Scummies 2009 Nominations

[Scummies]

Player Awards

• Body of Work
  • Best Mafia Catcher
    - "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award
    • roflcopter in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by Caboose
      
    • Caboose in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by roflcopter, seconded by Tenchi, thirded by PokerFace
      
    • Porkens in Mini 756 - nominated by Knight of Cydonia, seconded by Juls, thirded by Trumpet of Doom
      
    • OhGodMyLife in Silent Mafia 3 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by charter, thirded by Slicey, etc.
      
    • camn in Open 122 - nominated by VP Baltar, seconded by Kmd4390
      
    • Vi in Mafia 91 - nominated by Shanba. seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by alexhans, etc.
      
    • inHimshallibe in Mafia 95 - nominated by Xylthixlm.
      
    • Spolium in Newbie 705 - nominated by Santos
      
    • BloodCovenent in Mini 801 - nominated by AshMC1984, seconded by Empking, thirded by ortolan, etc.
      
    • ryan2754 in Mini 829 - nominated by DeathRowKitty, seconded by RedCoyote, thirded by alexhans, etc.
      
    • DTMaster for Battle Mafia - nominated by BloodCovenent.
      - nomination retracted by DTMaster
  • Most Cunning Manipulation
    - "The Don Corleone" Award
    • LlamaFluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by Claus, seconded by Mr. Flay, thirded by Kison, etc.
      
    • Wall-E in Open 100 - nominated by ThAdmiral
      
    • don_johnson in mini 737 - nominated by Rhinox, seconded by Spolium
      
    • Casey in Mini 740 - nominated by Juls, seconded by Budja
      
    • Zorblag in Newbie 749 - nominated by Mirth, seconded by Albert B. Rampage, thirded by Mitey Mouse, etc.
      - declined by Zorblag
      
    • Imaginality in Mini 779 - nominated by AshMC1984.
      
    • Vi in Mini 792 - nominated by Elmo, seconded by Zorblag.
      
    • ryan2754 in Mini 761 - nominated by Kise.
      
    • J-scope (Jahudo and KaleiÐoscøpe) in DHSDSM Alpha and in DHSDSM Beta- nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Adel, thirded by ortolan, etc.
      
    • Xylthixlm in Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Seraphim, etc
      
    • Khamisa in Open 154 - nominated by Kise.
      
    • Goatrevolt in Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by Faraday.
      
    • Mirth in Mini 699 - nominated by farside22
      
    • q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by DrippingGoofball
      
    • benmage in Battle Mafia - nominated by Vi, seconded by BloodCovenent, thirded by Maemuki, etc.
      
    • UncertainKitten in Mini 853 - nominated by malthusis, seconded by Tarhalindur, thirded by Boxman.
      
    • Thok in CT III - nominated by Papa Zito, seconded by CSL.
    
    
  • Most Outstanding New Player
    
    
    should have joined the site no later than ~Oct. 2008
    • VP Baltar in Newbie 696 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by Incognito, thirded by Stef, etc.
      
    • Gwynplaine in Newbie 707 - nominated by julienvonwolfe, seconded by Tenchi
      
    • Papa Zito in Newbie 762 - nominated by Mastin, seconded by sirdanilot, thirded by OhGodMyLife, etc.
      
    • Agar in Newbie 792 - nominated by Khelvaster, seconded by Indigo Heron, thirded by Wickedestjr, etc.
      
    • SerialClergyman in Mini 836 - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by Kison, thirded by Empking, etc.
      
    • Ojanen in /in-vitational 4 and Newbie 764 - nominated by SerialClergyman, seconded by charter, thirded by mith, etc.
      
    • Raskol in Newbie 818 - nominated by Debonair Danny DiPietro, seconded by Pomegranate, thirded by KittyMo.
      
    • ODDin in Newbie 845 - nominated by Zorblag, seconded by KittyMo.
  • Most Improved Player
    • Spyrex - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by VP Baltar
  • Best Replacement
    • ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by farside22, seconded by populartajo, thirded by LlamaFluff, etc.
      
    • Xylthixlm in Phables: Death Note Mafia - nominated by LlamaFluff.
      
    • Ether in Boost Mafia 2 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
      
    • Ether in Mini 728 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
    
    
  • Best IC
    • Thesp in Newbie 792 - nominated by Khelvaster, seconded by Indigo Heron, thirded by Wickedestjr, etc.
      
