p shady that you pushed it in any capacity before making sure it was a slip

[Gamma Emerald]

The sergtacos wagon is uninteresting to me.

And serg, if you're choosing between Creative and Tchill, I reckon Creative is the more scummy of the two.

Vecna, why do you think that Vedith is the behaving the way he is as scum. Is it that you think he's just more stressed, or another reason?

Its just the way mafia affects the brain for a lot of people. You'll find a lot of players have a more agitated tone to their voice when they rolled mafia. Whether that is because theyre (sub)consiciously aware that everyone is out to get them or whatever....I dont know. But ive caught quite a lot of scum just by looking at the way they talk, and then comparing it to their towngames. It usually outs in the way how they adress people, and how they respond to claims, suggestions or accusations.

People very often ignore these reads of me though, but theyre accurate pretty often.

Might be right
Maybe I need to re-ISO Vedith
As Town he has a certain funny charm, and I think it could be missing here

[Gamma Emerald]

Actually Vedith is fucking disgusting here, and I don't really see his Town charm, so I might vote him

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm not really sold on him being scum. His analysis seems deep and doesn't seem to have intent to mislead.

[Gamma Emerald]

Actually Vedith is fucking disgusting here, and I don't really see his Town charm, so I might vote him

Explain this please.

I hate how Vedith treated my predecessor, and I don't think his posts are shining with the tone they have as Town.
Clear enough?

[Gamma Emerald]

You were a complete ass to him after he claimed

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't care. You made someone quit the site because you decided to be an asshole.

[Gamma Emerald]

How was he not progressing the game?

[Gamma Emerald]

Go ahead and throw shade if you wanna get lynched. I'm almost certainly town here. You even admitted this yourself.

[Gamma Emerald]

That's not my argument. It's that your posts lack the charm I've noticed in them when they come from town!you

[Gamma Emerald]

?

[Gamma Emerald]

No?
I didn't call you scum in Micro 666

[Gamma Emerald]

I think I didn't do that in UpickinFreezer either
Like, if you were a scumread that game it was due to PoE. By content, you'd probably have been Town to me that game but I'm not sure.

[Gamma Emerald]

Whatever. I've made my call. You're not trying to help me here, you're just saying "Wrong!"
VOTE: Vedith

[Gamma Emerald]

Ohmygosh IT'S A TITUS!
Hi

[Gamma Emerald]

You know what that makes sense. Ugh, I just feel like Jon Snow - I know NOTHING.
Can someone else also case Creative? That one looks alright but I'm not voting there yet without a decent amount of coverage.

[Gamma Emerald]

Wait
I'm gonna have to brief Titus on the game state, FUCK

[Gamma Emerald]

Here's an overview of the gamestate.
Day 1 we lynched Mulch. I didn't like who he was pushing, can't really speak for anyone else. Mulch selfhammered and claimed mafia for a bit to throw everyone off their feet, revealing their true colors. Maestro probably came out the worst, shouting about the way the move was horrible for "both teams". Looking at that now I see the "both teams" thing probably comes from scum trying way too hard to look uninformed. Night 1 I, the loyal cop, investigated Creative and got a No Result. It could be a guilty or a product of some other role. Not going to worry about the specifics of that too much because that's basically a Reverse Fairy Godfather (Fairy Miller?). I initially decided it was the latter because I townread Creative at the time. But I feel some more recent actions make him a bit more suspect. So far I've covered two of our suspects: Maestro and Creative. Next is Sergtacos. Sergtacos feels like he came into Day 2 with an agenda to push me and Maestro as partners. Another suspect, though less focal, is Vedith. I feel his posts do not have the same charm they do as when he is town. Honestly, I adopted this tell from someone else who used it on him. Vecna has some more universal tell I can't recall right now.

So the likely lynches in order of how much I think they are supported are
Creative
Serg
Maestro/Vedith (both around the bottom)

So I'd suggest ISOing those 4 and getting reads on them.

[Gamma Emerald]

Ref for WHAT