Ack you just reminded me I forgot to go over some stuff in that post...In post 2399, Jaack wrote:@tool-did you have any thoughts on my participation in the growing suspicion of you?
I found your kind-of acceptance of Tyler's case suspicious too. That was actually part of why I found it so likely that Tyler was scum; what's the likelihood that the two town members of the {not clear} group would both turn around on me? Probably not high, and so I reasoned that either of you could be scum. I found Tyler more likely (and more alarming) for the reasons I listed in my last post.
But then your ultimate response wasn't to vote me or try to rally a wagon against me, it was to go back and do more research on Tyler, and to continue not thinking of xyzzy as a lynch option. Whereas xyzzy's response was to vote me.