    • Incognito for Newbie 700, Newbie 775 and Newbie 798 - nominated by Haylen, seconded by nhammen, thirded by VP Baltar, etc.
  • Funniest Player
    - "The Coffee on the Monitor" Award
    • Jahudo for this post and this post - nominated by Pokerface, seconded by OhGodMyLife, thirded by shaft.ed
      
    • Raging Wishbone (Walt Wishbone and Raging Rabbit) - nominated by Pokerface.
      
    • Korlash - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by dramonic, thirded by Pokerface.
      
    • Spyrex - nominated by Slicey, seconded by Papa Zito, thirded by Faraday, etc.
      
    • PookyTheMagicalBear for this post - nominated by mith, seconded by charter, thirded by populartajo, etc.
      
    • VP Baltar - nominated by DrippingGoofball, seconded by Papa Zito, thirded by Zachrulez.
• Single Game/Thread/Post
  • Best Performance Pro-Town Team
    • The Town of Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Korts
      
    • The Town of Open 118 - nominated by Slicey
      Recinded by Slicey.
      
    • The Town of Mini 773 - nominated by afatchic, seconded by Kublai Khan.
    
    
  • Best Performance Scum Group
    • The Mafia of Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Stef
      
    • The Fallen Angels of War In Heaven II - nominated by shaft.ed
      
    • The Mafia of Mini 740 - nominated by Juls
      
    • The Mafia of Open 151 - nominated by Kise.
      
    • The Mafia of Open 154 - nominated by Kise.
      
    • The Mafia of Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by MichelSableheart, thirded by TDC, etc.
      
    • The Mafia of Mini 838 - nominated by dramonic, seconded by Chaco, thirded by EriktheRed
      
    • The Japanese Mafia of Mafia 86 - nominated by nhammen, seconded by animorpherv1
      
    • The Inquisitors in Mini 853. - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Boxman.
  • Best Performance Third Party
    • Xylthixlm in Phables: Death Note Mafia - nominated by LlamaFluff, seconded by Pokerface.
      
    • Sabrewolf for Large 99 - nominated by Empking, seconded by tubby216.
      
    • Haylen for Mini 851 - nominated by xofelf, seconded by J-Fox, thirded by KittyMo, etc.
      
    • Haylen for Mean Mod LoveFest - nominated by xofelf, seconded by J-Fox, thirded by KittyMo, etc.
      
    • The Outsiders of Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by Boxman, seconded by Tarhalindur.
      
    • Xylthixlm for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur. seconded by Boxman.
      
    • EtherealCookie in Perfectionist Mafia - nominated by Max.
  • Best Role Claim
    - "Johnny Cochrane" Award
    • Llamafluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by The Fonz, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by BlakAdder, etc.
      
    • mykonian in Mini 707 - nominated by q21, seconded by animorpherv1
      
    • q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Simenon, seconded by Adel, thirded by Giuseppe, etc
      
    • ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by PokerFace
      
    • Fishythefish in Mini 801 - nominated by AshMC1984, seconded by Kise.
      
    • ryan2754 in Mini 761 - nominated by Kise.
      
    • UncertainKitten in Mini 853 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Boxman, thirded by malthusis.
  • Funniest Role Claim
    - "George W Bush" Award
    • Xylthixlm in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Kairyuu, thirded by nhammen.
      
    • imaginality in Mini 733, nominated by Mirth, seconded by destructor
      
    • PookyTheMagicalBear in /in-vitational 4, nominated by mith, seconded by populartajo, thirded by Slicey.
  • Most Enjoyable Game
    • Adel for Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Raging Rabbit, seconded by Korts, thirded by destructor
      
    • Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo
      
    • Mr. Flay for War in Heaven II - nominated by populartajo, seconded by shaft.ed
      
    • OhGodMyLife for Medieval Mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur
      
    • Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
      
    • Kinetic for Wheel of Time Mafia: Rip in the Pattern - nominated by Sajin, seconded by Faraday.
      
    • The Players for /in-vitational 4 - nominated by mith, seconded by charter, thirded by SerialClergyman, etc.
      
    • forbiddanlight for MtG: Parallel Universe Mafia: Kamigawa - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
      
    • MafiaSSK for MtG:Parallel Universe Mafia: Weatherlight Saga - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
      
    • Tarhalindur for MtG: Parallel Universe Mafia: Time Spiral - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
      
    • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
      
    • Machiavellian-Mafia for Prisoner's Dilemma - nominated by The Central Scrutinizer
      
    • Jahudo for Mini 783 - nominated by Juls. seconded by Vi, thirded by PokerFace, etc.
      
    • Porkens for Mini 819 - nominated by Locke Lamora, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by SpyreX, etc.
      
    • PsychoSniper for Mini 807 - nominated by xRECKONERx, seconded by Starbuck.
      
    • millar13 for VENGEFUL 5 Version 2 - nominated by Drench, seconded by Empking, thirded by Stef, etc.
      
    • Newbie 830]Newbie 830 - nominated by CSL, seconded by Mr Flay.
      
    • Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.

Moderator Awards

• Best Setup
  • Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo, thirded by Stef, etc.
    
  • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
    
  • Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
    
  • Kinetic for Wheel of Time Mafia: Rip in the Pattern - nominated by Sajin, seconded by Faraday.
    
  • Saunt Adelaus (Adel and Claus) in DHSDSM Alpha - nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by Slicey.
    
  • Saunt Adelaus (Adel and Claus) in DHSDSM Beta - nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by Slicey.
    
  • Patrick for Mini 692 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
    
  • Patrick for Boost Mafia 2 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
    
  • Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients Mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.
• Best Role
  (new or adaptation) - "Flying Pumpkin That Shoots Lazers Out Of Its Ass" Award
  • Tarhalindur for Townie Speaker for the Dead - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by populartajo
    
  • OhGodMyLife for Charlemagne, Town Vehmgericht Master - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Slicey, thirded by Stef, etc.
    
  • SensFan for Mason-Neighbour - nominated by xofelf, seconded by hitogoroshi.
    
  • Vi for Mentor - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by Amished.
• Best Flavor Text
  - "Paperback Writer" Award
  • farside22 for Family Guy Mafia - nominated by pacman281292, seconded by Kmd4390
    
  • kloud1516 for Mini738 - nominated by Wizardcat
    
  • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
    
  • BridgesAndBaloons for Mini 714 - nominated by alexhans
    
  • Prof. Guppy for Mini 779 - nominated by AshMC1984
    
  • alexhans (co-mod) in Mini 791 - nominated by Mastin, seconded by Kairyuu
    
  • EmpTyger for Mini 793 - nominated by veerus, seconded by Furry, thirded by MafiaSSK, etc.
    
  • Porkens for Mini 819 - nominated by Locke Lamora, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by SpyreX, etc.
    
  • SensFan for Mini 788 - nominated by xofelf.
    
  • Korts for Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by Goatrevolt.
    
  • Korlash for Korlash Town - nominated by dramonic, seconded by Trumpet of Doom, thirded by yellowbunny.
    
  • mith for /in-vitational 4 - nominated by ekiM, seconded by Amished.
    
  • Haylen for Open 177 - nominated by SaintKerrigan, seconded by CSL, thirded by Maemuki.
• Best Mechanic/Mutation
  • Vi for Vi Pod's battery powered deadlines (also found in Border of Touhou and mafia) - nominated by Sotty7, seconded by dramonic, thirded by tubby216, etc.
    
  • Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.
    
  • KaleiÐoscøpe for Realistic Mafia II - nominated by animorpherv1
    
  • Yosarian2 for Lynch all Lurkers Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Mastin, thirded by hitogoroshi.
• "Smooth Operator"
  - for the "moderation" part of modding: vote counts, prodding, generally keeping the game running smoothly
  • Vi - nominated by Sotty7, seconded by dramonic, thirded by tubby, etc.

Site Awards

• Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wiki
  - "Professor Mafia" Award
  • JDodge, nominated by Mr. Flay
    
  • Lord Gurgi for this, nominated by PokerFace
    
  • Xylthixlm for this, nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by skitzer, etc.
    
  • Albert B. Rampage, nominated by Adel
    
  • Vi for this, nominated by Xylthxlm, seconded by Oman, thirded by VP Baltar
• Behind the Scenes
  - "Name Should Be In Orange" Award
  • Max, nominated by Empking
    
  • MeMe, nominated by Shanba, seconded by stef, thirded by Oman, etc.
    
  • Vel-Rahn Koon, nominated by Shanba, seconded by stef, thirded by Oman, etc.
    
  • Mr. Flay, nominated by Shanba
    
  • jeep, nominated by Shanba, seconded by animorpherv1
• MishMash Use
  r (Player or Mod or Both)
  • Cybele - nominated by animorpherv1.
• MishMash Game
• General Discussion Award
  • Quagmire - nominated by Sopianae

Accurate as of post 643.

[PokerFace]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 89#1434589

Re-issuing this nomination for 2009 should it not have been considered already for 2008

[OhGodMyLife]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 89#1434589

Re-issuing this nomination for 2009 should it not have been considered already for 2008

Second Jahudo

for funniest player.

[shaft.ed]

third

if I didn't over there.

[Max]

New Award

:

Best Contribution to Wiki

[Shanba]

Not sure that's necessary. I believe Mr. Flay already won the behind the scenes award for his contribution to the wiki.

[mith]

Yes, contribution to the wiki would fall under Behind the Scenes or Mafia Discussion, depending on what it was. I don't see the need for an additional award there (we get few enough nominations for those categories as it is).

[Empking]

I'd like to nominate Max for behind the scenes.

[Oman]

Examples or posts or stories?

[Empking]

He's done a lot ofcontributions (that I've seen) on the wiki.

[Oman]

Fair call, I'll take a look.

[Oman]

My only problem is that its so early in 2009, and there hasn't been anything stunning. If he did that constantly for a few months then yeah sure.

[Shanba]

Yes, contribution to the wiki would fall under Behind the Scenes or Mafia Discussion, depending on what it was. I don't see the need for an additional award there (we get few enough nominations for those categories as it is).

Hrm.

Well,

nominate MeMe

for the maintenance of the mini queues, which seems to be a monumental task, as she not only looks after modding signups, checks each mod has the requisite experience etc, she also handles signups of the games themselves, checking each player against their mini limit, checking when each game is finished and removing that game from all the necessary players, keeps on top of the mods, acts as the go to person when a mod has a difficult situation, locks and sorts all the finished games... and does it all quickly and efficiently

While we're at it,

nominate Vel Rahn Koon

for his work with the newbie queue and modding newbie games, too.

Nominate Mr. Flay

, again for his work on the wiki which he basically runs, and which is one of the major reasons that mafiascum is growing so quickly in prestige and, simply, in size. He even made that bot thing to clean the spam!

Finally,

nominate jeep

for all the obvious reasons.

[SensFan]

I don't think we should be nominating anyone for the year-long awards on January 26th. For all we know, every one of those people will flake on their duties in the next month.

(Not likely, I know.)

[Shanba]

I don't think we should be nominating anyone for the year-long awards on January 26th. For all we know, every one of those people will flake on their duties in the next month.

(Not likely, I know.)

Is there any issue with nominating them now and then removing them from the list if they flake? I did it now because I probably would have forgotten within a few days, and certainly would have forgotten towards the end of the year.

[Mr. Flay]

MeMe, JEEP, and I have all won BHS in the past, I believe. VRK is nominated for 2008?

I also think it's premature to nominate for it now, but if a nominee were to flake, I'm sure the Judges would correct it come judging time.

[Shanba]

MeMe, JEEP, and I have all won BHS in the past, I believe. VRK is nominated for 2008?

I also think it's premature to nominate for it now, but if a nominee were to flake, I'm sure the Judges would correct it come judging time.

Is there a rule that says no player can win the same award twice?

[Empking]

I don't think we should be nominating anyone for the year-long awards on January 26th. For all we know, every one of those people will flake on their duties in the next month.

(Not likely, I know.)

What difference would that make?

[Max]

My only problem is that its so early in 2009, and there hasn't been anything stunning. If he did that constantly for a few months then yeah sure.

I agree with this posts

[The Fonz]

Nominate: LlamaFluff

for best roleclaim for mafia 86.

[PokerFace]

Nominate: LlamaFluff

for best roleclaim for mafia 86.

Link?

<<Too lazy and tired right now to go searching that thread.

[Jahudo]

Nominate: LlamaFluff

for best roleclaim for mafia 86.

Seconded

since he had me convinced and he was able to play multiple factions against one another to his advantage.

This is the game PokerFace: viewtopic.php?t=9540

[PokerFace]

I knew which game it was I was more so wanting exact link to post with claim. I don't want to search the entire thread for the post/claim

[Jahudo]

I knew which game it was I was more so wanting exact link to post with claim. I don't want to search the entire thread for the post/claim

Ok here's the actual claim. At this point he knows there's a SK and says he checked EA (the real SK) and it didn't turn him vanilla. This could be explained by an unknown RB action night 1.

[Claus]

I'm not sure if best roleclaim is the best award for Llama. I'd go for the best player (scum) - his game was not just the roleclaim. He went from a lone mafioso against a large town, an opposite mafia of three and a BP-SK to win the game through good choice of nightkills, manipulation, and also the well defended roleclaim. One slip, and there were three groups able to NK him anytime for about 3 nights.

Nominate Llama Fluff for

Best Player (Scum)

for the same game.